Wow. In January, NYPD falsely alleged a 16 year-old resisted a lawful search & in the struggle, the teen's gun went off, hitting himself & then the officer's leg. The DA prosecuted. Mayor Adams (wrongly) blamed bail reform. This is how the NY Times presented it. But now...1/2
...a judge who saw video evidence says the officer was lying every which way. The cops were conducting an apparently illegal search, and the teen complied with it and kept his hands up. The teen is, in essence, a victim of a police-involved shooting. nydailynews.com/new-york/ny-c-…
Why did he have a gun? A survey of young people in NYC who carry guns found a large majority had had a family member or friend shot, had been arrested themselves, had been shot at, and more. In their experience, police did not keep them safe. courtinnovation.org/publications/g…
It’s worth saying clearly: Bail reform didn't impact this case (Mayor Adams was wrong on that) but the case DOES illustrate one reason (of many) for ensuring protections against pre-trial jailing. In short, #CopsLie.
New Yorkers, you can tell your lawmakers to help protect people from being jailed based on police lies by protecting bail reform. Use this quick & easy tool. p2a.co/odTjzAr
Some context: In 2016, @macfathom wrote a great piece on cops found to be liars by judges, but continuing to do harm because mayors, prosecutors & police commissioners look the other way. villagevoice.com/2016/11/01/the…
One scary thing about advocacy to protect the success of bail reform is that some pols actually believe cops’ and prosecutors’ shtick about “supporting reforms” and “just wanting tweaks”.
“No one should be jailed because they can’t afford $500,” they say.
Who jailed them??
Money bail didn’t jail people. The old bail laws didn’t jail people. Cops jailed people and prosecutors and judges kept them jailed by requesting and setting, respectively, unaffordable bail despite a range of options for release (ROR, unsecured bonds, etc.)
This meant untold suffering and worse. Coerced guilty pleas. Racial oppression. Sharpened divisions and inequalities in society.
Yet under the old laws (and a US Supreme Court ruling and the US Constitution), no one should have been jailed on unaffordable bail.
Bail reform is working. Thousands of New Yorkers have been spared the trauma of jail and still come to court. But what about that guy in the Daily News w/ 138 arrests? A 2015 study finds: “Tailored supportive housing is likely to be less costly and improve outcomes.” [Thread]
In 2015, NYC's Bureau of Correctional Health Services studied 800 of the people most frequently cycling in and out of jail. People like the man with repeated arrests on the cover of @NYDailyNews. What they found: Jail wasn’t working as rehabilitation or deterrent.
@NYDailyNews This week, @NYDailyNews ran a cover story about a man arrested 138 times. Predictably, they got a follow-up story: his 139th arrest. Cops tried to link 5 arrests to bail reform, ignoring that the old system failed 134 times.