Last night, Scotland's live evening news programme covered the court hearing where we defended the meaning of sex in the Census. @AskNic was interviewed. Watch the full TV package here /1
@AskNic "what the Scottish Government is doing is muddling up sex and gender identity. It's unnecessary to do that and its also unlawful" /2
"The Scottish Government is trying to erase sex by muddling it up with gender identity and that really matters. While sexism still exists in society, sex matters. We need to be able to count it, to talk about it and to have policy based on it" /3
"trans lobby groups have said they want both questions to be about gender identity and that means we lose valuable data about sex. Sex matters too" /4
"Scot Gov floated some astonishing arguments. Apparently social attitudes in Scotland have changed so much that its impossible to know what the correct answer to the sex question should be. That answer could change from day to day & there could be more than one correct answer" /5
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
THREAD: There has been much outrage amongst transactivists this week in response to the @EHRC announcements about Scottish GRA reform and Conversion therapy. Plus shock that EHRC has met with stakeholders such as Fair Play For Women /1
Many are angry that women are now considered stakeholders in policies regarding sex and gender. They see this as evidence that EHRC is now "transphobic" /2
Many point the finger at the new @EHRCChair Kishwer Falkner and her appointment by W&E Minister Liz Truss @trussliz.
What they don't know is that we have, of course, been active stakeholders for many years now. /3
JUDICIAL REVIEW THREAD #scottishcesus#FairPlayForWomen
FPFW has been given permission by the court to live tweet as we watch proceedings of the judicial review of the guidance to accompany the ‘sex question’ in the 2022 Scottish census/1
Judge is The Hon Lord Sandison
Advocate for FPFW: Roddy Dunlop QC
Advocate for Scottish Ministers: Douglas Ross QC /2
THREAD: It's a big day for us tomorrow. We're taking Scottish Ministers to court over their unlawful definition of sex in the Scottish Census. The remote hearing starts a 10am. We'll be live tweeting proceedings /1 #scottishcensus#fairplayforwomen
The Census is important so needs to be done right. It only happens once a decade & costs Scottish taxpayers £140 million.
But it delivers the most comprehensive dataset there is, used by policy makers, public bodies & academics.
Yesterday, Fair Play For Women reported Police Scotland to the EHRC for breaching Equality Law. Reported in Telegraph. /1 telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/01/3…
And picked up by the Times.
“Police misrepresenting the law in this way is a serious matter. The idea that service providers are in any way deplorable and acting unlawfully is likely to foster bad relations” /2
Today, we have submitted a formal complaint to the Equality and Human Rights Commission about inaccurate and misleading information given by Police Scotland regarding the use of single-sex exceptions /1
Police Scotland has a duty to promote understanding between groups, and the EHRC has a duty to make sure Police Scotland doesn’t breach those obligations. We believe a breach has occurred and action is now required /2
In a comment to the Times, Assistant Chief Constable Gary Ritchie said “Hate crime and discrimination of any kind is deplorable and entirely unacceptable”.
With regards to discrimination, this statement made on behalf of Police Scotland is inaccurate and misleading /3
BREAKING NEWS: Scottish Census officials have been told by the Equality and Human Rights Commission that requiring transgender people to accurately record their sex in the Census does not breach their right to privacy /1
EHRC wrote to the head of NRS just days before we launched our Census legal challenge
"Where there is a requirement in statute, such as for the census, any potential interference with Article 8 [right to privacy] arising from collecting data on sex is likely to be justified” /2
Scottish Ministers pushed on regardless and will now have to defend their definition of sex in the Census in court on Wednesday /3