Today's factoid: 2 wks ago I invited people to send examples of how they personally had been affected by Brexit; and a separate tweet requesting positive examples. I got 422 replies to the 1st, many heartrending. 7 replies to the 2nd. This alone is revealing. But there's more...
Of the +ve replies, (all contributed in good faith), one was that UK/US scientists had been able to invent covid vaccines - on which I note this has nothing to do with being in or out of the EU; scientists being able to do such research all along, irrespective of EU membership;
And while in EU, easier for scientists to collaborate with EU counterparts, and benefit from EU Horizon funds. I do acknowledge UK vaccine procurement and distribution effort was v impressive...at least at start of year, though we've now fallen behind, alas.
Second reply was that we're now able to control immigration, since FoM unpopular. To which I note a) we now have shortages of workers in many sectors since so many EU nationals have left; and...
b) as tragedies in channel indicate, we're still not in control of our borders, and outside the EU, can no longer benefit from the EU programme which allowed us to return migrants to the first EU country in which they arrived, so we have even more of a challenge on our hands;
3 of the other replies were arguments contradicting the positive examples given above...along the lines of my own comments
And the last comment offering a positive benefit of Brexit was to the effect that after all the destruction they have wrought, the Tories would one day be held accountable and buried forever as a political force. Now there's a thought.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with alexandra hall hall

alexandra hall hall Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @alexhallhall

1 Dec
I've had many ask why I took the job as Brexit Csllr, if I was as opposed to Brexit as my recent tweets now suggest? Or why I didn't just resign after the ref. I suspect I won't persuade many of my genuine intentions, and apols to those who've heard this before, but here goes...
First, as a professional civil servant, it was not my place to question the decision to hold the referendum, or how it was conducted, or the result. Whatever my personal views on the wisdom or otherwise of leaving the EU, I never felt I had a right to oppose it, while in govt.
Also, like many Remainers, I felt that like it or not, the results of the ref needed to be respected. I also had family members and friends who voted Leave - I disagreed (strongly) with their reasons but respected their right to have their views
Read 18 tweets
27 Nov
Venturing into fraught territory, how do we establish a sustainable, coherent, long term approach on refugees/migrants, that is more humane than current Home Office policy of making life even more miserable for people who are already desperate?…A thread
(On which I have some experience, having headed FCO humanitarian unit in 1990s, covering refugees, war crimes, Geneva Conventions etc; and Hd Human Rights dept in 2000s)
And visited camps/discussed policy on refugees/displaced persons from Vietnam, Cambodia, Burma, Somalia, Rwanda, Syria, Palestine, Colombia, Angola, Afghanistan, Abkhazia, and many, many more over my career
Read 14 tweets
22 Nov
This week I shall try to give more substance to my thread last week about US views on Brexit. But first, some background on why it was so difficult to convince American sceptics that Brexit was a good idea. [Partly in response to critics that I was obviously lousy at my job].
First, the talking points simply lacked substance. Our top lines would be bland assurances (eg "we're committed to the GFA; no hard border;"; "We'll get a new free trade, no tariffs, no quotas deal with EU etc with little detail on how this would be delivered.
Second, the messages were primarily aimed for UK domestic audience, and highly political, so eg contained numerous barbs at the EU, which jarred with assurances Ministers would give to US contacts that of course we would always remain friends and allies of the EU.
Read 15 tweets
21 Nov
I didn't know Richard before, then he reached out to me this week and shared that his reasons for resigning were almost identical to mine...and he writes beautifully. However, I personally think the rot began even earlier than May, to the "bastards" in John Major's time
And, while I agree May botched up, she was grappling with the equivalent "bastards" in her time, prime suspect BoJo, who didn't even have any ideological commitment to Brexit, but used it as a vehicle for his ambition. AND
....it was his kind of tendentious, misleading, reporting from Brussels that misinformed the public and fanned the flames.
Read 4 tweets
18 Nov
Today's thread...a very long one, (sorry) in response to a request that I share how Americans felt about Brexit. Their views were not uniform, and evolved over time. I also don't claim universal knowledge - others may have different perspective, welcome to chip in. Here goes...
Initially, mostly: ok, not sure why you voted to leave the EU, but you Brits are sensible people, must have your reasons, and presumably have a plan. We respect your democracy, and we'll always be close friends and allies..AND
Some cheerleaders - Heritage Foundation, Trump and some of his supporters: Great - we never liked the EU (especially those lecturing pious French and Germans) and now you can shake off the shackles and consolidate with us (ie, do what we want); BUT
Read 26 tweets
17 Nov
Brexit by a thousand cuts: lost jobs, crushed dreams, separated families, more expensive goods, tedious paperwork, supply shortages, staff shortages, fewer uni exchanges, no ski chalets, less music tours, poorer medical treatment, no retirement in the sun...on and on and on.
That's just the effect on individuals. Each and every one of us. Doesn't even begin to cover the broader issues - the state of our Union, peace in NI, decay of institutions, smaller economy, less int'l aid, tarnished global reputation, diminished international influence.
Cake, eat it? Easiest Trade deal in history? New UK-US trade deal? 350 million for the NHS. Controlled borders. Sovereignty? We can try to blame the EU for "punishing us", and whinge about the dastardly French all we like. But we put ourselves in this position. Own goal.
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(