If you missed it yesterday, we felt this essay about the First World War--my father wrote it--was the right way to begin explaining the significance of the Ukraine crisis, of which many seem to be saying, "Why does it matter?" claireberlinski.substack.com/p/the-great-war
That war gave birth to the modern world. We have never recovered from it. We *can't* recover it, because once you know such a thing is possible, you can never unlearn it.
Western civilization will never again be as buoyantly confident and optimistic. *Human* civilization will never be as confident or optimistic. We are all children of that war, whether we know its details or not.
The worst thing, though, is that as memory of it fades, we continue to bear the scars and the trauma without knowing, really, where they come from. In world affairs as in life, that is a recipe for repetition compulsion.
The lessons are ones we would do well to remember when we imagine that a war in Europe would surely somehow be contained to a peripheral skirmish.
That is possible, of course. But it is not the only possibility.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Hi @MoneyGram, I'm case number 22249950. Just over a month ago, you revoked my account because you "identified it as being at high risk of fraud, scams, or other associated activity which may include a violation of MoneyGram’s Terms and Conditions."
I sent you an email asking why and what I could do to assure you that a) I'm the real Claire Berlinski; and b) I truly *do* want to send money to a family in Afghanistan--the beneficiaries of this fundraiser: gofundme.com/manage/please-…
This was your reply. I've heard nothing from you since.
This family needs the money I'm trying to send them. I'm sure you've heard that things are not going well in Afghanistan.
Generous donors contributed to that GoFundMe account.
So, last night I ordered a meal from @DeliverooHelp. It was never delivered. Not at all. No food. Nothing. Since then, I have tried politely to get @deliveroofrance's attention via email and DM. I've provided them with all the information about the order.
I've reminded them, politely.
They have not answered.
I spent more than 30 euros on a meal that wasn't delivered. That's a lot of money for a meal that wasn't delivered, isn't it?
I would expect not only a refund, but an apology.
Instead, I'm being ignored.
What's the word for taking someone's money but failing to provide the good promised in exchange?
She has to swing far enough right to win the (significant) part of the electorate that's very, *very* far to the right in the 1st round. Otherwise, she won't make it: She needs the people who now say they'll vote for Le Pen & Zemmour.
But then she'll (almost surely) be facing off against Macron, and there will be no left candidate. Most of France is *not* very, very far to the right. If she persuades Zemmour/Le Pen voters that she's right-wing enough for them, she will surely alienate the center and left.
So I've been picking random locations in the US, finding random high schools, and looking at the assigned reading. Kids are reading Shakespeare, for sure, at this high school in Wisconsin: k12.com/content/dam/sc…
And this high school in Dallas is having a Shakespeare monologue competition. That sounds intellectually wholesome: udallas.edu/constantin/aca…
A few thoughts about this. 1) Your question is rhetorical, but the answer is obvious: It's because no one is scared of Ukraine, which doesn't have nuclear weapons. This is what is *so* morally--and long-term, strategically--obtuse:
2) Why doesn't Ukraine have nuclear weapons? Because *we forced them to give them up.* And in turn, guaranteed their territorial integrity. No matter how people try to argue the Budapest Memorandum doesn't count, it does:
3) Why? Because if we don't stand by it, what kind of damned fool will ever give up his nuclear weapons, or abandon his program to build them, because we promise that in exchange, we won't let anyone chew them up and spit them out?