On the question of vax mandates for staff in nursing homes, a core issue is that many of these jobs are very low paying and that's driving labor shortages. And vax rates are in many cases low for a variety of reasons in the working class communities that work in these positions.
2/ That's not an easy problem to solve at the facility level. But the big picture solution is to increase wages. But there's a tendency in these conversations to point to the roots of vax hesitancy in these communities (very real) and economic privation to push back against ...
3/ the idea of mandates. These counters are very valid but the have the tendency to end up at we'll make sure your ailing mother isn't being wheeled around by an unvaccinated person with COVID once we get social democracy. But that's not really workable or just.
4/ I have I guess the 'privilege' of having parents who are dead and in-laws who are comparatively healthy. So I'm not experiencing this directly. But if I had a loved one in one of these facilities I'm seriously, fuck that. That's really intolerable.
5/ You need to do everything humanly possible with regs and the law and money to make sure extremely vulnerable populations aren't willfully being given COVID and then once you've maxed out on that front start working on the roots of the problem.
6/ Late in life decrepitude and chronic illness doesn't discriminate. And it's more marginalized communities most likely to be in facilities with low vax rates.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Josh Marshall

Josh Marshall Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @joshtpm

24 Sep
There’s another dimension of this story worth addressing. It’s largely a press failure. But Dems have done too little to correct it. Again and again this battle has been portrayed as between “progressives” and “moderates”. So AOC and Bernie vs Manchin and Sinema.
2/ Thats almost totally false. Maybe not every last thing in the recon bill. But the package actually has overwhelming support in both caucuses. Overwhelming. It is literally the Presidents agenda. There are some quibbles over the SALT tax. There are some differences over …
3/ the exact scope of the climate package. There are some Dems quibbling over whether some of the social safety net programs will be made permanent. Those are real disagreements. But they’re mostly negotiable and they mostly don’t touch the scale of the package.
Read 12 tweets
24 Sep
this is very very key. what’s changed over the summer is that Dem mods have spent months calling the package too extreme etc. they’ve also created a drawn out process that has allowed the idea to take hold. the contrast with the covid rescue bill is instructive.
2/ the bill was,popular. Dems were United behind it. It passed quickly. Done and done. Remains popular. now there’s an element of circular logic here. Pols need to be able to say there are things they don’t support obviously. They also need to be able to negotiate. But here …
3/ we get to something pretty key. The hold ups from the sinemas and Manchins have never been policy focused. Their mostly positioning, which is to say focused on creating good political outcomes for themselves. They obviously wouldn’t agree that that is the case.
Read 6 tweets
23 Sep
I've been looking at other Sinema polls over the last 8 months. They vary over the course of the year unsurprisingly. But what's consistent is very tepid support from Democrats. Usually in the neighborhood of 50%. From your own party, that's terrible.
2/ What's notable though is that Sinema seldom does any better with Independents. Again, it varies. But she's seldom any better with indys than her colleague Mark Kelly. Usually worse. So the premise that she appeals to indys and people who like bipartisanship doesn't ...
3/ really bear out. In the polls she does relatively well on ... the ones where she has net positive approval overall where the makes up ground is with Republicans. Not independents but Republicans. Given when these polls come over the course of the year, the roots of this ...
Read 5 tweets
23 Sep
This is really good. You should read it. Everything is on the line. Biden needs to remind everyone in his party this is a BFD so STFU and everyone follow the President's lead. It's a BFD. Everything is on the line. nymag.com/intelligencer/…
2/ The one potential quibble I have with Ed's take here is that he says the progs should come off the mark and agree to vote for the bipartisan mini-bill and Biden will get absolute assurances that Sinema and Manchin and whatever other mods in the House WILL vote for ...
3/ the recon bill. They can negotiate but not dictate. And they have to vote for the final thing. I broadly agree with that. But given the antics from Manchin and Sinema over the last six months that's a helluva lot of trust to place in the process. Frankly, I don't ...
Read 9 tweets
22 Sep
Craig Chimes In! From an email in my inbox this morning: "The iguana was tough, quiet with a penchant for crawling under a table or other dark recess. The kangaroo rat caused the most stress, a small quick thing, but the iguana would be missed ...
2/(He had a name and taking him home for the weekend was an honor Mr. Yam bestowed in the deserving.). I actually think we lost the rat at some point." And then a bit later: "Teaching, managing, whatevering I bring up the story of the animals and cages. It just comes up a lot...
3/ There’s some kind of game theory math puzzle in there but I’m not smart enough to tease it out. If operation linebacker is the game of two men chained together on a cliff, what is the right way to describe this? You are right about the matter of rules ...
Read 5 tweets
22 Sep
The latest debt limit hostage situation/drama reminds me of a story from my youth which has always struck me as illustrative of some very basic realities about human nature and responsibility. So here goes.
2/ Back when I was in 8th grade my friend Craig and I were teachers assistants in the Computer Science class. As near as I can tell this consisted of our getting class credit for hanging out in the comp sci classroom during an off period and goofing off. In theory I guess ...
3/ we did some assisting for the teacher, Mr. Cisco. But the story turns on the adjoining classroom. That was Mr. Yam's classroom, a somewhat legendary science teacher in the community. Mr. Yam had a lot of tall tales and his room was filled with like a million cages of various..
Read 18 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(