The Cenacle is traditional site of "the upper room": venue of Last Supper. Structure is probably partly a 1stc synagogue, built on top 12thc with a Gothic hall by Crusader Kingdom of Jerusalem, and also venerated as the tomb of King David. Ottomans turned it into a mosque 16thc. Inner S wall of the Cenacle. The vaults and window surroundsThe outer S wall of the Cenacle from the little cloister. ThPoint cloud scan of the Cenacle structure, Israel AntiquitiePoint cloud scan of the Cenacle structure, Israel Antiquitie
"Tomb of David" and undercroft below the Cenacle, and roof above 12thc vaults with the Ottoman minaret and dome over the tomb of David.

The complex is now overshadowed by the Dormition Basilica, built 1900-10 by German Catholics after purchase of site by Kaiser Wilhelm II. Niche in the S wall of W compartment of 1st C synagogue, venUndercroft looking W (down the women's aisle) to the tomb ofRoof of Cenacle looking S. Ottoman minaret to right, dome ovRoof of Cenacle looking W, toward the Ottoman minaret. 1900s
The structure stood next to the double-aisled Byzantine basilica of Hagia Sion, and then was incorporated into the SE corner of the Frankish church built on its ruins. This explains why only the S side of the Cenacle is fenestrated. Plan of the 5thc Byzantine Hagia Byzantine basilicaPlan of the 12thc Frankish churchAerial view of the Cenacle (grey dome centre) from E. WikicoPlan 2 of the 12thc Crusader basilica (red) superposed. The
before i get to the point here's some pictures. first 1870s looking SW over the cemetery where the Dormition basilica would be built, then 1900 looking SE when construction begins

yeah I know it's quite a mental effort to get your head round this with no good satellite photos. Photograph by Felix Bonfils, before 1878Stereogram photograph, American Colony of Jerusalem, c.1900
12thc church with Cenacle at Mt Sion, until Kingdom of Jerusalem collapsed, was run by Austin Canons.
Beginning with Austin house of Easby in Yorkshire, conventual refectories in England often had an undercroft included in their builds, so brethren always ate in an "upper room". Easby Abbey, North Riding, f.1155. The initial build of the Haughmond Abbey, Salop. Refectory interior from S cloister wHalesowen Abbey, Warwickshire, a Premonstratensian house, thFlanesford Priory, Herefordshire, under Goodrich castle. The
The Cistercian community that came under the wing of Crusader Roger de Mowbray got a refectory with undercroft at their final Byland site in the early 1160s, almost certainly consciously evoked the Cenacle.
Copied at Cistercian Rievaulx pretty quickly (superstructure early 13thc) Byland Abbey, refectory, looking S from the S walk of the clRievaulx refectory, looking SE. Again there was a vaulted un
some Benedictine houses I can think I've been to of with undercrofts under the refectory are Worcester Cathedral Priory, and Durham Cathedral monk crash-pad Finchale Priory.
both of these actually have their undercroft vaults intact too.
"Cenacle" is English form of the word "coenaculum" the Vulgate uses in Mark 14:15, Luke 22:12, and Acts 1:13/9:39. A cenaculum was the upper dining room of a multi-storey Roman house. In these monastic builds I think there's a fair bit of prestige involved as well as symbolism.
yeah they kept stuff in the undercroft, it's functional. but jacking up your refectory certainly a choice: there's loads that are just built on ground level. e.g. Fountains, Westminster, Lilleshall.

someone should do a refectories catalogue and work out how many had undercrofts. Fountains Abbey refectory, looking SW towards the largely deWestminster refectory from the S, standing in the headmasterLilleshall Abbey, Salop, looking S from the cloister walk. t
not me though lol. Wont be thinking about this until next Maundy Thursday. A happy Easter to all observe the vigils and celebrate.
"Sic non potuistis una hora vigilare mecum?
Vigilate, et orate ut non intretis in tentationem. Spiritus quidem promptus est, caro autem infirma."

