Madima Profile picture
Sep 20, 2021 25 tweets 8 min read Read on X
RocoMamas is the top performer in the Spur Corporation stable in the last 2 years.

The RocoMamas brand seems to have fitted well in the Spurs Corporation stable.

Spur Corporation was bought two brands in 2015. Image
1) Spur bought a 51% interest in the RocoMamas Franchise Co, (owners of the trademark and related intellectual property of RocoMamas) in 2015.

Purchase consideration was determined as 5x RocoMamas’ EBITDA of the 3rd year following date of acquisition which ended on 28 Feb 2018. Image
The total purchase consideration actually paid over the three-year period was ~R59.2m determined as follows;

Initial payment of R2m,

Annual payment of R20.4m in the 1st year after the acquisition

R18.3m 2nd in the second year.

Final payment of R18.54m was paid in March 2018.
At acquisition of the 51% stake in RocoMamas, it only had 5 restaurants.

On 1 Apr 2017, the Spur Corporation acquired a further 19% interest in RocoMamas taking the Group’s equity interest in RocoMamas to 70%.

Purchase consideration for thd 19% was R14.04m and settled in cash.
From 5 restaurants in 2015, the Spur Corporation has made to increase the number of RocoMamas stores as at 31 Dec 2020 to;
69 in South Africa Africa
9 in the rest of Africa
4 India and Middle East
1 Australasia

The capital expenditure for this expansion was massive.
2) Spur bought Hussar Grill steakhouse chain for R35 million in cash.

Hussar Grill comprised six restaurants at the time of purchase.

3 of the restaurants were company-owned and 3 were
franchised outlets.

This gave the group exposure to an upmarket specialist steakhouse chain. Image
Spur Corporation has grown the Hussar Grill brand significantly since the 2015 acquisition when it had 6 stores.

Total Hussar Grill stores is 24
SA 22
Africa 1
Middle East 1.

The Hussar Grill outlets took a beating in 2020 due to the restriction on the sale of alcohol.
The worst performer year on year is Nikos Coalgrill Greek.

Spur Corporation acquired a 51% shareholding from the founding family members in 2018 with an option to acquire an additional 19% shareholding after three years. Image
Some fun fact.

Spur gets its beef patties from the same plant as Burger King South Africa.

The meat plant was wholly owned by Grand Parade Investments (GPI) and is called Grand Foods Meat Plant (GFMP).

GPI has a 9,1% effective interest in Spur.
Deal between GPI and ECP is going ahead with the absence of Grand Foods Meat Plant that will now be sold to a black owner for R23m.

ECP will spend R500m opening new stores, creating jobs.

ECP had agreed to create a 5% black empowerment stake within two years.
GPI paid R700m for the Burger King master franchise for the Republic of South Africa in 2012.

It is selling its entire 91,1% stake in Burger King SA to ECP and will capitalise loans to the firm amounting to a 4.7% stake leading to a total divestment of a 95.7% stake for ~R570m.
Taste Holdings bought the South African master licence agreement for Starbucks for R226m in 2015 for 25 years.

Taste was required to pay yearly royalties to Starbucks US of R2.5 million.

Taste had envisaged on establishing 12 to 15 outlets within the first 24 months. Image
Capital expenditure and pre-opening expenses for the first 12 to 15 stores were estimated at R108m.

Market opportunity was estimated at 150-200 outlets, at an estimated capital expenditure per store of R3m-R10m.

We all know they never got to that 150-200 outlets. Image
Taste Holdings later disposed of 13 Starbucks stores for a mere lousy R7m, which was ~R538k a store as well as the franchise master to Rand Capital Coffee.

The estimated cost of opening a Starbucks store in South Africa was around R3m-R10m at the time. Image
October 2015, Taste raised R226m via a rights offer of 75m new shares at R3 each. This was shortly after it acquired the South African master licence agreement for Starbucks for 25 years.

This was the start (or continuion) of the destruction of shareholders' wealth. Image
December 2017, it (Taste) did other capital raising and raised ~R398m by issuing 442 million shares at 90c.

That rights offer came just 6 months after a “claw-back offer” in June 2017 in which Taste Holdings had raised R120m by issuing 80 million new shares at R1.50 each.
Inclusive of debt and share multiple rights issues, Taste management raised and squandered R1.4bn to keep Starbucks afloat.

The wealth destroyed over that period is one for the history books. ImageImage
Another blunder was when Taste Holdings bought and liquidated Domino’s SA after struggling to find a buyer.

Taste’s paid ~R6m for 15 stores with a negative net asset value of R10.25m and which made a loss after tax of R8.02m in the year ended 29 Feb 2016. Image
Taste bought 60% of the ordinary shares in issue and 100% of the claims held by Fiamme Pizza in Aloysius Trading.

The then CEO of Taste, Carlo Gonzaga, was a director and shareholder of Aloysius through his shareholding in Fiamme Pizza. Image
The total purchase consideration was R6 000 320 which was made up as follows;

R120 for the 120 shares in Aloysius

R6 000 000 for the claims in
Aloysius and

R200 for the subscription of 200 Aloysius shares.
Taste decided to place Taste Food Franchising (owned and licensed the Domino’s business in South Africa), Taste Commissary and Taste Food Trading into voluntary liquidation.

Taste then fully impaired the remaining intercompany loans with TFF and TC to the value of R450m. Image
Taste management estimated that it would require ~R700m, including amount raised in the prior rights offers, to reach positive free cash flow and that the Starbucks network will need to expand to between 150 and 200 cafés and Domino’s to between 220 and 280 restaurants. Image
Taste then went and sold their entire food brands, comprising of; Starbucks, Domino’s Pizza, Maxi’s and The Fish & Chips Co in order to focus on "luxury" brands such as Arthur Kaplan & World’s Finest Watches (NWJ).

