Bill Baue Profile picture
17 Nov, 19 tweets, 13 min read
HUGE NEWS: The Impact Management Platform (a network of ALL major sustainability standard setters) launched today w/a website that embeds sustainability Thresholds & Allocations throughout (including a dedicated Landing Page.)

See @r3dot0 analysis here:
r3dot0.medium.com/reporting-stan…
@r3dot0 This move comes after two decades of standard setters increasingly dropping the ball on integrating sustainability thresholds & allocations at the core of sustainability reporting standards/ guidelines.

So we welcome them finally picking up the ball and ALL now running with it!
@r3dot0 "At its launch today, the Impact Management Platform (IMP) unveiled a new website with a standalone page devoted to Thresholds and Allocations that explains just how to apply these necessary elements of sustainability measurement, management, and reporting.”
@r3dot0 Thresholds & allocations are the key concepts 1st suggested in the Sustainability Context Principle introduced in GRI's 2nd generation (G2) of Sustainability Reporting Guidelines in 2002.

History of Thresholds & Allocations: sustainableorganizations.org/TA-Timeline.pdf

G2: r3-0.org/wp-content/upl…
@r3dot0 Susty Context calls for assessing “the performance of the organisation in the context of the limits & demands placed on economic, environmental, or social resources at a macro-level.”

“limits & demands” = thresholds

org performance / macro-level resources points to allocations
@r3dot0 Thresholds & allocations are also embedded throughout IMP’s “wheel” of actions organizations can take to measure, manage and report their sustainability impacts (especially when it comes to the “Assess Impact” stage).

impactmanagementplatform.org/get-started/or…
@r3dot0 Thresholds & Allocations are also a PRIMARY focus of the excellent video animation on the About page of the IMP website.

vimeo.com/644743370

impactmanagementplatform.org/about/
@r3dot0 IMP’s embrace of thresholds & allocations represents a watershed, hope-filled moment, precisely because the Platform consists of the very players who have, until now, been diluting the rigor of sustainability reporting...
@r3dot0 Earlier this month, the IFRS launched its International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) that fails to embrace the core tenets of sustainability, such as thresholds & allocations as well as inside-out impact and risk assessment.

lse.ac.uk/granthaminstit…
@r3dot0 Earlier this year, the Global Sustainability Standards Board (GSSB) released the GRI Universal Standards that eviscerated the Susty Context Principle by removing requirements to assess performance — despite pleas to retain this vital performance standard!

r3-0.org/wp-content/upl…
@r3dot0 These stances of ISSB and GSSB both fly in the face of guidance on the IMP Thresholds & Allocations landing page, creating confusion for sustainability standard users, who are now confronted with two legitimate options:
@r3dot0 1) Demand that IMP members now walk their talk by aligning their own standards w/IMP guidance on thresholds & allocations; or

2) Apply the IMP thresholds & allocations guidance & ignore the elements of the various sustainability standards that contradict this consensus guidance.
@r3dot0 The IMP Thresholds & Allocations landing page walks users thru a step-by-step explanation of thresholds 1st, then allocations

The explanation uses the Doughnut visualization conceived by @KateRaworth to introduce the concepts of ecological ceiling & social foundation thresholds
@r3dot0 To add allocations to the mix, the IMP Landing Page uses the example of greenhouse gas emissions, where the global threshold must be “downscaled” to the organizational level via “fair and just allocations.”
@r3dot0 The Available Thresholds section of IMP's Thresholds & Allocations Landing Page links to external resources for further guidance, incl @SBT_Network & @UNRISD Sustainable Development Performance Indicators.

impactmanagementplatform.org/thresholds-and…
@r3dot0 @SBT_Network @UNRISD The Landing Page also uses the example of Living Wages to illustrate an instance where allocations are not required, as paying sufficient wages is not a shared burden, but one that falls exclusively on the employer.
@r3dot0 @SBT_Network @UNRISD IMP adopted this approach to thresholds & allocations in part due to its participation in the piloting of a set of thresholds-based (& transformation-based) sustainability indicators in a project hosted by @UNRISD & managed by @r3dot0 (w/ support from @mwmce)
@r3dot0 @SBT_Network @UNRISD @mwmce IMP’s embrace of thresholds & allocations represents a HUGE STEP in the right direction for the future of sustainability reporting that warrants applause!!
@r3dot0 @SBT_Network @UNRISD @mwmce The path is now paved for ALL the sustainability reporting standard setters in the Impact Management Platform to advance authentic, rigorous sustainability reporting in ways that reflect real-world impacts.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Bill Baue

Bill Baue Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @bbaue

17 Nov
"So far, ISSB is just 'blah, blah, blah.’”

Significant that this opinion (riffing on Greta) comes from @SASB Founder Jean Rogers (now Head of ESG at Blackstone), seeing as ISSB absorbed SASB.

