Alok Bhatt Profile picture
Jan 24 12 tweets 4 min read
Classical case of repeating half lies so much that it becomes a truth. Almost every M named as Bose’s associate, either defected to Pakistan or abandoned Bose for political gains.

Thread follows!
First person named by Sugata Bose is that of Mian Akbar Shah- note how all of them have conveniently missed the man who accompanied Bose right from Calcutta up to Kabul but made Mian Akbar Shah-the hero of the escape - typical of Bhadralok style secularism
The man entrusted with the responsibility to accompany Bose alias
Mohammad Zia ud Din, Travelling Inspector The Empire of India Life Insurance Company Ltd. Bhagat Ram arranged tickets of Delhi-Kalka mail & Frontier Mail to reach Peshawar alongwith Bose
Although Bose was travelling as a Muslim, his stay was arranged at Deans Hotel -hotel used by Hindus. Infact, it was Tongawala who insisted that Bose-disguised as good Muslim- shud not stay at hotel frequented by infidels & made both of them stay at Tajmahal instead!
Guess what after Bose’s death and creation of Pakistan, Mian Akbar Shah dumped Khudai Khidmatgar movement and joined Muslim League and even fought elections on their ticket. I am sure had Bose been alive, Akbar Shah wud have stayed in Pak and not India!
Second is Abid Hasan & there is not much that need to be told about him. Yes he was a close associate of Netaji but he got more than anyone else from India. Served as IFS officer for 21 years; was closed confidante of Nehru Gandhi’s-bête noire of Bose!
Thirds comes Mohd Zaman Kiani; glorified by Sugata Bose. Yes he was a Bose compatriot but later played the most important role in accession of POK by force. He, as Pak Army, officer, led their Poonch rebellion and played huge role in formation of what Pak calls Azad Kashmir
Kiani even served as Political agent of Pakistan in Gilgit - if one can glorify Kiani, then what is the harm in glorifying Jinnah!
Habib Ur Rehman-LOL; same guy who was Chief of Staff of Kiani when he established GHQ in POK. He led the war in Bhimber and ensured its loss from Maharaja’s forces. Helped raiders rape and kill Pandits and what not- was awarded Fateh-e-Bhimber,Fakhr-e-Kashmir, Ghazi-e-Kashmir
Shahnawaz Khan: need I say anything more about his role in deepening mystery of Netaji’s disappearance following alleged air accident. The loot of money filled suitcases, that followed & whitewashing of the whole affair at the behest of Nehru! @anujdhar shud educate @_nehruvian
Unlike their M compatriots, glorified by @_nehruvian and @Javedakhtarjadu and Sugata Ghose; both Sehgal and Gurbaksh Singh remained true to Indian union and India. Read history correctly and without any biases
Dear @Javedakhtarjadu and @_nehruvian this is also a fact and a valid perspective

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Alok Bhatt

Alok Bhatt Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @alok_bhatt

Jan 25
Thank you गिर दा 🙏🏻🙏🏻
उत्तराखंड मेरी मातृभूमि

मातृभूमि, मेरी पितृभूमि,

ओ भूमि तेरी जै- जै कारा म्यार हिमाला।

ख्वार मुकुट तेरी ह्युं झलको

झलकी गाल गंगे की धारा , म्यार हिमाला।

तली तली तराई कुनी

कुनी मली मली भाभरा , म्यार हिमाला ।
बद्री केदारा का द्वार छना,

छना कनखल हरिद्वारा, म्यार हिमाला।

काली धौली का छाना जानी,

जानी नान ठुला कैलाशा, म्यार हिमाला ।

पार्वती को मैत या छो,

या छो शिवजयू को सौरसा , म्यार हिमाला।
Read 4 tweets
Jan 24
I came across a beautiful concept called “SheHaat”on Nahan-Kumarhatti highway. Brainchild of then Sirmour DC and a localite; this project helped reinforce my belief in the “son of the soil” theory delivering results, when it comes to bureaucracy! Image
Best part is that the walls of the facility have the pic of the man- whose brainchild it was- displayed prominently. Every women I spoke to, swore by him. His name is Dr Raj Krishna Prithu and he is a Himachal PCS officer promoted to IAS. ImageImageImage
The facility came up on a panchayat land and was built by the Govt. It was then given to a group of 25 local women for running. All the women are trained in kitchen work, handicrafts, accounts and running the stores. There is a skill development unit attached to the facility
Read 16 tweets
Jan 16
Do file a complaint- I am sure they will ask u why u kept ur handle deactivated.

On papers, coz they are in order, precisely why u r roaming free in Pak. It is about the timing of ur visa - when all visas are banned- and free access that u enjoyed in no go areas for Indians!
Also u are at risk because u r back in the country from where u were screaming to be rescued few months ago. I have only used info available on your own handles and ur insta feed. U r in a place where not even ordinary afghans are dreading to travel. Don’t shoot me-the messenger
Pak didn’t even spare a Muslim Hamid Ansari-still languishing in Pak jail for venturing into KPK; even Zeenat Sehahzadi-Pak girl who was helping his mom, went missing and u r kidding me that Pak authorities will allow a Hindu baniya-disparagingly used by them-to travel in KPK?
Read 4 tweets
Jan 16
And this @kanika0509 is back in Afghanistan, where she was screaming to be saved from, 3 months ago!

Requesting @HMOIndia & @MEAIndia to probe her links with ISI as no Indian is given visa by Pak for KPK region without any ISI and ISPR clearance!
Dear @HMOIndia request u to please prepare a list of Indians who were given visa of KPK by Pak in past 10 years and that should be a reason to probe @kanika0509 ‘s link with ISI and ISPR - this time she will not seek @MEAIndia help as she will be under protection of ISI in Afg
And @HMOIndia - here is conduit of @kanika0509 with ISPR/ISI: Wajahat S Khan. The journalist with deep connections in ISPR and one who used to do programs for them earlier. Now he is on study leave and also working for Nikkei Asia- same platform that uses Rupa S for propaganda
Read 8 tweets
Jan 7
Makes so much of sense
Part 2 - we need to propagate such sane voices and amplify them
Good to see him talk about the pagdi thing- as I said earlier, it is beyond me as to why the man is being hated by few members of the community despite the facts as mentioned in this video as below. It is only coz Khalistanis, see in him, an enemy of theirs & that of Pak masters
Read 4 tweets
Jan 6
Earlier, some Ms within, were nurturing dream of creating another Pak; now they are joined by Khalistanis with dream of creating Khalistan. The common thread that binds both is Pakistan & to shatter both those dreams, destruction of Pakistan must become an unstated goal of India!
The hot pursuit of these men and women and the unstated goal can alone silence these chuchunders
This tension will not subside as BJPs governance goals and nationalistic goals are miles apart from Cong. Which is exactly why we, time and again, see statements like this one from Cong leaders; yesterday’s event was all abt realising this goal only
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(