Democrats were THIS CLOSE to backing meaningful “police reform” (whatever that means, body cams for the body cams? banning chokeholds for the fourth time?) but those meddling defund kids messed it. Otherwise it would have absolutely been a real thing that would have happened
8cantwait were a series of “requirements” state and city lawmakers would insist police departments would suggest to police they abide by. Several of which were already on the books for years and no one ever followed already
Theres a sophisticated perma-reform regime of PR firms, partisan hack think tanks & nonprofit limited hangouts specifically set up to waterdown reform efforts thats been around for decades & it’d be good if the “defund is too far” crowd would at least try & engage w/ this reality
The thing is we have an A-B test for this theory. Eric Adams is said to be the SENSIBLE refomer, who aggressively and openly hated “defund” but was a “Real reformer” who would get practical reform through. So I will circle back to this tweet in a year and see what he gets done
The NYT told us during the primary that Adams “supports police reform” but since his election has hinted he will oppose the already modest and watered down bail reform and has openly called for bringing back the notorious “jump out boys” who were disbanded in 2020
This is sort of one of the main criticisms of “reform” framing, it’s that it means nothing and carries with it absolutely zero politically commitments and Donald Trump supports “police reform” and is deliberately vague
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Bail reform in NY was already very watered down, now supposed Rational and Reasonable Reformer Eric Adams wants to basically kill it. Remember: this is about caging humans for months, sometimes years, before they’ve even had a trial, much less been found guilty of anything.
Again, BLM & abolitionists were scolded time & again during the campaign by the Serious People at the NYT and MSNBC that Adams was going to “balance” “real reform” w/ “safety”. Other than cosmetic changes in leadership: what actual reforms has Adams proposed since he was elected?
Proposals Adams has made since primary win:
✔️ Ending school mask mandate
✔️ Bringing back “jump out boys” NYPD unit that was shelved in 2020 because it harassed and killed so many black people
✔️ Teaching “crypto in schools”
✔️ Hiring more police officers
Yes! A 1859 NYT editorial scolding abolitionists as unreasonable and doing harm to the cause of opposing slavery is a fascinating read, especially the part where they say “silence on the part of the north concerning slavery would be the best policy”
“The very best thing that could possibly be done towards the abolition of Slavery would be for the North to stop talking about it.”
“Ten years of absolute silence would do more than fifty of turmoil and hostility, towards a peaceful removal of the evil. It is quite possible that the Abolition crusade may force a bloody and violent termination of the system, but this no sane man desires”
This is such a smart gambit by Hawley, just the perfect superficially appealing fake bullshit. Here, white rural communities aren’t suffering because private equity firms like the one Hawley used to be a lawyer for gutted jobs, but due to vague moral failings
The problem is a moral one not a material one, its origins are immigrants, academics, feminists, gays, the Chinese & the wokes not the interior rich & petty bourgeois owners who fund Hawley’s campaign & whose interests he serves & who drive down your wages & gut your labor laws
Self help Christian woo woo is smart, it speaks to a genuine human need and fills a real void but offers warmed over MRA dogma mixed with capital-serving victim blaming
Theft and property crimes are not a moral failing but the product of poverty & widespread social failures and I’m not “defending” it (whatever that means) I’m criticizing reporters and editors doubling as vigilantes targeting a population that is, by definition, unhoused and poor
The US is BY FAR the most criminalized nation in earth. We make up 5% of the world’s population but 24% of its incarcerated population. If arresting people prevented crimes the US would have the lowest crime rate among rich nations but it has one of the highest.
Maybe, for the love of god, we can think of another way to solve theft and property crime than demanding, as these reporters are, more cops arrest more homeless people? Huh? Maybe? Maybe we can think a little outside the fucking box on this one??
Why do people think theyre clever pointing out longterm radical projects are presently unpopular. At the time of his killing MLK had a 75% disapproval rating, including ~50% among AA’s. In 1859 the NYT condemned militant abolitionists & called John Brown “a wild & absurd freak”
For yrs polls showed a majority of black South Africans opposed sanctions on South Africa. By the mid 80s this flipped and a majority supported them. But for over a decade the movement to sanction SA wasn’t supported by most black South Africans. Then they had their minds changed
In the early 1960s lunch counter sit-ins were widely loathed and JFK sent his brother to scold civil rights activists for making democrats look bad and instigating southern whites and, you guessed it, costing them votes
From the astute school of political analysis that brought you “poll taxes are just about govt revenue”, “the southern strategy is really about states rights”, and “the Tea Party was just worried about high taxes” comes “CRT is just about being aspirational and postracial”
Man, that semester of journalism school where they teach reporters to have the most generous, literal-minded and ahistoric reading of obviously bullshit right wing dog whistles needs to be abolished & replaced w/ literally anything else, 12 hrs a week of staring at an empty wall
I often wonder, when people like Nate go over to their friend’s house and they open their fridge & their friend says “have whatever you like” if they grab the ice cube trays & walk out because they are apparently pathologically incapable of grasping that words have social context