It’s Monday and I’m here at the federal courthouse in Santa Ana, California, for what should be a short status conference in Michael Avenatti’s wire fraud case. Follow this thread for updates from the courtroom.
⚖️🧵⚖️
Avenatti's case is on Judge Selna's 9:30 a.m. calendar. There's a sentencing ahead of them, but they're doing that one now, so Avenatti's should start right at 9:30 a.m. cacd.uscourts.gov/daily-calendar
Remember, when we last left off last Wednesday, Judge Selna had ordered @TheJusticeDept to give Avenatti complete copies of the forensic images of his law firm servers. Here's my @lawdotcom article on that: bit.ly/2YR2bOs
You can catch up on all our @lawdotcom coverage of the Avenatti case here: bit.ly/3znVccj
OK, sentencing is over (she got three years probation) and Avenatti is at the defense table with his standby counsel Courtney Cummings Cefali. No Dean Steward today. AUSAs Alex Wyman, Brett Sagel and Patrick Fitzgerald are here.
(Wyman and Sagel are case prosecutors and Fitzgerald is in charge of @TheJusticeDept privilege-review team that's in charge of Avenatti's law firm servers.) Time for a progress report. Fitzgerald is updating Judge Selna.
.@FBI gave Avenatti a digital copy of the Eagan Avenatti LLP files, so defense now has "all the EA files that the privilege-review team had or have access to," Fitzgerald tells Judge Selna.
Other issue is indexed files DOJ already has. Fitzgerald says DC guy believes he's found a way to download those on hard drive and @FedEx it.
There's also an effort in LA to index the file copies there, but Fitzgerald says the tech process is going even slower than last week.
Selna asked if the indexing took place over the weekend, too.
"It did, your honor. It's just going very, very slow," Fitzgerald says.
"Well, it's going to be a seven-day-a-week project," until it's done, Selna says.
Fitzgerald says yes, the computer is working seven days a week.
Avenatti says he's found Brady material (exculpatory evidence) in the new stuff already, and he'll be filing a brief on that. Asks when he'll get the indexing from DC, and Selna says according to Fitzgerald it's "imminent."
Regarding trial logistics, Selna scheduled a pre-trial for Oct. 27 at 8:30 a.m.. Jury pool is due Nov. 2, but if the trial he's got the week before ends early, they'll bump that up.
Selna addressed Avenatti's objections about screening jurors by saying they'll get jurors in for hardship questionnaires in open court, under the supervision of either him or a magistrate judge.
Avenatti then told Judge Selna he needs "to seek some medical care" and inquired abut modifying his bail conditions to allow it. "It's nothing serious, your honor," Avenatti said. It's just "been a couple years since I've been able to attend to things."
Selna tells him no modification is needed, just coordinate w/ bail and probation. AUSA Sagel asked about hearing set for next Monday. Still on calendar? "Unless the 4.5 million has been produced, yes," Selna says, referring to the files Avenatti still needs from @TheJusticeDept.
So that's it. Short and to the point. Regarding the DOJ's privilege-review team, this article I did for @lawdotcom looks at the history of controversy surrounding that process and how Avenatti's mistrial differs: bit.ly/3jWNB06
Prosecutors also filed a brief last week that lays out their argument against the mistrial, and denies any exculpatory evidence has been withheld from Avenatti. That's available here: bit.ly/3lowaF2
That was filed while Avenatti was working on double jeopardy motion, which he mentioned in his reply. "Requiring him to read the 76 page submission, research the issues, and draft his response over these same days is unduly prejudicial and onerous." bit.ly/399fefW
Here's Avenatti's double jeopardy motion, which calls for Judge Selna to cancel the retrial and dismiss his indictment. Prosecutors' reply is due next Monday, and the hearing is Oct. 4. bit.ly/3lyZngO
That’s it on the Avenatti front for now. I’m headed over to @OCSuperiorCourt for a hearing in @PIMCO billionaire Bill Gross’ ongoing Laguna Beach neighbor dispute over loud music, so look for a thread on that Gilligan’s Island-inspired debacle soon. 👀
7 hours later, I’m capping the Avenatti thread with a couple pics of the courthouse cats, just snagged. 😼😼
One more thing: Avenatti filed an amended double jeopardy motion with declaration and exhibits today. I can't see the immediate difference between it and the first one, but if anyone wants to try to figure it out, please have at it. Here's the motion: bit.ly/39k92SG
Here's his original filing: bit.ly/3lyZngO It's 52 pages, whereas the amended motion filed today is 38 pages. But the declaration and exhibits this time are 571 pages, whereas the decs and exhibits for original motion were 560 pages.
