The TERF etymology of 'differently abled', a thread:
Some years ago, I decided to track down the history of the term 'differently abled'. It is a journey that took me all the way back to the Michigan Womyn's Music Festival in the 1970s. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michigan_…
MichFest as it became known, was held annually beginning in 1976. It eventually shut down in 2015, a year after a large boycott due to its policy of excluding trans women. Michfest only admitted "womyn-born womyn".
Michfest attracted disabled "womyn" early on by prioritizing accessibility. The only electricity attendees had access to were in the tents that were created for disabled folks. Like the other areas at MichFest, these tents housed lots of sex.
The disabled "womyn" who attended MichFest decided to create another term for themselves while they were at this event. And fairly quickly, probably by the end of the first year, the term became 'differently abled.'
And those tents they used got renamed. They were now called DARTs. Differently Abled Resource Tents.
The first usage of 'Differently Abled' that I have found is from a journal called 'Off Our Backs', in an issue that focused on "michigan festival: music matriarchy, malelessness". It was printed in October of 1980.
Three and a half years later it appeared in the Spring 1984 issue of Feminist Studies. Helaine Victoria Press included 'differently-abled' women in a call for postcards.
But the next usage is what I have lingered on for years. In a September 1984 issue of 'The Science Teacher' which is published by the National Science Teacher's Association, there is an advertisement with the header "Differently-abled and in science?"
How did 'Differently Abled' leap from feminist journals to a journal written for science teachers with nothing in between? At first I thought the author of the header must be involved with the AAAS Project.
But then I realized the AAAS description says 'handicapped' repeatedly, and so I believe whoever curated the 'Taking Note' section of 'The Science Teacher' likely wrote all of the headers.
And this feels important, because this is the moment that denotes a shift from the liberated usage of this term to describe sexual disabled adults to something that was used to describe students. Who wrote this and what was her relationship to MichFest?
Anyway, this is where things get fascinating. On April 9, 1985, someone named Jack Smith wrote an op/ed in the Los Angeles Times titled "Is the language itself disabled in that it can’t fairly define the handicapped?" latimes.com/archives/la-xp…
This article is actually where my journey began. In it, he discusses how the Democratic National Committee 'coined differently abled', "in a valiant effort to find a kinder term than handicapped"
Smith goes on to describe a letter he has from "the Women's Center, UC Santa Barbara, from Margareth Annschild, director." In it she states "We welcome the differently able." I'm dying to know what Margareth Annschild's relationship was to MichFest.
Not long after, the National Review dismissed the 'valiant' term 'differently abled' as "semantic gobbeldygook." I seem to have misplaced this gem of a printout that I spent hours trying to locate at the NYPL, so need to go back and get it. But the rest, I suppose, is history.
Also, I have an interesting etymology/history of the phrase 'curb cut effect' but need a few more weeks to figure a couple elements of it out. If anyone wants to build on this differently abled etymology - feel free to reach out. Would be happy to send everything I have.
Incredible! Here's 'differently abled' in a Long Island Newsday in 1976. [ID: a 13 year old wheelchair user used 'differently abled']
I want to note I have long felt that Connie Panzarino was influential in 'differently abled' at MichFest. She was from the Boston area. Looking into a list of other early disabled attendees to see who else might have been on the east coast. sealpress.com/titles/connie-…
I so wish to understand this dynamic of a term being taken up by two distinct populations. One of them being disabled children (and their parents). The other being liberated disabled adults.
I have been thinking a lot about how @alexhaagaard and I advise corporate employees to #ResistTheAnnouncement. The new Microsoft Surface Adaptive Kit offers an excellent case study as to why.
In 2019, Microsoft announced the Xbox Adaptive Controller through a massive holiday ad campaign. They then followed it up with a Super Bowl ad. The Xbox Adaptive Controller was absolutely everywhere.
Since that time, there has been little mention of the Xbox Adaptive Controller, and it has mostly faded from the public consciousness. So much so, that it led me to ask this question:
I'm looking for a creative disabled writer or poet who might be interested in writing Alt-Text descriptions for an organization on an as needed basis. Paid per description, either as income or in gift card format so as not to put benefits at risk.
Also, what would be a good rate for a single Alt-Text description? I imagine the monthly range of work required would be anywhere from five to twenty descriptions.
Would be a great gig for someone who hasn't been given their shot professionally, and could use a bit of a resume boost.
I also want to point out that they created a challenge that was entirely inaccessible to Laura. She was crying out, I need to go back and check, but I believe her words were that her brain does not work in a linear way. She said this multiple times, clearly in distress...
Laura is clearly neurodivergent, that’s what she was stating. But there were no efforts to accommodate her. And when you look at the shape of her patisserie, it is clear she was unable to fill in gaps that the other contestants were able to.
Because this is clearly going to make the rounds, this is an Alt Text thread. The image is a chart, containing four colored rows. The left most row is green, titled thriving, subhead "I got this". The next row is yellow and says surviving subhead "Something isn't right."
The next is orange and says struggling, subhead "I can't keep this up." And the right most row is red and says crisis, subhead "I can't survive this."
Thriving: Calm and steady with minor mood fluctuations. Able to take things in stride. Consistent performance. Able to take feedback and to adjust to changes of plans. Able to focus. Able to communicate effectively. Normal sleep patterns and appetite.
Alt Text Update: awkwardly I didn't read the sign below the ADA sign, and didn't include it in my alt text. But comments have made me aware that I need to update this post with Alt Text that describes the second sign. Because holy shit. The sign reads:
"Due to HIPAA and the 4th Amendment, we can't legally ask you about your medical condition. If we see you without a mask, we will assume you have a medical condition and we will welcome you inside to support our business."