Not entirely sure of Elst's intentions here but typically it translates this way as I have seen elsewhere.
Rama was a king, a mere mortal. He was later made into a God. So was Krishna. Infact Krishna Bhakti seems to have influenced deification of Rama.
+
Rama was made a God by making him an Avatar of Vishnu. So it was with Krishna. You see how all these Avatars are constructed? All this is just fiction. These are just stories that are made up to perpetrate falsities and hegemony of a certain class.
+
You see how your religion is full of such falsities. Ours isn't like that...
You know where this goes next.
+
Unfortunately due to strong opinions on caste we have chosen to dismiss traditionalist scholarship enmasse.
This dispute is not new.
Karpatriji's takedown of Camille Bulcke in Ramayana Mimamsa here is very relevant for this thread.
+
Read and indulge with all sides of the story and then decide. Afterall it will come down to the chittha vrutthi / చిత్త వృత్తి of the individual as put poignantly by 'Kavi Samrat' Viswanatha Satyanarayana here
One can choose to see a Kalpavriksham in Ramayana or a Vishavriksham (tree spewing poison). Upto the individual. Same holds for how they perceive Rama as well.
/End
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Facebook reminded me of my reading of this 1998 paper by Prof. Madhav Gadgil et al titled - "Sacred Woods, Grasslands and Waterbodies as Self-organised Systems of Conservation".
+
I read this during my B-school days. They didn't teach. I read. If this stuff is taught as a part of curriculum it will upset young impressionable minds!
+
"If resources earlier valued are now obtained from elsewhere, or in other ways, as for instance, with use of medicinal herbs being abandoned in favour of allopathic drugs, .."
I am convinced that a few decades later as I grow older and as my next generation reads the story of Vinayaka as they perform the rituals of Vinayaka Chaturthi, it will go like this.
Guessing it will all be in English by then anyway.
As per scholars of both east and west, Ganesha worship had originated only from 500 A.D. It was some tribal God who later became the son of Shiva and Parvati. Who concocted this story? Wily Brahmins.
+
Basically your ancestors are idiots. You are a fool that you pray for such in the name of Puja.
Nevertheless here's the story.
There was this asura called Gajasura who did penance and got a boon from Lord Shiva.
+
Haha! I like this coinage "genetic Shangri-La". Prof.Michael Sandel questions this in his recent book on Meritocracy as well.These are uncomfortable questions that many champions of equality refuse to touch. They are positively afraid of the consequences of questioning such.
+
"Is this truly our ideal-a "genetic Shangri-la" where inequalities of life outcome due to poverty and oppression have been removed, but inequalities of life outcomes due to genetics remain? ..."
+
"Why are inequalities that are related to your genes more accept able than inequalities rooted in the social circumstances of your birth? After all, as I've argued throughout this book, both are accidents of birth, forms of luck over which a person has no control"
I wasn't aware of this piece of history!!
From the chapter "Under the Curse of Gold - Kerala's Gold Boom and the Exit of Vishwakarma Goldsmiths" in this book "In search of Vishwakarma - Mapping Indian Craft Histories - Edited by Vijaya Ramaswamy"
+
"State as an 'Apparatus of Capture' also played a dubious role in denigrating the well-to-do position goldsmiths enjoyed till mid twentieth century.
+
The Gold Control Act declared by the Indian state in 1963, and repealed only in 1990, was the most crucial state intervention that changed their status fundamentally.
Facebook reminded of 2019 reading memory - Jerry Mander's
"In the Absence of the Sacred: The Failure of Technology and the Survival of the Indian Nations"
+
"European doubts about the peoplehood of Indians extend back to the murderous explorations of Hernando Cortez in the mid 1500s, among the Indians of Central America and Mexico"
+
"The fate of the Indians became the subject of fierce disagreements within the Catholic Church"