Seth Abramson Profile picture
Nov 10, 2021 22 tweets 4 min read Read on X
The far right disinformation campaign on the Steele dossier is as aggressive a disinformation campaign as America has ever seen.

The indictments they cite don’t say what they say they do; the dossier doesn’t say what they say it does; they’re rewriting our history in scary ways.
We’ve reached the point where you can't even state basic facts about the Steele dossier without nutcases showing up to tell you those basic facts are wrong.

And U.S. corporate media, because it sees no money anymore in the Trump-Russia scandal, is letting those lies proliferate.
The number of people aware of what the dossier says and how much of it was confirmed is dwindling. The number of people who understand Steele’s background and that the dossier was raw intel is dwindling. The number of people who know how the dossier came to light is dwindling.
No, the dossier did’t launch the Russia probe. No, the dossier doesn’t allege there’s a Trump sex tape. No, Steele didn’t tell the FBI the dossier was 100% accurate. No, none of Bill Barr appointee John Durham’s indictments have *anything* to do with the *content* of the dossier.
No, nothing in the dossier has been conclusively disproven. No, it’s not true media wasn’t able to find corroboration for any of the dossier. Yes—some of the dossier has been confirmed. No, there’s no evidence the dossier was a Russian intel operation. This is all disinformation.
And when Trump runs for POTUS in 2024, the disinformation that corporate media thinks is irrelevant today—is issuing no pushback on today—will be shouted by Trump at every single campaign rally for a year. Media is digging America’s grave by not responding to this disinformation.
Those of us who are derided as blind defenders of the Steele dossier have done nothing more—literally *not a single thing more*, since January of 2017—than ask that reporting on the dossier be *accurate* instead of a systematized disinformation campaign coordinated by Team Trump.
Right after the dossier was released nearly five years ago, I wrote on Twitter that it was likely around one-third *inaccurate*—exactly as its author told the FBI and the media at the time. I also said that another third of it probably was—by its nature—incapable of confirmation.
So when I wrote a book in 2018 that in minor part analyzed the question of whether there was corroboration for the remaining third of the dossier, I did so using only major-media sources. I found that some of that third had been confirmed and some had a mountain of corroboration.
I also made sure to carefully analyze Steele’s background and the manner by which his dossier went to the FBI and eventually came to light. I don’t think I’ve ever seen a man more lied about in American media than Chris Steele, nor work-product more lied about than his raw intel.
There’s now a viral clip of a host from The View haranguing Schiff about Durham’s latest indictment. The host falsely says the Danchenko indictment proves that Danchenko lied about the *content* of the dossier—made it all up. But the indictment has nothing to do with any of that.
Those of us who have been *painstaking* in sourcing our journalism on the Trump-Russia investigation are watching in horror as Trumpist insurrectionists and other far-right demagogues are effortlessly rewriting U.S. history without any pushback whatsoever. It’s truly a nightmare.
Mark my words, and save this tweet: the cowardice and laziness major media is showing now by permitting genuine villains to spread disinformation about Steele’s dossier and major-media reporting on the dossier will come to haunt America in 2023 and 2024 to an unimaginable degree.
Trump colluded with Russia.

He didn’t do it by helping them hack Democratic Party computers—and no one in media ever said he did.

He didn’t do it by funding the Kremlin’s propaganda ops—and no one in media said he did.

But that he colluded with the Russians is beyond doubt.
His Russia policy was written by Russian nationals and agents. He was secretly negotiating a deal with the Kremlin for his whole campaign—and lied to voters about it. He hid his many efforts to profit from his relationships in Russia. He knew his campaign head was a Russian pawn.
He withheld information about his team’s secret meetings with Russian agents from U.S. law enforcement. He greenlit a secret backchannel between himself and the Kremlin. He lied about whether the Kremlin had compromising information about him. His Russia policy betrayed America.
He publicly invited Russia to wage cyberwar on America. He spread what he knew was Kremlin disinformation. He sought to bolster a nonstate intelligence agency he knew was doing Russia’s bidding. He greenlit his team seeking dirt on Clinton from Russian hackers. He did Putin’s PR.
He obstructed justice and tampered with witnesses in the Russia probe. He helped his family cover up a meeting with Kremlin agents in his home. He pardoned at least three men he knew had secretly colluded with Moscow. He signed secret letters of intent to do business in Moscow.
He deliberately advanced Russian efforts to invade Europe, destroy NATO, and wage a domestic information war inside the United States. And all of this is just the tip of the iceberg.

And none of Trump’s defenders can deny any of this. They simply *lie about the dossier* instead.
They take the actual allegations against Trump and transform them into allegations that were never made so they can “refute” them. They pretend the dossier was an *report* rather than raw intel requiring additional follow-up. They call people Kremlin agents who are U.S. allies.
They impute knowledge to people even after it’s confirmed these people didn’t have the knowledge imputed to them. They build slogans they know are false—like “Clinton paid a Russian spy to interfere in the 2016 elecrion”—not because it’s true but because they know it’ll go viral.
The people pushing these lies are bad people who intend to end American democracy in the next 36 months. And the people in media who refuse to push back against these lies are cowards collecting a paycheck as Rome burns.

