In addition to its terrible injustice, this grim story may be of special interest to #Motherisk families (speaking of #accountability):
Broadwater was convicted on two pieces of evidence: Sebold's account; and a now-debunked #hair analysis: cnn.com/2021/11/24/us/…
🧵
1/
#Motherisk families were destroyed because #SickKids idol Dr Gideon Koren was believed about #hair samples arising from his allegedly "forensic" analysis.
Indeed, he was believed for a very long time. thestar.com/news/crime/201…
2/
But...did we miss the public report on "the vast body of work" by #SickKids and #Motherisk doc Koren (who was the object of fulsome praise from Dean of @uoftmedicine for his "research output")?....
2/n
#SickKids has promised a “systematic exam” of Koren’s papers to “protect the integrity of the existing medical literature.” @UofT assured the public it would 'take appropriate actions’ if findings involved individuals at U of T”. Nearly 3 years ago. thestar.com/news/investiga…
3/n
Recovery is possible after more than research misconduct. Koren's #Motherisk lab made million$ selling unverified hair tests, tearing apart vulnerable families, prompting two govt-commissioned inquiries retractionwatch.com/2019/02/19/con…
Unlike Motherisk families, Koren has thrived...
2/4
"Gideon Koren: so toxic that he had to surrender his medical licence and flee Canada... is Professor at the Adelson Medical School at Ariel University."
🙏 Prof Leonid Schneider forbetterscience.com/2020/06/29/mot…
3/4
💯 @BRAINCURES
True w/ other forms of ’investigations’ of academic #misconduct; I've never seen it go any other way: institutions attack or protect, depending on loyalties.
As I draft this (long) chapter of my book, thinking about institutional #accountability, a thread ... 1/6
At @uoftmedicine, carefully selected "consultants”, paid to “review” #Pharma-related scandal, gathered “information" from selected senior academics who lied, yet were believed. The “review" resulted in yrs of adverse actions against my colleagues & me: jme.bmj.com/content/30/1/8
2/6