This let to a rebrand from Taste Holdings to Lux Holdings. Image
Spurs first listed on the JSE in 1986.

A restructuring of the group in 1999 resulted in the formation of the Spur Corporation.

Spur Corporation's fingers have also been burnt in acquisitions.

It introduced a drive thru service this year.

Comparison of Famous Brands (FB) and Spur Corporation is unfair at times.😂

FB has 2 436 restaurants in SA alone and had a turnover of ~R4,7bn for year ended 28 Feb 2021 (a 35% ⬇️ YoY)

Famous Brand's FY2021 revenue is ~5x the market cap of Spur.

Spur Corp has ~633 restaurants. Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Madima

Madima Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @MaanoMadima

Mar 21
It is reported that the “greatest CA(SA)”, Markus Jooste, SAICA has ever produced, shot and killed himself when police came to arrest him today.

Let’s look at how Steinhoff (Markus Jooste) got its hands on Pepkor (92.34%), Tekkie Town (100%) and (almost) Shoprite.

[Thread]
Before going too far, it is important to note that there is an allegation that most of the deals Steinhoff (Markus Jooste) entered into were based on false and misleading representations made by Steinhoff N.V. and Markus Jooste.
The PwC Report into Steinhoff quantified the fictitious and/or irregular transactions at €6.5bn (R106bn) for FY09 - FY17.

The above 'fictitious and irregular transactions' had ''the effect of inflating the profits and/or asset values of the Steinhoff Group".
Image
Image
Read 22 tweets
Feb 16
A recap of Vodacom’s formation.

Vodacom was incorporated in 1993 as a joint venture between Telkom (50%), Vodafone (35%) and VenFin (15%).

1993, Vodacom was awarded a mobile cellular telecoms licence in SA and launched commercial services in 1994.

[Thread] Image
1996, Vodafone and VenFin sold a 5% stake in Vodacom Group to a BEE company, Hosken Consolidated Investments for R118 million.

2002, Hosken made a killing when it sold the 5% stake back to Vodafone and VenFin for R1.5 billion. Image
VenFin (then venture capital subsidiary of Rembrandt) looked around and realised that there is money to be made here.

2006, VenFin wanted out of the joint venture. Telkom didn't put up a fight. Vodafone had a clear landing strip.

Vodafone bought Venfin’s 15% stake for ~R16bn.
Read 7 tweets
Nov 15, 2023
Ever wondered who’s Astron Energy?

All Caltex-branded service stations in SA and Botswana are being rebranded into Astron Energy.

The name change follows a 2018 majority acquisition of former Chevron SA by Glencore SA Oil Investments.

Short [Thread] Image
Astron Energy, a Glencore group company, is a leading supplier of petroleum products in Southern Africa, with a vast network of service stations and is the second-largest petroleum network in the region.
Why the name change?

The name change follows the 2018 majority acquisition of the former Chevron South Africa Pty (Ltd) by Glencore South Africa Oil Investments (Pty) Ltd, since which time Astron Energy has been operating the Caltex brand under a licence agreement for $973m.
Read 5 tweets
Sep 28, 2023
The history of Kagiso Tiso Holdings is a long and complex one, so bare with me.

Standard Bank, Investec, Rand Merchant Bank, and the Liberty Group provided the seed capital to form Tiso Group which later became Kagiso Tiso Group.

[Thread]
In 1985, the Kagiso Trust began its development work to help promote the struggle against apartheid.

Archbishop Desmond Tutu co-founded the Kagiso Trust with Dr Beyers Naudè, Reverend Frank Chikane, Dr Max Coleman, Dr Alan Boesak, Dr Abe Nkomo, Father Smangaliso Mkhatshwa, and Eric Molobi, and took on the arduous task of trying to persuade the European Union to impose sanctions on the South African apartheid government.
In 1985, the EU agreed to impose partial sanctions on South Africa and also decided, through its Special Programme for the victims of apartheid, to support projects that promoted non-racialism and capacity development among those disadvantaged by apartheid.

They indicated that they wanted to allocate development funds using three channels, namely: South African Council of Churches (SACC), the South African Catholic Bishops conference, and a third secular channel, Kagiso Trust.
Read 15 tweets
Sep 24, 2023
Ever wondered how the 99-year lease agreement at Waterfall works like especially where Balwin is concerned?

[Thread]
A bit of history.

It is reported that the first title-deed-holders of the Waterval farm were the Gibson brothers, who arrived from England in South Africa in 1871.

They bred cattle and operated their Red Star Line stagecoach business between Johannesburg and Pretoria.
In 1934, the farm was sold to Moosa Ismail Mia.

He later registered the development in the name of Witwatersrand Estates Limited, which to this day is owned and controlled by the Waterval Islamic Institute.
Read 18 tweets
Sep 12, 2023
I did a thread on Starbucks and someone asked about the ownership of Seattle Coffee.

You can’t talk Seattle without talking about the Food Lovers Market.

Fruit & Veg City has rebranded into Food Lovers Market Group with an estimated annual turnover of +-12bn.

[Thread]
The founders of Food Lovers Market Group are Brian and Mike Coppin

The business was founded in 1993 as Fruit & Veg City and has rebranded into Food Lovers Market Group.
Food Lover's Market is one of the last few independent food retailers of scale on the African continent.

It has added categories such as bakery grocery, butchery and deil foods to complement its market leading position in fresh produce.
Read 17 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(