Our first speaker Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd begins speaking on 'From Colonial to the Everyday: Hindutva’s Caste Ambiguity'
What are called as ‘Hindu texts’ do not have anything about counting people, including the Rig Veda. They do not mention the role of the productive communities of Shudras and their numbers.
Whether it is the right wing, the left wing, the liberals, none have spoken about the damage by the Hindu texts about the absence of productive communities.
During the British times most academicians were upper castes, hardly any Shudras. In fact, during the first census of 1871, the British administrators thought the Brahmins were majority of population since they were the most in touch with them.
Post the census they found out that Brahmins were an absolute minority, that they were about 4% of the entire population.
By the time UPA ended its rule and the second Mandal came in, there was an understanding that the Shudra+OBC question should not be pressed too much. Now the demand is from the OBCs themselves, because even the BJP is saying they are representing OBCs.
The BJP project Narendra Modi as an OBC candidate and has got power.
OBCs census is not about reservation, it is about censorship, legal and spiritual censorship. Where are they in Hinduism, in temples, in central government, in government offices? Caste census should be for advancing democracy.
Caste census should be for advancing democracy. CPI, CPM won't change, as much as BJP RSS have, I will not support a Left revolution because it will still be dominated by Brahmins.
Ambedkarism should show us the way ahead, education agenda has to be completely shifted, English medium for all should be part of the Shudra/OBC nation building. Then only a different form of democratic discourse will start in India.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
"the institution that is asking for an update of data is the judiciary. And if the judiciary wants to know the nation wants to know!" _ Prof @jaffrelotc
"Hindutva politics and the Post Mandal caste politics that BJP plays is not contradictory, it's indeed complimentary" - @jaffrelotc
"It's not only that we dont know the effect of reservation on public sector, but we also have no data on its effect of academia!" - how has reservation affected the socio-economic status of Dalits and Adivasis in terms of their access to power in education-@jaffrelotc
Q&A for the 4th Panel on 'From Colonial to the Everyday: Hindutva’s Caste Ambiguity' is going on.
#CasteCensus "Between 2014 and 2018, UPPSC jobs came down by 40% and so oppressed groups got fewer jobs by reservations. In 2019, by setting income limit of 8 LPA, government made this quota accessible only to the elites of UCs."-Christophe Jaffrelot @saaf_oxforduni
#CasteCensus "Shudra landed castes (Marathas, Jatts etc) did not support reservation. Only now that regional Shudra leadership is demanding Caste Census. Once it comes, they realizes the truth about their strength in powerful places"-Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd @saaf_oxforduni
Our third speaker Christophe Jaffrelot (@jaffrelotc) has begun discussing 'From Colonial to the Everyday: Hindutva’s Caste Ambiguity' #CountingCaste #CasteCensus
@jaffrelotc We need data, showing representation of different castes in different institutions. This is one of the ways to assess the degree of representativeness and hence democratisation, this is true for India and other countries.
@jaffrelotc Those who come from one group will be inclined to speak about their group, especially in parliament. I started looking at this data of Members of Parliaments, in the 80s and this data is a goldmine.
Our second speaker Sagar has begun discussing 'From Colonial to the Everyday: Hindutva’s Caste Ambiguity' #CountingCaste #CasteCensus
I will speak from my experiences of reporting on Hindutva, before coming to the caste census. Hindutva is not just about mobs wearing shawls, red marks on their forehead. It is more about people who want Hinduism as the normal politics of the country.
First coined by Savarkar, he says Hindutva is about common religion, common heroes, common history, common festivals, common flow of blood, everyone born this side of Sindhu. He says Christian and Muslim communities are not Hindu because they do not have this common history.