The Emissary Profile picture
Oct 19, 2021 7 tweets 3 min read Read on X
As time went on, other Muslim League leaders would fire their rhetorical silos on the justification of Pakistan. They would inevitably be tied to not just Muslim safety, but Islamic fulfillment of power & God given right.

Pakistan could only be an Islamic State. Image
One of the most interesting parts of the Raja of Mahmudabad’s case was the superiority of Islam as an eternal and supreme religion, a Sanātan Dharma in a way 😎. The Prophet Muhammad had perfected & revived Islam which was sent to all peoples over history. Image
Mahmudabad contrasted this perfect Islamic state with the follies of European nations & accuses Gandhi of encapsulating a hybrid faulty nation combining Tolstoy &…get this…Savarkar to create a Congress Hindu Raj.

OTOH, he viewed Pakistan as a future national model for the 🌍. Image
Something I want to make clear - all ML leaders were very aware of the fate of the Muslims of UP, the Quraysh of Indian Muslims. From hostage population theory to being mujahideen who sacrifice their lot for Pakistan to an outpost of expansion. Image
Khaliquzzaman, another ML leader, would follow comparing wataniyat(nationalism) vs mazhab(religion). Ironically, he claims that Indian Muslims would never harm their Afghan brothers if ordered by an Indian Premier.

Seems like only the Taliban are convincing enough today… Image
Besides the hostage population theory, another common thread amongst ML leaders was the begging of British Raj assistance & promises to sabotage the “Hindu Raj” independence.

It was partition or bust for many ML leaders as demands for confederate federalism failed quickly. Image
Khaliq reflected a common position of integrating ALL of Punjab & Bengal(& Assam) as part of Pakistan. Demographic expansion was encouraged in border districts. He wanted Urdu/UP Muslim culture to be directly bordering Pakistan as a perpetual influence to Islamicize Punjab/Bengal Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with The Emissary

The Emissary Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @TheEmissaryCo

Apr 25
The best part of the idea of 'India being a COLONIAL construct' coming to fore is that we can debunk this in the open.

Here are a list of ancient names for India from across the world 🇮🇳🌍🧵 Image
In this case, I will refer to strict subcontinental boundaries at inception, so I will skip Āryavarta in the Vedas & go directly to Bhārata - named after all-conquering King Bharata.

Here's an emphatic declaration from the Vishnu Purana. You cannot argue with geography... Image
Image
Jambudvīpa, the Island of the Jambu (Indian blackberry) tree, is found across ancient literature as well.

The below excerpt shows how subcontinental the idea really was as the extreme south is directly correlated with extreme north for pilgrims.

Read 10 tweets
Apr 23
A few thoughts on the (geo)political ramifications of the Pahalgam Massacre: Image
Firstly, we have to start with Pakistan. There was local support in Kashmir, but the signs point to Pakistani involvement whether via the actual terrorists (a couple have already been ID'ed as Pakistani) or just clandestine support from the Pakistani state.

If you look at it from their angle, this is a great time to pull this off. Whether Pakistanis are seen as strong-willed or numb, they've endured massive economic stress which now seems to be cooling. Simultaneously, Baloch & Pashtun lands have seen much more militant attacks recently. For the Pak Army, there's no better time to unite the Pakistani people via provoking India than now.

They won't seem desperate due to economy not being the *worst* it could be (while still being bad). And also they can rally around alleged Indian involvement in Balochi & Pashtun areas.Image
Image
For India, it is an interesting situation to say the least. The economy is doing good, but could be doing better - much better in fact. Reforms are coming via state and some backend central moves (that may materialize or not) but for the centre, there is a looming notion of pulling the trigger of reform and going head to head with anti-development forces, something that could definitely result in electoral defeats and power loss.

This is a double-edged sword here. On one hand, Modi could use a riled up populace to sneak in reforms on the down low. On the other, it could be seen as too opportunistic in a time where he should be doing more to address the issue of Kashmir/Pakistan. Nonetheless, the initial diplomatic silo has been a solid and uncharacteristically quick first move. Keep an eye on how uniform the condemnation has been from the West & Gulf countries, this may play a role in further long term beyond military action like economic or diplomatic isolation that could bleed Pakistan over the years.

Kashmir has had issues recently with terror attacks, but it is relatively much more stable than pre-370 and easily much better than high octane periods like the 90s. Tourism and investments were rising. For local separatists, this wasn't a good situation. They do not want locals to let go of their very real religious bigotry & ethnic animus towards Hindus & Indians just for a couple of rupees. This attack in coordination with Pakistan helps kill the money train & slow motion normalization (some may say futile normalization).Image
Image
Read 4 tweets
Oct 29, 2024
One of the biggest precursors to the Meiji Restoration was the downfall of the samurai.

Once revered as emblematic warrior elites, they were now debased in the eyes of commoners.

This collapse of hierarchy would pave the way for a cataclysmic civil war changing Japan forever 🧵 Image
The primary reason for their fall was their involvement in commercial affairs & subsequent deep debt many took on due to a weak hand when it came to finances:
The most kinetic aspect of this was the entry of commoners into formal armies in the form of mixed units (kiheitai), especially those of the Choshu domain.

The kiheitai were originally not that successful as Choshu commoners didn't respect the samurai, especially rebels (ronin).Image
Read 10 tweets
Oct 14, 2024
I increasingly go to LW outlets for RW wins.

The reasoning is this... 🧵 Image
1. RW had a very successful messaging strategy for the past decade - OUTRAGE.

Outrage over uneven secularism, communal incidents, etc... It was a shattering of mainstream narratives by the internet & it felt great.
For many, the usual outrage has gotten stale. The new fashion is criticizing the BJP for not being Hindu enough

Now THAT gets clicks & gives people that same twang of outrage of old WhatsApp forward of a random communal riot or love jihad or whatever

Folx get off on this stuff
Read 9 tweets
Mar 22, 2024
Indian Civilization's 3-Body Doctrine

In Hinduism, the Jivatman is said to be composed of 3 aspects:

-Sthula: Physical
-Sukshma: Mental
-Kāran: Causal

The Upanishads & Yoga Sutras explore this doctrine in-depth.

But what if we applied this doctrine to India itself? 🧵Image
Sthula

Regarding the Jivatman, sthula refers to the physical body that we use to engage with our senses & feelings.

It is the physical matter of our body. Our sensory organs help us observe the world.

Our Prana, the life force that sustains us & physiological processes.Image
For Indian civilization, this is its geography, structures, & people itself.

"The county north of the ocean & south of the snowy mountains..." as the Vishnu Puran says.

India is pilgrimages & structures made by its most important sthula element - its people.

Even those not in the Republic of India today still descend from those who, at one point in time, identified as Indians or were under the local rule of those who did. Genetics will forever display "Indianness" on their faces and cells in one way or another.Image
Image
Image
Read 7 tweets
Mar 4, 2024
One of my most fascinating visits in India was going to Jama Masjid in Delhi.

Some confirmations & other surprises from my priors 🧵 Image
Walking up to Jama Masjid firstly consists of walking through a bazaar up till the main gate & stairs.

Saw both Muslims & Hindus in the bazaar (more of former while latter were less & mostly shopping).

The grandness of the gate is the first thing that stands out to you once you reach. This theme of size & grandness is an important spark of thought as I walked across the mosque.Image
Image
Image
The mosque is Mughal architecture par excellence.

My visits in Istanbul, Jordan, & Dubai gave me a taste of Turkish & Arab styles, but here is where you really see the “Indo” in Indo-Islamic architecture.

The chhatris, ramparts, gates, “kalashes,” etc… all gave a distinctly Indian feelImage
Image
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(