THREAD: Russian nazism has many common traits with German nazism, but some important differences. German nazism resulted from a fear of the Other becoming increasingly like you and "destroying" you ("arians") from within. This is the key neurosis of Nazi anti-semitism 1/6
Russian nazism is different: it doesn't stress the otherness, it stresses the sameness. It believes Ukrainians and Belarussians are the same as Russians, therefore all "deviations" should be brutally exterminated 2/6
While German nazism was afraid of the Other becoming same as you, Russian nazism is afraid of "same as you" becoming the Other - i.e. Ukrainians, Belarussians etc 3/6
Fighting against differences of this Other means that you should mark all these differences as deviations. And say these deviations are "nationalisms". But Russian "fight against nationalism" (of Ukrainians etc) is actually promotion of Russian own nationalism. 4/6
This is the core of all Russian propaganda about "Ukrainian Nazism". They call "Nazi" everything which is simply Ukrainian: language, culture, music etc 5/6
To conclude: Russians want a "final solution of the Ukrainian question". Germans were exterminating Jews because they were different trying to become too similar; Russians want to exterminate Ukrainians because they are "too similar" (for Russians) trying to become different 6/6
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
THREAD on Ukraine's 20th century history in a global context. This can help understand current events. -- 1) one of possible lenses to look at 20th century history is to see it as struggle between various phantasies to build continental empires. Primarily German and Russian
2) Early 20th century "geopolitics" (Mackinder, Haushofer et al) was obsessed with an idea of Eurasia. Who controls Eurasia, controls the world, it believed. Who controls Eastern Europe, controls Eurasia.
3) Continental empires saw themselves as competitors to the 19th century maritime empires (Britain, France etc) and were dreaming on vast new geopolitical projects which would challenge domination of these maritime empires
a thread to understand what's going on: think of Russia as postmodern fascist state, a mix of Mussolini and Baudrillard. This means: a) there's no society or individuals, only state, which subjugates all, b) there's no reality, only virtual image which subjugates facts
Kremlin's key enemy is the reality itself. It tries to be ahead of reality and playing with the reality as if it is a computer game - with only difference that they play with real people and their lives and destinies
they use "evacuation of orphans" to get an virtual image of a horrible aggressive Ukraine. They deport people to get an image of "refugees" who flee. They make "terrorist acts" against their own hostages and invite their "media" to get an image of Ukrainian attack.
Thread on Russian colonialism. 1. It is different from maritime colonialism of European empires. In the latter, the colonized were substantially different from colonizers. In the Russian colonialism of East. Europe the colonized were often NOT too different from the colonizer
2. Maritime empires constructed an image of the "otherness" of the colonized. Russian continental empire constructed an idea of the "sameness" of the colonized. This legitimized politics of assimilation
3. The politics of assimilation suggested that the colonized are inferior beings, but they have a chance to become true humans if they reject their identity (linguistic, cultural, ethnic, religious). You could join the ruling nation / ruling class through amnesia