Great to see Jean expressing independence from entanglements!

greenbiz.com/article/bob-ec…
@SASB She adds: "Adopting standards before following due process that their own constitution requires is concerning right out of the gate.”

@ProfCarolAdams also identified this fatal flaw.
@SASB Rogers continues: "The second area of concern is the lack of harmonization with GRI and the EU, as the EU is a major IFRS jurisdiction.

It’s just setting up a needless power struggle, and nothing will have been accomplished — just a different flavor of soup."
Read 7 tweets
11 Nov
Thanks to @dvlahov for inviting me & @mwmce to have a conversation (as we’ve been doing for the past decade+) but on the mainstage at the @SustainBrands / @SOCAPmarkets #Integrate21 Conference.

It was fun!

Here’s the deck we used to anchor the convo:

r3-0.org/wp-content/upl…
@dvlahov @mwmce @SustainBrands @SOCAPmarkets We first asked: Is Sustainability “Sustainable”?

To answer that question, we grounded our discussion in the @GRI_Secretariat Sustainability Context Principle as introduced in 2002 in the 2nd generation of Sustainability Reporting Guidelines.

r3-0.org/wp-content/upl…
@dvlahov @mwmce @SustainBrands @SOCAPmarkets @GRI_Secretariat We noted that @GRI_Secretariat inexplicably removed the capitals from the SustyContext Principle in G3.
Read 16 tweets
26 Oct
Watching livestream of book launch for "THRIVE: Fundamentals for a New Economy” that @aheadahead1 & I contributed a chapter to.

dezwijger.nl/programma/boek… Image
@aheadahead1 “There is a lot of bullshit about circular economy” says Chapter Author @hanswstegeman referring to companies like Ikea and H&M that are ultimately about fast fashion and planned obsolescence.
@aheadahead1 @hanswstegeman @KTrebeck says:

"Ronald Reagan once said, ‘There are no limits to growth because there are no limits to our imagination.'

But an economy based on unlimited growth actually shows lack of imagination.

This is a handbook of imaginative ideas for our future to be just, safe, fun"
Read 8 tweets
4 Jul
The Anthropocene reality of financial risk by @BeatriceCrona Carl Folke & @vgalaz

sciencedirect.com/science/articl…

Aligns closely w/@r3dot0 Sustainable Finance Blueprint r3-0.org/wp-content/upl…
@BeatriceCrona @vgalaz @r3dot0 "Complex dynamics, such as threshold effects (tipping points) and strong interactions resulting in cascading effects, are all known drivers of systemic failure in any complex system. Yet
state-of-the-art risk analyses still do not adequately account
for them."
@BeatriceCrona @vgalaz @r3dot0 "Furthermore, most financial risk assessment still relies on historical data, and would underestimate or completely miss the potential for thresholds and cascading effects not previously experienced…"
Read 17 tweets
1 Apr
.@kmac hits the nail on the head!

Europe Should Keep Its Green Bar High, Even If Many Can’t Meet It

Only a small fraction of today’s economic activities would pass a rigorous, science-based assessment for sustainability

bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
@kmac "the taxonomy’s purpose … is to set a very high bar based on what scientists [say] is needed ... to avoid the worst effects of climate change. Instead of assessing sectors or companies as they are now, the taxonomy identifies … what...activities ... will lead to a safer planet"
@kmac This sets it apart from other frameworks, such as the @FSB_TCFD which seek to identify risks arising from climate change.

Or the sustainability reporting project being developed by the @IFRSFoundation, which hosts accounting standards used across the world."
Read 8 tweets
31 Mar
"‘Transformational investment’ requires a ‘transformational framework’” writes Francesco Curto of @DWS_Group

ipe.com/home/guest-vie…

"A transformational investment will not succeed without changes in how we operate. To achieve such frameworks, three objectives must be met:..."
@DWS_Group #3 "Resolve the conflict of interest along the value chain [that] are detrimental to consumers, who face uncertain definitions, higher costs and lack protection as financial products make ESG claims that cannot be verified."
@DWS_Group "Then came a formal complaint by Bill Baue … to the board of the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) about potential conflict of interests. The complaint centred around the proposed methodologies used to guide companies and investors towards net zero…"
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(