Culture writing is so bad right now. I feel a bit morally torn about even exposing my followers to this paragraph
2/ Parks and Recs "is now widely considered" to be bad because a half dozen similarly neurotic tastemakers who don't know what fiction is or is for said so on their glorified blogs
3/ "I am mad at this sitcom because it does not reflect the up-to-the-minute politics of my most influential Twitter follows" is a view held by perhaps 1% of the population and 80% of mainstream culture writers
4/ It may have been a mistake to hire a bunch of people who have raging contempt for culture to write about culture
5/ Look I don't want to overstate this but I'm just saying that the Constitution should have a carveout explicitly stating it doesn't apply to anyone who dislikes this show
6/ I can't resist returning to this. As we all remember from the musical, it is about Alexander Hamilton resisting the lure of working outside the system in some sort of (for lack of a better term) revolutionary manner and instead embracing moderation and incremental bureaucracy.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ This journalist said he'd been cured of his trauma in 2011 via violent sex. A decade later, he again says he's been cured, now via major, risky surgery. I think there are some really fraught journalistic challenges inherent to covering the first-person accounts of folks who
2/ have dealt with profound trauma and/or other mental-health problems. One key thing you'll be taught in any Psych 101 course is that individuals often don't have a great grasp on what treatments will help them or why. Very tricky to find the right journalistic line to walk here
3/ Similar dynamic in a NYT Mag article about a very disturbed young person in 2019. I feel like anything involving gender identity is held to a different evidentiary standard and that this doesn't necessarily help people.
2/I think the easiest way to sum up what's going on here is a weird form of backward reasoning where if a sentiment is expressed by (someone seen as) a TERF, it is, by definition, bigoted, and something something something white supremacist. The dot-connecting needn't make sense.
3/ I'm sure somewhere there is a followup question where AHP asks her to name an example (or even two!) of a contemporary feminist thinker who believes in this idea. Just haven't gotten there yet.
The folks terrified of fascism want the state to clamp down on Josh Hawley and Rudy Giuliani
2/ Surely if we want to attenuate rather than embolden far-right forces, the best solution is to contrive a way to have federal authorities take Donald Trump and Josh Hawley into custody -- it just makes sense, if you are a Student of Fascism like I am
3/Goes w/o saying that Giuliani is corrupt as hell and if he did actual illegal stuff, prosecute away. But clearly the (very creepy) claim here is that these folks should be arrested for... not sure? Lying about the election? Think through more plz.
I wrote a long critique of Gizmodo and The Markup's piece about predictive policing, which I thought exemplified many of the worst, most paternalistic trends in how liberals approach crime and policing
(For paid subscribers, but with a partial preview)
2/ The authors argue that the main problem with PredPol, the predictive policing algorithm they're criticizing, is that black vs. white and rich vs. poor people *report* crimes at different rates. That can lead to the illusion of discrepancies. This is a very strange claim:
3/ Yes, there's some data suggesting discrepancies in the rates at which people report crime. But there's also data showing that the disparities in *actually experiencing* crime tend to be more than an order of magnitude larger. Gizmodo and The Markup ignore this entirely.
I am probably going to Asheville and Atlanta later this month and am in search of vegetarian-friendly food recommendations. Also good 3-4-hour hikes around Asheville assuming the area bears are the friendly/herbivorous type, or the kind you can ride into battle on.
2/ I know Atlanta is huge but I don't even know where I'm staying yet so maybe your food recommendation will help tip the scale!
3/Okay so might be doin 2-3 days in New Orleans instead of Atlanta. Feel like if I can only do 1, that's the move. Recs please! Never been there. Premium on just walking around, seeing music, nothing too crazy. Will eat anything without central nervousness
2/ This was a good conversation. Lotsa questions/critiques but overwhelmingly from folks who follow/like my work. I shoulda anticipated that.
I can't post the show link because I'm getting an error message when I try to, but the ep is safely saved as a draft so up soon I hope.
3/ I think I'll just have to have folks who disagree with me come on to effectively cohost individual episodes -- probably a selection issue with expecting to get truly critical folks with this sort of open call. At the top of the ep I did address some Twitter-criticism though.