Gospel: Today's story of the "widow's mite," where a poor widow gave "from her poverty" to the Temple, is often held up as Jesus's praise of her generosity (Lk 21). But is it? Some NT scholars say Jesus is actually critiquing religious authorities who are exploiting the poor....
Luke likely got the story from Mark. And Luke Timothy Johnson in "Sacra Pagina" notes that Luke follows Mark's order in this part of his narrative "carefully."

The entry from "Sacra Pagina" (Donahue and Harrington) on the original passage in Mark 12 (41-44) is eye-opening...
"The widow is surely generous. But is she generous to a fault? Does Jesus really approve her action? Thus far in Mark 11-12 the Jerusalem Temple and its officials have been treated...
..from a critical perspective (see especially 11:15-19) and in 13:2 Jesus will prophesy the destruction of the Jerusalem Temple--an event that was to occur in 70 CE under the Romans. Thus the context of Mk 12:41-44 raises the question whether the generosity...
...of the poor widow should be taken as an occasion for praise (the usual approach) or for lament (an approach suggested by Addison G. Wright and others). When interpreted as a cause for lament the widow's actions would illustrate the perils...
.of institutional religion whereby the Temple establishment manipulated this generous woman into parting with what little she possessed. At the very least, attention to the Markan context leaves open whether the widow is presented as a model to be imitated...
...for her generosity or as someone to be pitied as the victim of religious exploitation."

"Sacra Pagina," The Gospel of Mark, Donahue and Harrington, p. 365.

Image: "The Widow's Mite," Louis Glanzman.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with James Martin, SJ

James Martin, SJ Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @JamesMartinSJ

22 Nov
As I see it, wearing a Pride shirt is not against any church teaching. Pride shirts and rainbow images are one way for members of a persecuted group to see themselves as beloved children of God. As for the argument that pride equals vanity and is thus sinful...
...the idea of LGBTQ pride is along the same lines as "I'm proud to be Irish." Feelings of value are essential for a group of people, especially youth, who are often told that they're sinful simply for being who they are. Rather, as Psalm 139 says, they are "wonderfully made"....
We also have to remember the high suicide rates among LGBTQ youth, often for this very reason: they are told by many in authority, including religious authorities, that they have no value, and should take no pride in who they are or how God created them...
Read 7 tweets
19 Nov
Gospel: "My house shall be a house of prayer," says Jesus today, quoting Isaiah (Lk 19).

I always think of the Jesuit Community at St. Mary’s Hall at @BostonCollege when I read this passage. On the first floor is a huge iron gate, the old demarcation of the "cloister..." Image
...the dividing line between the public space and the private Jesuit rooms, which reads: “Domus Mea Domus Orationis.”

I was very impressed when I saw that as a first-year novice in the old New England Province. First, because I had never seen anything remotely like it before...
...and second, because I had no idea what the Latin meant. On my first visit, one old Jesuit priest was giving us novices a tour. He pointed to the sign, thoughtfully translated it for us, and then said, “House of Prayer? Well, at least trying not to be a Den of Thieves!”
Read 8 tweets
16 Nov
Gospel: Here is something that may upend how you see today's Gospel, the story of Zacchaeus (Lk 19). Basically, the translations that most Bibles use are inaccurate, as Joseph Fitzmyer, SJ, points out in The Anchor Bible Series; as does Luke Timothy Johnson in Sacra Pagina...
The usual translation is that upon being welcomed by Jesus, Zacchaeus undergoes a conversion experience, and promises to give half of his money to the poor and repay anyone he has defrauded four times over--in the future. Here is the NAB, which we read at Mass today:
"Look, half of my possessions, Lord, I will give to the poor; and if I have defrauded anyone of anything, I will pay back four times as much."

But that's not accurate. As Johnson writes, "In both sentences Zacchaeus uses the present tense..."
Read 8 tweets
16 Nov
On a day when Pope Francis praised the new book of
@MikeOLoughlin, an openly gay man, I was happy to participate in a panel at Gesu Church, a Jesuit parish in Detroit, on welcoming #LGBTQ parishioners. More on Gesu here: gesudetroit.com
Here is the beautiful welcome statement from Gesu's website:

"You are welcome! Reflecting the welcome that Jesus Christ offers to all, Gesu Parish welcomes every person to seek full participation in our parish community and within the Body of Christ....
"We believe that all are worthy of respect and love, because all are created in the image of God. Our welcome is not limited by a person's age, sex, race, cultural background, physical or mental health or ability, sexual orientation, gender identity, social or economic....
Read 5 tweets
7 Nov
Gospel: The story of the "widow's mite," where a poor widow gave "all she had" to the Temple, is usually held up as Jesus's praise of her generosity (Mk 12). But is it? Some NT scholars say Jesus is actually critiquing religious authorities who are exploiting the poor....
This entry from "Sacra Pagina" (Donahue and Harrington) on this passage is eye-opening:

"The widow is surely generous. But is she generous to a fault? Does Jesus really approve her action? Thus far in Mark 11-12 the Jerusalem Temple and its officials have been treated...
...from a critical perspective (see especially 11:15-19) and in 13:2 Jesus will prophesy the destruction of the Jerusalem Temple--an event that was to occur in 70 CE under the Romans. Thus the context of Mk 12:41-44 raises the question whether the generosity...
Read 6 tweets
6 Nov
Gospel: "You cannot serve God and mammon," says Jesus today (Lk 16). The word "mammon" derives from the Hebrew word for money or wealth. But why can't you "serve two masters"? For one thing, your focus will be on the wrong thing. If you make decisions thinking, "How will this... Image
...serve God?" then you will lead a life of love, mercy and compassion. If you make decisions thinking, "How will this make me more money?" then you will lead a different kind of life. Obviously, everyone needs some money to live and to flourish. But when money becomes...
...the thing around which your life is ordered, then it has become a god. Often people smile when they read the First Commandment: "You shall have no other gods before me." They think, "Well, of course, I don't worship little idols or false gods." But if your life revolves...
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(