Thread by @Alminhaji

Many many issues here!

1. He hid page 397 deliberately! Due to the fact that it exposes the Wahhabis and Karramis alike!
By him stating the Quran is Muhdath as in it revelation, not that it is Muhdath from Allah.
While completely ruins his ideology!

Please learn to translate because if that is what they actually said they woupd be kuffar!
They said the literal speech of God didn’t enter this world. This is a fact, but rather Jibril cane into this world. Fact!

As for his argument that it has to be letter and sound for that is the Hanbali opinion. And it is not agreed upon. And it isn’t what you say.
And many many scholar disagree with this argument!
And there is no Ijmaa that Kalam is only Letters and Sounds.
So the argument is void

In addition; The claim he makes that you can not show the Siffah if it is an ability with in the speaker isn’t accurate, for it can be visualized via its effects.
We don’t label it this way, but this clarification makes it easier.

He goes on to argue that since you can’t point to the Siffah, and the Quran is a siffah, and you can’t do that if it isn’t sounds and letters then this is assigning what can not be performed, which is unlawful.
This argument is void, as he can assign what is unbearable!

This argument that Allah can not assign that which is unbearable is actually a Mu’tazili opinion.
Ahl Assunnah; do not say Allah can or can not do something, but it is Allah who makes this decree if he will do something or he won’t.
Thus the argument is based on Mu’tazili ideas

And finally; he uses weak narrations to claim Kalam can only be sounds and letters; which he took from Mu’tazilah I mean this one right he is non existent!!
It is sad; but many people good people fell victim to the Mu’tazilah.