someone showed me this video. naturally, i wanted to pile on with an explanation, but i'm gonna take a slightly different tack. short 🧵
(video link if you want to watch it.)
it's basically this contrived problem: a really long set of wires, a battery, a switch, and a light bulb.
close the switch, and how long does it take for the light bulb to turn on? i mean everyone who had high school physics played around with batteries, switches, and light bulbs. naturally it's not that simple, because nobody plays with wires that long
@eevblog has a pretty long explanation, so go ahead and watch that too (where do you folks get the time to watch all this stuff anyway?)
the original video reminded me of a lot of stuff i learned about Poynting vectors and EM fields that i rarely use and subsequently forgot. but circuits people like me don't really work with fields, so i'm giving myself a pass. sorry Dave, most EEs aren't great with fields.
i mean yeah the fields look cool and this is a great visualization.
but i much prefer Dave's circuit model. it explains what is going on!
the first key thing to understand is that this is *NOT* a DC circuit! you might think it is, but because we're dealing with a propagation time from a switch closure, this is fundamentally a transient analysis.
a DC circuit would be a battery, a light bulb, two really long pieces of superconducting wire, and the bulb is on and just sits there in a very boring way so we'll not talk about that anymore.
if you look at the switch, closing it means you switch instantaneously from one state to another. the horizontal axis (not shown) here is time.
i'm lazy so i ripped this photo off from the internet. the switch closure *event* is not DC -- take a look at that frequency response!
so what do we know about AC? well, a capacitor looks like a short circuit, and an inductor looks like an open circuit. so is this voltage step going to travel 234234234 miles to make the loop through hordes of lumped inductors, or is it going to take a short cut across this cap?
yeah it'll take the shortcut for sure*

*the highest frequency components will

wait what
yeah the lower frequency components will be able to take a slightly longer path as well. there's current sharing going on. a lot of it goes through the shortest path, but (as the frequency goes down) some more current goes through these other paths as well
so basically you get this ripple effect that spreads out from the area right next to the battery/switch/bulb.

and that is how you get from transmission lines back to fields 😁
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaalmost forgot: as Dave says over and over again, this whole contrived problem depends on the weird shape of the circuit--those wires that are 1 meter apart. if it were a giant circuit of wire 1 light year in diameter, then you have an entirely different problem!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Tube Time

Tube Time Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @TubeTimeUS

26 Nov
so this gif has been making the rounds, with the unhelpful title of "data cable on a computer from 1945". but what computer? what sort of data? let's find out.🧵
the gif is from this YouTube video, an introduction to the ENIAC, where they interview some folks and show off the pieces of the ENIAC on display at the University of Pennsylvania.
but where to start? it turns out we still have the operating manual for the ENIAC! Image
Read 17 tweets
12 Nov
here's a fascinating vintage Swiss washing machine that uses punch cards to program the wash cycle!
"For my laundry, I prefer Schulthess." she's holding the punch cards that she used to select a particular type of wash cycle. i wonder if anyone ever tried to custom make one of these cards... 🤔
turns out the company is still around, and still making washing machines! schulthess.ch i suppose you need one of these if you want your clothes to be Swiss Clean™
Read 8 tweets
15 Oct
want to see a crazy rework? here's a SAS RAID controller card that ran into a little problem. 🧵 Image
two capacitors got ripped off the board. not only that, but they took the pads with them. Image
these are series AC coupling capacitors used for the high speed differential data lane. this means the layout is critical.
Read 9 tweets
13 Oct
here's a repair job from a friend. it's a rather rare IBM PC accelerator card. it's very dirty. let's dig in! Image
separating the two boards, you can see it is divided into a memory board and a CPU board. Image
the upgrade CPU? an 8086. it's not a big upgrade from the 8088 in the PC, but presumably it is clocked twice as fast. Image
Read 105 tweets
12 Oct
oops I got another computer. this one is a PCjr! Image
not a typical PC under the hood. Image
it's dustier than a crypt inside! Image
Read 17 tweets
9 Oct
let's take a break from computers and electronics, and go on a trip! a trip to San Jose. this is one of the rare little spots that's not overdeveloped. you can easily see the East Bay hills. Image
it's starting to feel a bit like the wild west. Image
railroad tracks and buzzards. if you look very carefully in the background, you can see the airship hangars at Moffett Field. Image
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(