A narrative is being built that there were multiple advisories but the students did not leave Ukraine. Here is the timeline of what happened. Thread 👇1/n
The first advisory issued on Feb 15 asked Indian nationals whose stay is ‘non-essential’ to ‘consider’ leaving Ukraine. 2/n
Students in the middle of an academic term, whose universities did not move to online classes may have different perceptions of ‘non-essential’. Contrast this to the unambiguous 2015 Yemen advisory asking ALL Indian nationals to LEAVE, essential or non essential. 3/n
Next day the embassy issued FAQs for students. The very first point was about flights being fully booked. It said MEA was in discussion with min of civil aviation for expanding flights 4/n
Note other than connecting options, there was only one direct flight (Ukraine Airlines) to India which did not operate daily. Finally On Feb 18th, three special Air India flights were announced for Feb 22, 24 and 26. 5/n
The flights were sold out as soon as they were announced and there were multiple tweets from students requesting for more flights 6/n
Others tweeted about their inability to afford the high ticket prices 7/n
On Feb 20th, the Embassy issued a second advisory asking all nationals whose stay is not essential and ‘all’ Indian students to leave Ukraine by available commercial or charter flights. Note the difference from the first advisory that now all students were asked to leave 8/n
Next day, on Feb 21st, three more AI flights were announced for Feb 25th & 27th. 9/n
Then came the Feb 22nd advisory addressed to students: Leave rather than wait for official confirmation from Universities. Clearly the situation was escalating. 10/n
On the same day, the first AI flight scheduled brought brought back 242 Indian nationals. There were 5 more previously announced AI flights to go. And a promise that more will soon be announced. 11/n
On Feb 24th, the second AI flight had to turn back because by then Ukraine had closed it’s airspace. None of the other pre announced AI flights from Ukraine to India materialized. It was too late. 12/n
Judge for yourself whether it is fair to blame the students and their parents like @aajtak correspondent did and many others continue to do. 13/13
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
What’s in a name? A look at the politics that is unfolding in India over the name of a COVID variant. Thread 👇1/n
Learning from past experience, WHO’s 2015 guidelines warn against location based naming of new infectious diseases in order to avoid stigmatizing the communities involved and minimize negative effects on nations, economies and people. 2/n
Despite the guidelines, many like Trump insisted on calling COVID-19, the “China virus”. In India too such terms are popular in RW circles. Zee’s English channel WION for eg, makes a point every time to call it “Wuhan virus”. Another eg is propaganda outlet Opindia 3/n
This constant attempt to peddle hate and give a communal spin to everything.... It’s the same formula, same players. Here is yet another example 1/n
In March 2020, to help the poor tide over the lockdown, govt announced that a sum of Rs 500/- per month will be credited into the accounts of Women Jan Dhan Yojana account holders for the next three months. 2/n
The first of three installments was credited in the account of 4.07 crore women Jan Dhan account holders in first week of April. This led to massive queues at banks fueled by rumors that the amount must be withdrawn immediately. 3/n
Remember British Herald? In 2019, an obscure website ran a poll and declared PM Modi as the most powerful person in the world. Thread👇 1/n
Desperate for international endorsement for PM Modi, BJP leaders and supporters immediately lined up to congratulate each other for this ‘achievement’ 2/n
DD News, our public broadcaster made a tribute video to announce that PM Modi had become the world’s most ‘powerful’ person leaving Trump, Putin and Jinping behind 3/n
Let’s talk about vaccines and vaccine diplomacy. Thread 👇 1/n
In Sept 2020, at the UN General Assembly, PM Modi spoke about how India’s vaccine production and delivery capacity will be used to help all humanity in fighting this crisis. 2/n
At that time, Indian manufacturer, SII, had already entered into licensing agreements for 1 billion doses each with AstraZeneca and Novavax to supply to low and middle income countries, including India. Additionally indigenous vaccines were also being developed 3/n
Violence erupted in West Bengal soon results of the state election were declared. This thread documents how BJP supporting handles seized this as an opportunity to share misinformation and add fuel to the fire.👇 1/n
Unrelated videos & images have been circulated with incendiary text and hashtags like #BengalBurning#PresidentsRuleinBengal. Several prominent handles including BJP leaders & supporters have been actively involved in sharing these misleading images and videos. 2/n
A video of people dancing with swords and guns was shared as TMC victory celebration. The video can be traced back to at least Sept 2020 and the song 'Khela Hobe' was superimposed on the clip to make it look like it was linked to the polls. 3/n altnews.in/old-video-shar…
Social media and WhatsApp are replete with unscientific, non evidence-backed cures for prevention and treatment of COVID-19. This thread is about those unverified claims that were propagated and endorsed by the government, politicians or media. 1/n
As early as January 2020, Government of India’s, Ministry of AYUSH released an advisory that prescribed Homoeopathy for Prevention of Coronavirus Infections and Ayurvedic and Unani medicines for symptomatic management 2/n pib.gov.in/PressReleasePa…
Indian Medical Association (IMA) questioned the scientific basis of this protocol. They demanded that Union Health Minister should come clean on the questions posed to him. ‘If not, he is inflicting a fraud on the nation and gullible patients by calling placebos as drugs.’ 3/n