Aristocratic Fury Profile picture
Oct 10, 2021 18 tweets 9 min read Read on X
Today 10 October is anniversary of the famous battle of Tours in year 732. Under the leadership of Charles Martel, the Franks defeated the invading army of the Umayyad Caliphate. Their disciplined infantry and experience from previous wars played a crucial part in their victory!
This battle is very known and probably doesn't need a long introduction. The mighty Umayyad Caliphate met its match when it encountered the skilled Frankish warriors who stopped the spread of Islam. Tours was just one of many of their encounters, but it is the most known one.
While this battle is notorious for its role in the context in the struggle of Christendom against Islam, but the tactics that Christians used in this battle were much different than what they used later in crusades. At Tours, it was the infantry that played the crucial role!
While the Normans and crusader knights who fought against Saracens were famed for their lethal cavalry charges, at Tours, it was the Umayyads who had the superior cavalry! They used stirrups which were yet unknown to Franks and their elite cavalry had better weapons.
We don't really know the exact numbers, but almost all accounts estimate that at Tours the Umayyad numbers were higher, sometimes significantly higher. The Franks were probably slightly outnumbered at the very least, and were up against a powerful and determined force.
The Frankish leader Charles Martel did manage to bring together a very large army for Europe at the time, calling to arms Catholic tribes over his realms. Burgundians, Alemanni, Bavarians, Thuringians, Aquitanians and Lombards all took arms. Their numbers estimated up to 20000!
The most important attribute the Frankish army had at Tours was definitely military experience. Charles Martel himself had fought in many battles against his rivals and neighboring tribes such as Saxons and Neustrians, waging wars as far away as Frisia and Bavaria.
Because of this reason, the Frankish infantry was a much more formidable and disciplined force than one would expect from infantry at the time. From the accounts it seems that the Umayyad invaders underestimated this aspect.
The Umayyads had already lost to Christian forces in the region in the past, as they lost the battle of Toulouse in 721 against Odo of Aquitaine who was now serving Charles Martel at Tours, but they lost that battle by a surprise cavalry attack while they besieged Toulouse.
Despite this setback, the Umayyads had all the reasons to be confident. They were the empire on the rise, conquering vast lands with a skilled and experienced army united and motivated by religious fervor. They had already conquered Spain and wanted to progress further.
Charles Martel knew what he was up against as well as he faced the "mighty race of Ishmael, who are now
known by the outlandish name of Saracens" as the Chronicle of Fredegar puts it. He decided to take a very defensive and cautious approach.
Charles Martel positioned his army well on the higher ground, with infantry in front and cavalry behind to protect them from being flanked. The trees distorted their real numbers which was deliberate as they were trying to bait the overconfident Umayyads.
His plan worked as the Umayyads charged with their cavalry before making enough scouting beforehand. They did not expect the infantry to hold the cavalry charge but it did! The Frankish infantry held their ground in tight and disciplined formation.
"The men of the north stood as motionless as a wall. They were like a belt of ice frozen together," wrote the Mozarabic chronicle in 754 about how well Frankish infantry performed in this battle as the Moorish horsemen attacked them wave after wave without any success.
This shocked the Moors who did not expect infantry to resist the cavalry charge. Their favorite tactic of pushing strong in the center while flanking the opponents was also neutralized by well chosen position of Frankish troops. They were dragged into a long vicious melee.
The Franks managed to overwhelm their enemy, but it was also at high cost after vicious fighting. The tactical mastery and prudence of Charles Martel won them the battle, and led them to crucial victory which asserted the power of the Franks in the region.
The disciplined Franks did not loot the enemy camp immediately after Moors fled, but patiently stayed in their positions over entire night out of caution. Many battles in history were lost due to soldiers looting too early, and Franks did not make this mistake!
At Tours, patient defensive infantry tactics won the battle for Christendom. Soon after this battle, however, the Europeans would start focusing on developing lethal heavy cavalry charges. The Franks and their descendants would become a powerful force that changed history.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Aristocratic Fury

Aristocratic Fury Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @LandsknechtPike

Nov 12
Jan III Sobieski is well known for his victory at Vienna in 1683.

But he had already made his name as a warrior long before that.

