You know what Yascha Mounk conveniently fails to mention? That he also called for an end to “hygiene theater” in May 2021 – that was before Delta, before Omicron. About 350,000 Americans have since died of Covid.
Something to keep in mind when assessing his credibility.
You’d think that including some form of acknowledgment of his previous calls to “end pandemic theater” might be in order? Something like “Mind you, I also proudly proclaimed the exact same thing many months ago, and that was clearly premature”? Some critical self-reflection?
It’s the complete lack of humility that I find astonishing. “I used my significant public platform once before to deride people who remained cautious, including pretty much all the actual experts - they were right, I was wrong, many people died, but hey, no hard feelings, right?”
I reflected on Mounk’s previous call to “stop playing hygiene theater” in this short thread here - again, this was in May 2021, and it’s honestly quite remarkable that the same guy is at it again nine months later:
I guess when you’re convinced to be fighting a noble war to defend “real” (read: white Christian patriarchal) America against the insidious forces of leftism and “wokeism,” it all makes perfect sense!
It’s worth reflecting on why so few people on the Right consider these inconsistencies a serious problem, and why they’re evidently not a dealbreaker for most conservatives, neither intellectually nor politically. It’s all about what rightwingers consider the “Higher Truths.”
These Higher Truths to which conservatives subscribe: That “real Americans” are being victimized constantly, made to suffer under the yoke of crazy leftist politics; that woke Libs are out to destroy “real” America; that “We” are entitled to rule, and “They” must be stopped.
This may sound harsh, but I agree with @jasonintrator. Too many commentators thought their expertise on European fascism enabled them to weigh in on Trumpism, not realizing that they actually lacked an adequate understanding of the American (Far) Right, past and present.
One such case is Richard Evans, specifically his essay “Why Trump isn’t a fascist,” published a week after the January 6 attack on the Capitol. newstatesman.com/long-reads/202…
Richard Evans is one of the pre-eminent scholars of Nazism – and arguably one of the best-known historians in the world. I respect him greatly, especially his earlier work that focused on nineteenth-century German social history; the focus on Nazism actually came quite late.
Aside from the disastrous effects of their “bipartisanship or bust” politics, the fact that the “unity” crowd consistently relies on this kind of bizarrely distorted and utterly stupid version of the nation’s history should really give anyone with a shred of self-respect pause.
“Bipartisanship or bust” is how democracy dies. And actually, if that had been the maxim, America never would have gotten anywhere near democracy territory in the first place.
There’s no question that Sorbo understands the opportunity that is presented to him: There’s a whole rightwing propaganda infrastructure for guys like him - a standing invitation to gain a little bit of attention (and money) by leaning into their supposed victimization.
But when he looks in the mirror in the morning, does he go: “Goodness, I can’t believe they’re buying this BS - let’s go out there and tell some more nonsense stories!” I don’t think that’s the case. What’s on display here is a little more interesting than that.
A clarifying piece by @perrybaconjr: What kind of democracy, and for whom?
Conservatives want to restrict democracy in order to uphold white Christian patriarchal rule. They are turning to authoritarianism because they are failing. Thoughts from a historical perspective: 1/
There are two key questions that have defined recent U.S. history: How have ideas and realities of democracy changed, specifically since the 1950s? And how has political conservatism reacted to those shifting versions and visions of democracy? 2/
It is often said that the U.S. is the world’s oldest democracy. While that is not necessarily incorrect, depending on the definition of “democracy,” it obscures rather than illuminates the reality of American life, past and present, and the nature of the current conflict. 3/
I wish more people knew about this story: a bust one of the KKK’s founders (!), in the year 2000 (!), in Selma, Alabama (!), in direct reaction to the election of a Black mayor. Grapple with this in earnest and you’ll understand so much about America’s past and present.
Nathan Bedford Forrest is famous not in spite, but solely because he was a traitor, war criminal, and the first Grand Wizard of the Ku Klux Klan. He was the embodiment of white supremacist violence when he was alive, and has been a symbol of continued white supremacy ever since.
What would you say about a German town with a large Jewish community, that just elected a Jewish mayor, erecting a statue of a Wehrmacht general who was infamous for being an anti-Semite, massacring Soviet soldiers, and founding a neo-Nazi terror organization after the war?