And those of us disgusted watching all this feel helpless.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Seth Abramson

Seth Abramson Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SethAbramson

Feb 25
I only went to Harvard Law and have three terminal graduate degrees, including a PhD, so I apologize if this is a question a drooling moron would ask, @yhbryankimiq, but is there a reason you do not list his accomplishments?

Is it because none are his—but those of his employees?
I know this is a difficult concept for Elongelicals, so let me use their favorite form of argument: anecdote.

I have 5 higher-ed degrees; I earned them all personally and in the shortest possible period of time.

Elon flamed out at three colleges and was *not* admitted to a PhD.
I’ve founded 4 startups: a consulting company and three media outlets, one a multimillion-dollar operation. I had no seed money for my startups but the little in my bank account.

Musk had money from his dad’s emerald mines and $300 million via Zip2—the idea for which wasn’t his.
Read 37 tweets
Feb 20
As an Elon Musk biographer, I would peg his IQ as between 100 and 110. There’s zero evidence in his biography of anything higher.

And I want to repeat that now, lest you think it a typo.

There’s zero evidence, from his life history, of Musk having anything higher than a 110 IQ.
Stepped away from Twitter for a number of hours—on the basis of this not being a platform worth spending time on—and came back to find this tweet went viral because Nate Silver thinks Carlyle's 1800s theory of history, the Great Man Theory, is still relevant to historians in 2025
I understand the MAGAsphere runs on dudes who stayed at a Holiday Inn last night and are now expert astrophysicists, but another possibility is Musk's biographers know him better than fanboys do, and historians know more than pollsters about history.

🔗: sethabramson.substack.com/p/proof-of-des…Image
Read 45 tweets
Feb 17
I mean I'm just an American lawyer, so what do I know compared to a nepo baby whose money initially came from Zambian emerald mines, but under the United States Constitution and the thousands of Supreme Court decisions interpreting it for 250 years, free speech is *not* absolute
And I guess I would add to that, @ElonMusk, that if you don't know what I just said already, while you do not *have* to shut the f*** up under the First Amendment, you absolutely *should* shut the f*** up until you know what the f*** you're talking about, you *petulant man-child*
@elonmusk MAGAism is feelings over facts

All I ever hear Trump voters say is not what is true by law but what they think *should* be true, not actually how anything works but how they *wish* it would work

When you are poorly educated and know nothing, all you have is your Big Feelings
Read 5 tweets
Feb 4
If you wonder why civil commitment statutes exist, the extremely dangerous derangement Musk is exhibiting publicly is why

He's now accused multiple federal agencies of being criminal operations, accused many federal officials of being criminals, and seems to believe he is POTUS
America is watching the mental collapse of the richest man on Earth in real time—and it's only a question of how many markets collapse, how many millions of people lose their jobs, and how many people die due to his actions before someone who cares about him tries to get him help
Clearly not one member of his family is willing to get off the gravy train to stand up to him and tell him that he needs to get off drugs, take a break from public life, and be hospitalized for a period of time

His employees know he is deranged but are obviously terrified of him
Read 7 tweets
Jan 29
(📢) NEW at PROOF: This is my most important report on Elon Musk as a Musk biographer.

Read this and you’ll understand the man.

“Two Essays From Longtime Musk Friends Have Just Revealed Musk’s Supervillain Origin Story” (🔗):

Warning: dark stuff inside. sethabramson.substack.com/p/two-viral-es…Image
(Elon is throttling this feed. If you want anyone to see this new report, please RETWEET the post above.)
1/ One of the things that most surprised me about these revelations is how a number of them relate to the current nomination of Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and the support Elon Musk has for it. As well as the support he had for Kennedy becoming President of the United States.
Read 22 tweets
Jan 9
Here it is: the new PROOF report on Musk. Massive, fully sourced, horrifying. The silver lining is that what Musk is up to and what he wants is becoming clearer.

🔗:

Spoiler alert: it has nothing to do with caring about children—he doesn’t and never has. sethabramson.substack.com/p/elon-musk-ma…Image
1/ What I want to underscore about my work as an Elon Musk biographer is that it’s never my intention to suggest Mr. Musk is playing 4D chess.

To be a Musk biographer not writing hagiographies is to be singularly unimpressed with his apparent average intelligence. But that said:
2/ When you’re the richest and most powerful man on Earth, the field that you’re playing on—not as a matter of how you play it—is just different.

Elon Musk has resources that no one else can imagine, and therefore he is able to have ambitions that few others could or would dare.
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(