2022.01.04. Reiterating my concerns that molnupiravir's low efficacy is not worth the risk of creating highly mutated viruses, with similar opinions from Danish MDs and an admission from a Danish official that its approval skipped normal requirements.
2022.01.06. Suggesting we should better publicize reports that Omicron mostly causes hospitalizations by aggravating preexisting conditions, so those with preexisting conditions understand their risk.
2022.01.11. Summarizing data showing case-hospitalization rates at 25% in the Omicron wave vs pre-vaccine waves in Western countries, maybe 10% after adjusting for underreporting in this wave.
Some Omicron trends that we can now definitively see:
• Case hospitalization and fatality rates (CHR, CFR) in SA, Denmark, UK, Australia, US
• A guess at true infection hospitalization and fatality rates (IHR, IFR)
• Omicron peaking in many regions of the US
This follows a previous thread where we inferred from early SA data that the CHR was lower for Omicron than earlier waves due to prior immunity and lower virulence, and it would be similar in the West. (But still bad news due to very high case # s)
The SA data as of 2021/12/28 showed Omicron CHR and CFR at ~50% and ~15% of the 2021/01 peak.
The CHR is clearly ~50% of the year-ago peak. Deaths however are still creeping up and CFR now 20% of year-ago. Others observed older people got Omicron later in SA; may relate to that.
Since my analysis concluding 3 shots are required for the broad response needed against Omicron, and that #JnJers will need 2 shots of RNA, others like former Surgeon General @JeromeAdamsMD have reached the same conclusion
16M Americans are stuck in pre-Omicron limbo. We just need to admit J&J was like one shot of RNA, so they were behind 2xRNA-vaxxed and should be allowed to catch up. (And a 2nd J&J is not as good due to immunized clearance of the adenovirus vector)
Most #JnJers understand past mistakes of CDC and FDA on this and other topics have already degraded their credibility. This is why people are turning to writing articles to point out the problem. Credibility on this topic can only go up by addressing it usatoday.com/story/news/hea…
As @Merz mentioned Marin is one of the highest-vaxxed counties in CA. However it's not particularly young. The experience is "anecdotal" anyway but the PH officer relates it to past experience in the same location. It may serve as an example of what high vax rates can achieve.
@Merz The observation about low ICU rates is similar to what we've seen in London so far
While our attention was diverted by Omicron, FDA approved the viral mutagen molnupiravir (MOV) on the last business day before Christmas. The same time, Merck published that MOV doesn't reduce virus levels in the first 3 days. So patients will be shedding mutated virus for 3 days
I wrote in the Washington Post pointing out that widespread use of the drug increases the risk that we will create new immunoevasive variants. This could come from Delta; it may not be milder like Omicron. Since my piece is no longer browsable, I post it here as a public service
It's not just me. Most scientists or clinicians who know the data are worried. They include @JamesEKHildreth, Defense Health Agency director @peterweina, and former BARDA director @RickABright who were overruled either by FDA or by the prev admin on their MOV concerns
For a new year tried out a new mask, the 3M Aura N95 mask. Wow what a night and day difference. Didn't realize a mask could be this comfortable. Most amazing thing: speech comes through clearly.
My colleague @AbraarKaran is correct: CDC should be pushing better masks like these
These are $3 each and worth it. You can buy a 3pack (or 10pack) and rotate between them. On the 3 days off you let the mask air out to evaporate odors and let any viruses in them die off. More info on this thread.
Not only did HHS and CDC failed to push for mass manufacturing of these masks earlier (a problem since the previous administration when @RickABright was overruled on the matter) but CDC continued to push wrong or obsolete ideas about N95s
If we can avoid creating worse variants with molnupiravir, COVID19 can finally become like the flu in 2022.
1/n
The SA experience, mirrored in Western countries so far, suggests Omicron IFR is an order of magnitude lower than previous variants. This is due to preexisting immunity and lower virulence of Omicron.