Today I went walking in the hills and got so wet and cold I could hardly move my fingers and my hands were like raw meat. On returning to my house I put the heating on, changed into warm clothes and thought of the 27 men,women, and children who drowned in the Channel. That was
just over a week ago, but already the crocodile tears have dried on the faces of politicians. Already the ‘tragedy’ is slipping down the memory hole. So far there has been no investigation into allegations that the French and British ignored their calls for help and left them
floating in freezing waters, buffeted by waters that Channel swimmers smear themselves in grease to swim in even in the summer, clinging onto their deflated dinghy for hours till, one by one, they let go and abandoned themselves to death. Now
they are already being forgotten by the countries whose borders they dared to cross ‘without permission.’ Here are some of them, the men, women and children we call ‘migrants’, ‘illegals’ and ‘invaders’. When I look at these pictures I see the love, hope and laughter
in their faces, and I wonder what they would have given to the world and what they had already given, and what lives they might have lived here. But they weren’t allowed to, because men & women who have never know war or persecution, who have never known houses without heating,
who have never had to sleep out in the cold, who only cross the Channel to buy cheap wine or enjoy the pleasures of La Belle France, were afraid of them, or believed that these people had come to take ‘our’ benefits. I thought of these people in their warm homes
angrily shaking their heads when politicians like Farage brag about their prescience in drawing attention to the ‘migrant crisis.’ I thought of the politicians using false security rhetoric about ‘people traffickers’ and pretending to care about the people who
undertake these journeys. I thought how small they are, these greedy, opportunist politicians who peddle fear and hatred to distract from their own egregious misgovernance; the red faced fascists trying to stop lifeboats from saving people and calling their crew ‘traitors’
because they save people from drowning. I thought what a disgrace it is that a powerful advanced capitalist democracy that never stops talking about ‘values’, that uses these ‘values’ as a justification for waging war and then refuses to accept more than the bare minimum
of refugees from these wars. I thought how unbelievable it is that people can be persuaded to behave with such routine inhumanity and yet how easy it is to manipulate them with false narratives about invasion and sovereignty, till they cling to the illusion of ‘strong borders’
and ‘controlling’ our borders, regardless of the consequences. But more than anything, I felt an overwhelming sadness at these lives that were lost and all I could do about it was come on Twitter, and say, enough. No more deaths. Safe routes now. For their sake. And ours.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Matt Carr

Matt Carr Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @MattCarr55

3 Dec
Is there going to be an investigation into the horrific claims made on the Kurdish Rudaw News website? Or have we become a country that is ok with this now? rudaw.net/english/world/…
Last night Fiona Bruce asked on Question Time, ‘how do we stop them coming?’ This is how some of ‘them’ spent their last hours on earth
Here are some of ‘them’. Do we not feel any anger, horror, or pity that they died so horrifically? That they felt obliged to make these journeys in the first place?
Read 6 tweets
14 Aug
Lots of Tory MPs and Republicans handwringing about #AfghanistanBurning right now. Some Labour MPs joining in. Some of these lamentations are aimed at Biden. Others bewail a more general ‘betrayal of Afghan women’/wasted British and U.K. sacrifice/NATO failure etc
No acknowledgement of the strategic failures that were obvious - to those who wanted to look - long before the collapse of the Afghan state. Or the horrific damage inflicted on Afghanistan by so many countries in the savage geopolitical competition for Mackinder’s ‘heartland’
Let’s go back to March 17 1979. The Soviet Politburo meets to discuss the deteriorating security situation in Afghanistan, where the USSR’s communist allies are savagely suppressing and Islamist insurrection in Herat. Foreign minister Andrei Gromyko explains the situation
Read 33 tweets
5 Jun
Let’s have a look at the ‘way of life’ Lee Anderson wants to defend, shall we ? The former Labour councillor-turned-conservative certainly has a colourful record
In 2021, he was appointed to the Women and Equalities Committee, even though he had previously been reprimanded by the party: mirror.co.uk/news/politics/…
In 2019 he was caught on video setting up a supposedly impromptu doorstep with a constituent he already knew: theguardian.com/politics/2019/…
Read 14 tweets
4 Jun
This clip really does remind me why Miliband lost. Why Labour lost and will lose. For Labour to adopt a ‘Rejoin’ position wld be political suicide. But to ‘embrace’ Brexit and praise it as a ‘big idea’ is a painfully shallow, opportunistic and dishonest populist ploy. Why?
1) Because Brexit is transparently not a ‘big idea’ in any meaningful sense. Its grandiose aspirations - such as they are - are entirely disconnected from any realistic understanding of the real world, whether in regard to trade, migration, or geopolitics.
It’s a ‘big idea’ only in the sense that ‘Make America Great Again’ is a big idea. Brexit is based on a very similar combination of bitter nationalism, national exceptionalism, national victimhood, all fused with imperial nostalgia. This isn’t ‘big’; it’s toxic and dangerous.
Read 12 tweets
7 May
Conventional wisdom has is that voters should never be blamed, only politicians. As if voters are inherently virtuous.

They aren't. And what I see now is politicians & voters reinforcing each others' worst instincts and working together to turn UK politics into a moral vacuum
To put another way. If you voted Tory yesterday you don't care that tens of thousands of people have died who needn't have died if the government had acted more quickly and managed the pandemic more coherently
You're not bothered that the virus was effectively seeded in care homes, that billions of pounds have been siphoned up in NHS procurement contracts that produced inferior outcomes, that a Test & Trace system has never worked, despite the vast sums thrown at it
Read 14 tweets
15 Mar
One of the striking similarities between rightwing populist movements in the UK and US is the way they present a vision of society in thrall to 'the far left' or 'commies' at a time when the left is largely powerless in practical terms in both countries.
They do this by presenting even left-of-centre movements/individuals as 'far left' or 'socialist' when they are nothing of the kind. Thus Biden and the Democrats are described as 'radical', and moderate soc democratic reforms as 'communism/Venezuela' etc
When it's pointed out that the 'far left' doesn't have power in either country, they will throw in the (false) idea that the left has a cultural hold on society to compensate for its distance from government, and uses this power to attack 'their history/institutions' etc
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(