The timing of the vote meant just 129 peers voted - three times less than voted on the first division of the day
The votes of Conservative peers, who'd stayed late at night, also rejected a move to have this amendment voted on at a later date, put forward by @natalieben
On the Home Office's current position, crossbencher Lord Carlile said: "The Home Secretary is saying that it would be possible to convert it to a statutory inquiry in certain circumstances. That is one of the most meaningless statements in this context that I have ever heard."
Why does a statutory inquiry matter?
The last non-statutory inquiry into the police - the Daniel Morgan inquiry - took 8 years
Its author "faced obstruction, and said specifically in her findings that she knew that she had been hampered by not having the statutory powers"
Shami Chakrabarti last night: "I still have questions, and so do people all over the country, about the wider issues of culture, professionalism and practices in our police service in relation to crimes against women and girls
"We have not had our Lawrence moment."
Blows a bit of a hole in the idea of the Lords as the last great bastion of parliamentary scrutiny if you can just...win votes by holding them after everyone's gone to bed
📰Full story here:
🗣️ @natalieben: "I'm confident that conducted at a ‘normal’ working time – say before 8.30pm – this amendment would have passed in the House"
Priti Patel was threatened with legal action by @centreWJ over this last year
“There are fears that without the powers a statutory inquiry would have any findings will come late, will be inadequate, and ultimately will not fix the systemic issues”
"It’s like you’ve got some kind of illness and you’re just waiting to die"
That's how Mark Burkett, who served time in prison and was released, describes life battling the Home Office
He arrived in the UK, has two children, and has been detained for deportation twice since 2019
Priti Patel blames "galling last-minute legal claims" for the fact these flights leave almost empty
But those I spoke to say it's because access to legal help is a major challenge - it's often only in the days before deportation that detainees get proper solicitors
Ah why not, it's been a weird year but here's some stuff I'm proud of:
Did some work I'm really proud of in my last months at The Tab. This story on unis hiring investigators to deal with students accused of sexual assault made the nationals: thetab.com/uk/2021/06/14/…