First, the idea of Magazine cover as contrarian indicators, and especially TIME PoY was developed by one of Wall Street's greatest thinkers, Paul Macrae Montgomery.
I was honored to call him a friend. @ritholtz remembrance in 2014
One year later and Biden's approval rating is in the tank and Ds are figuring out what to do with Harris
4/15
2007 Putin was PoY. In 2008 the Russian stock market fell 75%.
5/15
In 1999 Jeff Bezos of Amazon was POY and the following year (2000) saw the peak of the 1990s tech stock mania.
BY 2001 Amazon’s stock was down 94% from its 1999 peak.
6/15
1997 Andy Grove of Intel was POY and Intel finished 1998 poorly.
7/15
1991 Ted Turner of Turner Broadcasting was POY. The next year his stock struggled.
8/15
In 1989 Soviet Union leader Mikhail Gorbachev was Person of the Decade (1980s).
Within two years his country ceased to exist, and he was living a meager life on a state-provided pension.
9/15
In 1979 the Ayatollah Khomeini was POY. Crude oil peaked in 1980 and held this level for a decade.
10/15
1974 Saudi King Faisal was POY. 1975, like 1980, each saw a major high in crude oil.
11/15
In 1966 the “under 25 generation” (baby boomers) was POY.
Econ historians will recognize 1966 as the beginning of the rise in inflation that ended in 1980. Boomers resource usage was a big reason.
Also, “Middle America” was POY in 1969 underscoring this theme.
12/15
1970 West German Chancellor Willy Brandt was PoY.
By May 1971, to support a struggling West Germany pulled out of the Bretton Woods fixed exchange rate agreement. The U.S. followed suit in August 1971.
The West German stock market finished 1971 down for the year.
13/15
In 1955 GM President Harlow Curtice was POY. That year GM became the first corp. ever to surpass $1B in sales.
This was also the year Engine Charlie Wilson, the former CEO of GM and Secretary of Defense said, “What’s good for General Motors is good for the country.”
14/15
In 1955 90% of all cars sold in the US were made by the big three, and 45% were GM cars. This was the high-water mark.
GM stocks struggled in 1956 and has yet to recover 65 years later!
15/15
Additionally in 1929 Walter Chrysler of the Chrysler Corp was POY.
This was the year the stock market crashed and the onset of the Great Depression.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
It is correct that the new home premium (green) above existing home prices (blue) has collapsed from 38% in 2013 to below zero today (the lowest in 54 years).
Why?
See new home prices (orange), they stalled.
3/7
Here is the average home price (orange) and the home's size (blue). The reason prices are falling is that builders are constructing smaller homes.
But as the bottom panel shows (green), the price per square foot is as high as ever.
I assume Marks is referring to the 1-year forward P/E ratio for the S&P 500, the standard Wall Street valuation metric (which is closer to 25 now, but was 23 a few weeks ago).
Here is a long-term proxy for that ... the Shiller Cyclically Adjusted Price/Earnings (CAPE) ratio back to 1881. It is a 10-year average of P/E/ ratios.
At 40, it is one of the highest readings ever, even higher than 1929.
It shows the NEXT (future) 1-year REAL (after inflation) return of the stock market on the y-axis.
The CAPE on the x-axis.
The red box is the returns when the CAPE is above 34. It's a mixed bag of positive and negative returns.
Restated, valuation is NOT a good timing tool.
3/4
But if the y-axis is extended to the NEXT (future) 5-year REAL (after inflation) return, then THERE IS NO EXAMPLE, OVER THE LAST 150 YEARS, OF THE STOCK MARKET BEATING INFLATION OVER THE NEXT 5-YEARS WHEN THE CAPE IS ABOVE 34.
Restated, valuation is an expectation tool. Unless one makes the case that corporate earnings are going to have their most significant surge in history, the stock market is destined to disappoint over the next several years.
The preliminary November University of Michigan Consumer Sentiment Survey was released this morning (blue). The "current conditions" measure of this survey set a new ALL-TIME LOW.
Before 2020 (COVID), the stock market (red) was the primary driver of the public's economic outlook. These two series moved up and down together. Since COVID, this relationship has completely disconnected.
This leads to some uncomfortable explanations.
Half of the country owns no assets and lives paycheck to paycheck. Have they now moved to being angry at a booming stock market that worsens inequality? Is this why socialists are getting elected? Do they want their agenda to knock the market down? Is a bear market now the goal, not the concern?
2/6
Why the anger?
Since the COVID recession ended in April 2020, cumulative price increases (orange) have outpaced cumulative wage increases (blue).
This devastates the bottom 50% of wage earners (and especially the bottom 30%) who own no assets and live paycheck-to-paycheck. They are having to do with less.
3/6
For comparison, the opposite happened in the 2010s. The cumulative gain in wages (blue) beat the cumulative rise in prices (orange).
In this scenario, the bottom 50% of wage earners were able to make ends meet and maybe get a little ahead, as their paychecks bought a bit more each year.
JP Morgan has identified 41 AI-related stocks, 8% of the S&P 500. These stocks now account for 47% of the Index's market capitalization, a new record.
The other 459 stocks, 92% of the S&P 500, are 53% of the Index's market capitalization.
2/5
The list of the AI-related stocks
3/5
ChatGPT was released on November 29, 2022.
Since this date, these 41 stocks have accounted for 74% of the S&P 500's total increase (blue). The other 25% came from the remaining 459 stocks (orange).