1. @andrealeadsom on 03/11 you said this in @HouseofCommons regarding MPs 'We spend so much of our lives trying to deliver justice to our constituents & fighting against unfairness wherever we see it.' I challenge that statement in respect of your actions for #LoanChargeScandal
2. I first wrote to you @andrealeadsom in Sept 2017 regarding #LoanChargeScandal & first met you regarding this unjust legislation in Oct 2017. You were unaware of the 20yr retrospective nature of the legislation until I told you. You agreed retrospective law changes were wrong.
3. For 4yrs @andrealeadsom I have asked for your help regarding the #LoanChargeScandal, 4yrs. How long did it take you to draft your amendment for the standards committee & then get the vote passed? Was it a matter of days. You've never spoken out for your constituents like that.
4. Yes, you've written letters regarding #LoanChargeScandal to @HMRCgovuk & @hmtreasury but never expressing your feelings against the unjust nature of this retrospective legislation. Always the minimum to keep us quiet."Fighting against unfairness wherever we see it" I think not
5. @andrealeadsom You promised me & fellow constituents a face to face meeting with Mel Stride to discuss #LoanChargeScandal. At the time he was a junior minister & you were Leader of the House. He refused the meeting, you didn't push or fight our corner to get us in front of him
6. @andrealeadsom when we asked you to sign the #LoanChargeScandal EDM started by @StephenLloydEBN you said you had a policy of not signing EDM's, when we asked for you to join the @loanchargeAPPG you said you do not generally join APPGs. How exactly are you fighting injustice?
7. I asked you @andrealeadsom to sign the recent open letter about the #LoanChargeScandal, you don't believe open letters help to improve sympathy to a cause. Over 140 other MPs have signed this open letter, way more than the 59 to peak your concern about the standards committee.
8. @andrealeadsom you said in the House 'It is so sad that it takes a tragedy for the House to act.'
You are aware that there have been 7 #LoanChargeScandal suicides. You spoke to the daughter of a victim. Disgraceful that you & the House haven't acted.
9. @andrealeadsom where does the #LoanChargeScandal "reflect the laws of natural justice. Where the accused can expect to have their own evidence taken into account and vitally to access an independent appeal process."?
The Loan Charge strips this away. Let's see you fight that.
10. @andrealeadsom you have dodged or refused to meet any officers from @LCAG_2019 or the tax barrister @keithmgordon with me & other constituents. Are you scared of the truth about the #LoanChargeScandal? It is built on lies, recent FOI requests attest to that.
11. As a constituent & victim of the #LoanChargeScandal I want you to show this fight against injustice that you talk about or is that just reserved for MPs? I want you to act as quickly as you did for your amendment to the standards committee & speak up in Parliament.
12. Speeches about your amendment @andrealeadsom raised some pertinent points about retrospective legislation & @RhonddaBryant said "Retrospective legislation to favour or damage an individual .... is immoral & the polar opposite of the rule of law".#LoanCharge is retrospective.
13. @Jacob_Rees_Mogg said today when talking about your amendment @andrealeadsom that it would be wrong to be applied retrospectively. Retrospective law changes are wrong & unjust. The #LoanCharge is wrong & unjust. Are there different rules for MPs?
14. If you want to discuss #LoanChargeScandal further and hear the truth meet with @keithmgordon, his offer to meet still stands. It is time you & the whole of @HouseofCommons woke up to the truth about this unjust legislation, or is it really preferential rules for MPs?
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I feel compelled to write this open letter to the members of the Loan Charge APPG.
Firstly let me thank your members for all their hard work & support to date for those affected by the #LoanCharge
2. @loanchargeAPPG Please excuse any clumsy language or incorrect assumptions, if they do not apply to you, but I am less eloquent than most MPs.
50k to 100k now have less than a week before the #LoanCharge deadline. This is desparate times, many face ruin.
3. To the 76 members of the @loanchargeAPPG who have signed the letter to @RishiSunak asking for a delay to the #LoanCharge deadline I salute you all for your unwavering support. But I must ask where are the signatures from the other 159 members? Where are these MPs when needed.
1. Who'd have thought that amongst all the 1000s of qualified people in Life Sciences in this country that the person chosen to lead the vaccine task force would be the wife of a Tory minister. What are the odds on that happening? @TheCanaryUKherefordtimes.com/news/18457643.…
2. Makes you wonder if they are more interested in giving handouts to their inner circle than finding a vaccine. I am sure that @Jesse_Norman's wife is very competent but it does raise the question as to whether this was to salve the tough ride Norman has faced with #LoanCharge
3. After all the #LoanCharge policy pushed forward by the Tories resulted in @Jesse_Norman being named in a suicide note for 1 of the 7 suicides caused by this retrospective legislation. Surely Jesse deserves something from his Tories buddies for having such a tough time.
2. @andrealeadsom Mary Aiston (MA): ....HMRC is not going to make people sell their homes to pay their disguised remuneration tax bills.
Chair: Is that a confirmed policy?
MA: Yes
Chair: You are putting that on the record here....
MA: Yes data.parliament.uk/writtenevidenc…
3. @andrealeadsom Can you ask the current chair of @CommonsTreasury@MelJStride to call Mary Aiston to sit before them again to explain this lie & the many others she told to the committee on 30/09/19 about the #LoanCharge
1. @Keir_Starmer 's templated reply sent to loads of people impacted by the #LoanCharge is not only insulting it also shows how ill informed @UKLabour leadership & their front benches are on this matter. I will quote from the letter in this thread. @Bill_Esterson@patmcfaddenmp
2. 'Labour have not opposed the Government’s changes to the loan charge...'
There were no Gov lchanges to oppose, there were changes proposed by @DavidDavisMP to support. Those changes would restore the access to normal judicial process which #LoanCharge removes. @Keir_Starmer
3. 'Labour have not opposed the Government’s changes to #LoanCharge, as it is clamping down on tax avoidance schemes.'
@Keir_Starmer it's not clamping down on tax avoidance schemes it is penalising people who were advised to use the arrangements. Promoters get off scot-free
1. @AnnelieseDodds@Bill_Esterson@Keir_Starmer pls understand #LoanCharge & then really think hard about whether abstaining from voting on #NC31 is the right thing to do.
After 7 suicides I don't believe staying silent is the morally correct thing to do, in fact I know it isn't.
1. #LoanCharge
Why don't we discuss @HMRCgovuk 's own admission that the Loan Schemes that 1000s used were legal. This admission is evidenced by the language they have used, not once is legality mentioned, and by the fact that in 20yrs they have not taken 1 promoter to court.
2. This is a letter I rec'd from @HMRCgovuk in 2014 it states 'The promoters of these arrangements said that the amounts described as loans were not subject to tax as income'. They acknowledge we were given advice but 'if' wrong promoters must have acted fraudulently. #LoanCharge
3. 2014 letter from @HMRCgovuk also says 'HMRC strongly believes that these arrangements do not work & the amounts described as loans are taxable' . They don't say:
- they break any laws
- they are illegal
'Strongly believes' is an opinion not a statement of fact. #LoanCharge