Title:
Did you read it?
Description of the book (in your own words):
One positive theme in the book:
What conversations are possible because of book?
Your primary concern:
How do passages of concern relate to book as a whole?
I think what is key is to frame parental concerns about book contents as the beginning of a conversation, not the end of one.
@r_bittner@AdvInCensorship@ncacensorship We can model how to contextualize passages that might seem objectionable; we can offer similar examples from "classic" texts; we can provide resources that help parents see the opportunity to talk to their kids about issues because of the book.
I know that this is fantasizing parent concerns that are actually sincere... and parents with an interest in reading the books. But the audience is not just the parent with the complaint.
The audience is also the reasonable segment of the community who generally support youth access but might be made reluctant to support a book when what's being emphasized is only the "tricky" content.
I think these folks--upon seeing a reasonable, balanced response from the district--may relax or even welcome the conversation.
My goal is not to see parent concerns--even extreme ones--dismissed, but for those concerns to initiate a different course of action than book banning.
One problem that comes up in these situations, I think, is the perception (from those opposed to content) that the district "isn't doing anything" about what they view as a problem. Having a clear set of actions--other than book removal--can answer that allegation.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I appreciate so many folks offering solidarity & reading what @andrewkarre & @veronikellymars & others have to say about book bans. That, AND...
Teachers, librarians, principals, students, school board members: they are the ones most in the crosshairs of this awful moment.
Let's talk about the 20 (or more?) sane voices expressing gratitude for youth access to rich, relevant varied literature that it will take to match the impact and reach 1 hysterical adult's decontextualized claims about a novel in the school library.
If you don't know what's happening in your school board meetings, find out right now. This circus may be coming to a fairground near you--or maybe you're in the thick of it.
The folks attacking the literature in schools have a playbook, talking points, reservoirs of outrage.