On this day 11 November he achieved a great victory against the Ottomans in 1673 at Khotyn.

This is how the Lion of Lechistan was born. 🧵 Image
Image
Image
The Battle of Khotyn happened in the context of the Polish-Ottoman War of 1672-1676.

The said war was started when the Ottomans invaded the lands of Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth in Ukraine with a 80,000 strong army.

This army was led Sultan Mehmed IV and the Grand Vizier. Image
The invaders entered lands that were already devastated by war and faced a much weakened Commonwealth.

The Polish-Cossack-Tatar War of 1666-1671 had just ended and left the Commonwealth exhausted, tired from having to put down the unrest in Ukraine. Image
Image
Image
Read 22 tweets
Oct 14
It's crazy how Americans bought the myth that during the time of Columbus people thought that the earth was flat, a complete lie popularized by quasi-historian Washington Irving in 1828.

This globe was literally made before Columbus' discovery, and has no America on it. Image
Washington Irving completely invented a fictional dialogue between Columbus and the Council of Salamanca, where the clergy supposedly objected him on the ground that the earth was flat.

His fraudulent book would become the most popular book on Columbus in English-speaking world. Image
This lie was then picked on in America and expended as some sort of anti-Catholic anti-medieval founding myth, where Columbus was supposedly representing enlightenment rationalism against irrationality and dogmatism of the Church.

All based on a total lie. Image
Read 11 tweets
Aug 16
The idea that monarchy and republic are opposed to each other is a modern thing.

The term republic (res publica) was often used to describe medieval kingdoms.

Even by 16th century the Kingdom of France was still called both a republic and a monarchy at the same time!Image
The Kingdom of France defined itself by the phrase of "chose publique" (res publica) from 1350s to 1580s, also using the word respublique, to describe the relation between the King of France and his subject.

The term was then replaced by State (État).Image
The absolutist French monarchy which emerged in 17th century preferred the term State over republic, and talked of the "good of the State".

However the term state also comes from earlier medieval concepts like status regis at regni (the state of the king and the kingdom).Image
Read 18 tweets
Jun 18
There are many mysterious legends in the Alps.

People from the village of Gurro believe that they are descendants of Scottish warriors who served the French king at the battle of Pavia in 1525!

It is said that after their retreat the Scots were stuck here due to a blizzard. 🧵

Image
Image
Image
The village of Gurro is situated in Italy close to the border of Switzerland.

The villagers are said to speak a curious dialect and have distinct traditions which they believe originate from their alleged Scottish ancestors.
Image
Image
For example the people of Gurro want to say yes they say aye instead of Italian si.

They also claim that the traditional wooden support under the windows is deliberately shaped to resemble St. Andrew's cross.

Traditional clothes resemble Scottish tartan.Image
Image
Image
Read 21 tweets
May 27
There are many anonymous accounts here on X.

But how did people post anonymously in the past?

16th century Romans developed an interesting tradition of "talking statues", attaching anonymous political commentary on statues.

The Pasquino was the first of such statues.🧵Image
Image
The Pasquino is an old statue in Rome dating back to Antiquity.

It was one of many random statues in Rome until early 16th century when Cardinal Oliveiro Carafa decorated the statue with Latin epigrams on the occasion of the Feast of Saint Mark.
Image
Image
The Cardinal's actions unintentionally inspired ordinary Roman people to start writing satirical poems and attaching them to the Pasquino.

It is speculated that these were first only consisting of lowbrow humor, but they soon began including controversial political criticism! Image
Read 22 tweets
May 22
In the Middle Ages there was no word for orange color.

The Westerners only adopted the word for this color in 16th century from the Sanskrit word naranga through Portuguese merchants!

It eventually became associated with the Protestant cause.🧵Image
Image
Image
The medievals adopted the idea from the ancients that there were only seven colors: white, yellow, red, green, blue, purple and black.

These were also the seven heraldic tinctures which were eligible to be used on the coats of arms.

Medieval nobles could not use orange color! Image
But in late 15th and early 16th century the Portuguese merchants brought first orange trees to Europe from Asia!

Suddenly there were fruits in Europe that were of this color orange, for which there was no name yet. Image
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(