A closer look at inflation in services excluding energy, this accounts for about 60% of the CPI and 75% of the core CPI.
Over the last three months up at a 4.6% annual rate compared to 2.9% annual rate pre-pandemic.
That excess is adding ~1.2pp to annualized core CPI.
Overall core services are still below trend--but is moving up more quickly so converging towards/above trend. You could look at that and say that our only inflation problem is goods. Or you could look at that and say we have another shoe yet to drop.
Leading candidate for yet-to-drop shoe #1 is housing prices. These are still up relatively slowly for *all* housing as compared to the large increases we're seeing for new leases. All should catch up to new.
Potential yet-to-drop shoe #2: pandemic-related prices. We're still in a pandemic. It has been constraining services demand and service prices. If we return to more normal then expect higher prices for airfare, hotels, events, etc.
Potential yet-to-drop shoe #3: there is some evidence from @jimstockmetrics and Mark Watson that service prices are more sensitive to labor market slack than overall prices. And labor markets much tighter now than they were a year ago. nber.org/papers/w25987
But who knows. I expect an undoing of the abnormal rotation to reduce inflation the question is how much--is it enough to get us to 2%? Does it leave us at 3%? And if it leaves us at 3% is the Fed OK with that (as I think they should be) or do they feel they need to fight it?
BTW, here is the same multiple period picture for durable goods that I showed you for core services.
And repeating the durable goods vs. services comparison over the last 24 months that started this discussion in the first place.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Several thoughts on that piece by @nealemahoney & @BharatRamamurti in @nytopinion.
1. They claim price controls are good politically. I'm very open to this being true, I'm under no illusion that what I think is good policy is particularly well correlated with good politics. But I am genuinely interested in more evidence beyond the brief observations they make.
2. They claim that even if you think price controls are a bad idea they can help you pass supply-increasing legislation that is on balance good. Once again, I'm open to this. And in government I've often done 3rd, 7th or 12th best policies because of constraints.
It has now, for better or worse, been effectively abolished.
The last three legislated increases in the minimum wage were bipartisan:
1989: President Bush (41) and a Democratic Congress
1996: President Clinton and a Republican Congress
2007: President Bush (43) and a Democratic Congress
Prices are up about 50% since it was increased to $7.25/hr in 2009.
As a result the inflation-adjusted minimum wage is about the lowest it has ever been. The productivity-adjusted min wage is the lowest it has ever been.
Only 1% of workers nationwide are paid at or below that.
The most helpful visualization of the persistent and, to some degree, resurgence of core inflation is this. Four straight months of strong core goods inflation largely due to tariffs. Plus services inflation remains reasonably strong.
A big upward revision for GDP, was a 3.8% annual rate (up from 3.0% in the advance estimate). For H1 GDP up at a 1.6% annual rate.
The biggest change was consumption which was 2.5% annual rate (up from 1.4% in the advance). Business fixed investment strong, residential weak.
Here is quarterly consumer spending. It looked like it was really slowing but with this upward revision and the July and August indications it's looking much more healthy.
Business fixed investment has been strong. It is unclear how much of this is pulling forward of capital equipment imports to get ahead of tariffs and how much is sustainable. (Note disaggregating structures have been falling while equipment is rising, reducing a disconnect.)
The problem recently has been in both goods and services. Core goods inflation has typically been about zero but in the run-up to this year had deflation. Now tariff-driven inflation.
And at the same time core services inflation has picked up.