One question to ask when you advocate for a particular position is "what would happen if everyone did as you suggest?" If everyone stopped using vaccines, we'd lose billions of lives. Polio would return. Children would die routinely of diphtheria. Tetanus would be a thing again.
I think this test alone more or less says everything you need to know about the idea. Something is desperately wrong if your idea, widely adopted, would kill a large fraction of our species.
Unfortunately, many people have no memory for history, and some cannot even remember how the world has changed in their own lifetime. They watch a nice BBC drama about life in 1820 and think it looks cool. They forget that in the real 1820 no one had indoor plumbing.
They certainly don't remember that even in the mid-20th century panics would cross the US as polio waves struck, killing and maiming children in vast numbers. Swimming pools and playgrounds would shut down for weeks or months at a time.
"Do you expect us to live in fear of diseases forever?" the people with no historical memory cry. No, not forever. Only until you stop trying to do your best to keep the diseases around.
No, it wasn't nice living in 1820. It sucked, and part of why it sucked was there was a very good chance you were disfigured for life by smallpox scars and that your best friend in childhood died of cholera.
I'm often very critical of the medical profession because I would like it to be better than it is, but there's a difference between wanting medicine to be better and thinking we'd be better off with more disease.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
