"Technology has served to fuel humanity’s belief in, if not its own omnipotence, then at least in its ability to achieve anything it wishes by the deployment of instrumental reason and technical know-how.
2/ "In this context, it is interesting to notice the panic, perhaps even mass hysteria, induced by the Covid-19 pandemic. We have been faced with an enemy which cannot be immediately defeated and which brings the reality of mortality closer to us than has been typical of our age,
3/ "... marked as it is by the practical denial of death. Our panicked response has entailed eliminating the consideration of any social good except the immediate preservation of life, whatever the cost to others, and a corresponding desperate hunt for a vaccine.
4/ "The inability of our moral imaginations to rank goods, let alone view the pandemic from any transcendent point of reference, has been dramatically exposed."
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ Over the past century, an arrogant, technocratic positivism sought to elevate empirical science as the only valid form of knowledge. With a kind of totalitarian impulse, this negated entirely other domains of inquiry: ethics and metaphysics were declared nonsensical.
2/ Certain questions simply could not be raised. The point was not to understand the world but to transform it. Within this impoverished philosophy, which knows only impersonal forces, a critique of violence becomes impossible.
3/ As the useful replaces the good and efficiency becomes the highest value, not only is knowledge instrumentalized but human beings are also instrumentalized.
News from the UK: a new mutation is associated with immune escape – suggesting the virus is coming under pressure from highly vaccinated population inews.co.uk/news/politics/…
"Although case numbers are very low, the presence of E484K – known in virology circles as “Eeek” because of its vaccine-dodging qualities – is a cause for concern and Public Health England have classed it as a 'signal under investigation'."
"Scientists have warned... that a combination of highly transmissible Delta with an immune escape mutation could pose a threat to vaccines. The shift also suggests the virus is coming under pressure in a largely vaccinated population in the UK and is trying to adapt to survive."
1/ Yes, the pandemic revealed and amplified what was already there. At every step our response to the virus has favored the laptop class over and against the working class. Some populations have remained entirely invisible.
2/ Here’s just one example: children with autism or other cognitive disabilities and their parents. During lockdowns, their day programs were shut down and their social routines completely disrupted. These routines and services are essential for their stability.
3/ In the face of these disruptions, and given their limited coping skills, they act it out behaviorally and emotionally, often landing in the hospital. Parents were calling me in tears, helpless, with no resources. Seen any of this mentioned on TV?
1/ A fellow physician recently reached out expressing support for my lawsuit and shared the following with me:
"I was ill for about 3 months or more after my first Pfizer shot in February 2021.
2/ "I never knew I had Covid but suspected my reaction was amnestic, especially due to the lump at the injection site that reminded me of a positive PPD [tuberculosis skin test], and persisted beyond when I was scheduled for the second shot. I declined the second shot.
3/ "My supposition was that I had exposure to Covid before the vaccine, had T cell immunity and was protected. I decided to check for antibodies. I had the test and my level was high, consistent with my supposition especially since it was 7 months after my single dose of vaccine.
Regarding asymptomatic testing, the distinction between vaccinated/unvaccinated makes no scientific sense, since both can be infected with and transmit Covid.
The scientifically defensible categories should be:
For #1, no need for testing, since there is not a single case reported of transmission in naturally immune.
For #2,3, test only if symptomatic.
If asymptomatic testing is determined to be necessary, both 2 and 3 should be subjected to the same testing schedule since both can get infected and transmit the virus, as the CDC has acknowledged.
From the outset, this pandemic was an affront to the idea of unlimited Progress, our ability to dominate nature through science and technology, through our pragmatic ingenuity. But then nature (or perhaps science itself) threw a virus at us that we fundamentally couldn't control.
This is one reason why natural immunity cannot be acknowledged as a major contribution to herd immunity and the pathway out of the pandemic. For us to reassert the idea of Progress requires that the solution be of our own making--scientific progress must offer the sole fix.
So, in the name of Progress, we forbade socializing, forbade encountering others face-to-face, forbade working unless the work could be technologically mediated or was necessary for bare biological survival. For the first time since Antigone, we forbade burying our dead.