First batch of decs and exhibits here: bit.ly/3hH1nCg
New batch of decs and exhibits for amended motion here: bit.ly/3hR1gUY
I will retweet whoever can identify for me the major differences in these filings. Thank you!
Update: Judge Selna gave Avenatti more pages than usual, but he still was limited to 30 pages, and his original filing went over. So he had to cut some stuff out.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Meghann Cuniff

Meghann Cuniff Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @meghanncuniff

17 Sep
Michael Avenatti is asking the California federal judge who declared the mistrial in his wire fraud case to dismiss his charges because of prosecutorial misconduct. Motion just filed: bit.ly/3lyZngO
The motion includes a massive 560 pages o' exhibits and declarations. Available here on Google Drive: bit.ly/3hH1nCg
This motion has a tough road ahead, as Judge Selna didn't find prosecutorial misconduct and has told Avenatti a retrial is pretty clearly in order. He also said at Wednesday's status conference the Nov. 2 trial is for sure happening.
Read 6 tweets
15 Sep
Another chapter in Orange County homeless saga continues w/ motion to halt closure of service provider. This is part of a proposed class action, and not exactly the harmonious dispute resolution process Judge Carter's consent decrees were aimed at: bit.ly/3Clno1D
This isn't completely unexpected, as there are other lawsuits including Santa Ana's still-pending lawsuit against OC over jail releases and out-of-city transfers, which I wrote about last year for @timesocofficial. lat.ms/3AiDMPH
But it's worth noting that people in LA celebrate Judge Carter's involvement up there because they want to replicate the same kind of consent decree dispute resolution process. But that assumes things are actually going well in OC, which is in reality heavily debatable.
Read 8 tweets
15 Sep
It’s Wednesday in Orange County, California, and I’m here at the federal courthouse because Judge Selna is getting the gang back together again i.e. there’s a 9 a.m. status conference in Michael Avenatti’s wire fraud case. Follow this thread for updates from the courtroom. ⚖️🧵⚖️
The judge called this status conference after receiving reports of trouble on the Tabs3 front, with Avenatti already saying a trial continuance is needed and prosecutors artfully telling Selna his mistrial ruling was flat wrong. Here's the USA's brief: bit.ly/3lowaF2
And here's Avenatti's status update on the remaining financial data @TheJusticeDept is to give him. bit.ly/3lsiCIL He's in court now awaiting Judge Selna, and was asking AUSA Patrick Fitzgerald of the privilege-review team aka taint team about the remaining files.
Read 27 tweets
13 Sep
Avenatti just filed a status report that says @TheJusticeDept still hasn’t given him all relevant financial data, and the taint team “is unable to provide a firm estimate as to when the remaining financial data will be produced.” bit.ly/2Xk9Wfv
Avenatti says ongoing conflict with the taint team over the scope of the searches “will probably require the intervention of the Court finally to resolve.” He hasn’t asked for a trial continuance…yet.
Of course, it's always in the footnotes. "As a result, a modification to the case schedule and trial will almost certainly be required."
Read 14 tweets
26 Aug
This is the big question in his California case right now - will the judge in New York extend Avenatti’s prison report date, currently set for Sept. 15? Avenatti filed his motion this morning asking to push it back to December.
Obviously this is totally out of Judge Selna’s hands. This will be decided by Judge Gardephe in the Southern District of New York, the judge who sentenced Avenatti to 30 months for the Nike extortion plot.
There’s long been friction between the two cases. Gardephe was not happy with Avenatti’s pre-trial arrest at his California State Bar hearing in January 2020 because it threw the pending Nike trial into (brief) disarray.
Read 37 tweets
24 Aug
I’m here at the federal courthouse in Santa Ana for what could be the 19th day of testimony in Michael Avenatti’s wire fraud trial. First, Judge Selna will consider a mistrial motion over newly released and also still missing financial data. Follow this thread for updates. ⚖️🧵⚖️
I sat down in my usual spot a minute ago. Only Judge Selna and his clerk were in the courtroom. "Good morning. We should put a little name tag on that chair," the judge said after I sat down. (He's back in his chambers now. That was the extent of the discussion.)
Avenatti and prosecutors are due at 8. This @lawdotcom article from last night is a hub of all our reporting on this Tabs and mistral motion. You'll find past coverage, links to the court filings and more. bit.ly/3mrMp6l
Read 102 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(