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with @drjacameron.stainedglassattitudes.com on bsky

@drjacameron.stainedglassattitudes.com on bsky Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @DrJACameron

Aug 22, 2023
An important drop: the definitive writeup from Stuart Harrison on Beverley Minster and how it's not dependent on Lincoln's rebuild (1192-), instead begun ahead in 1188, as a distinct variety of Gothic also found in monastic great churches in the north!

tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.10…
Beverley Minster, eastern crossing, looking SE. Although begun in 1188, the piers were likely remodelled after the collapse of the lantern above in the late 1210s.
key argument is it was the eastern crossing lantern that collapsed "in medio crucis ipsius basilicæ" during a well-progressed rebuilding programme late 1210s, rather than the main crossing. The western sides of the lantern survive above the high vault that closed the failure off.

Beverley Minster: the north spandrel of the western arch of the eastern crossing looking W towards the main crossing above the vaults and below the roof  John Phillips
Image
My picture from the crossing tower looking E to the site of the collapsed lantern
Also get Stuart's reconstructions of no-longer standing arcades of Jervaulx and Fountains! Carrying on the style from Ripon (c.1181), Byland (early 1170s) and of course, the E arm of York built under Roger de Pont L'Évêque (late 1150s). Never mind Lincoln, hardly needs Canterbury


3D reconstruction of Jervaulx Abbey, showing the three possible clerestory designs  Stuart Harrison
Jervaulx Abbey church. nave looking NE
 3D reconstruction of the bay elevation of the presbytery at Fountains Abbey presbytery. The vault cells have been omitted for clarity  Stuart Harrison
Fountains Abbey presbytery, the arcades were destroyed by the easternward collapse of the crossing tower
Read 4 tweets
Aug 6, 2023
As you've likely seen, The Glynne Arms, Himley, Staffordshire, widely known as The Crooked House - the wonkiest pub in the world - has burnt out, a week after it was sold by Marston's PLC to a private buyer. Chris Green / BBC
built mid-18thc as a farmhouse (1765 mentioned a lot, cautious on that though as I can't find a direct source) it was a public house by the 1830s. Undermined by a nearby colliery going too far, the land on the S side sunk OS 25" Staffordshire LXVII.10, Revised: 1900, Published: 1903
first half of the 20thc its lean was quite renowned and it was widely called The Crooked House. the big brick buttresses had already been put on the S side.


Early 20thc tinted postcard
possibly 1901. makes sense if you look what state the shed was in by the '30s
Vintage Ralph Tuck Real Photo Postcard c.1930 This postcard was specially commissioned by W. Davies, 11A Abbey Road, Gornal Wood. (William Davies was a Stationer & Book Seller in Abbey Road.)  text and image from http://www.lowergornal.co.uk/p_glynnearms.htm
J. Nelson for National Buildings Record, received 15 May 1945
Read 39 tweets
Dec 21, 2022
East end of Westminster Abbey c.1500 by Stephen Conlin, before the old lady chapel (begun 1220 but remodelled c.1256 after the whole Abbey church was rebuilt from 1245) was demolished for new Tudor one 1502-3. The gallery space runs through from the aisles over the main vault.
The E end of the old lady chapel, which we know by excavated walls was polygonal. To the R is the 1470s St Erasmus chapel (yes, short lived!) and its reredos, which was moved by Abbot Islip to over the Lady of the Pew chapel in the ambulatory.
Speculative organ loft built into the back of Henry V's chantry, stalls and tombs I should probably know but I can't remember where to read about the burials in the old lady chapel. Of course the pedantic Remois passage would continue round the window sills. essential
Read 9 tweets
Dec 19, 2022
Time to reveal that thing I've been working on for last few months! After Evensong 15 Jan 2023 I will be talking about the high altar screen @StAlbansCath!

(I've not seen the final colourisation yet, the current header is just my indicative sketch)

stalbanscathedral.org/Event/saints-i…
Funny figure, William Wallingford. Embezzled convent funds with late abbot Stoke: Abbot Whethamstede claimed all he learnt at Oxford was amassing cash.
Yet he advanced to prior, then abbot, and crowned the modernisation of his abbey church begun by Whethamstede with this screen. Initial showing Abbot Walli...
As I'm unlikely to squeeze in the wider 15thc modernisation:
W window was put in at Whethamstede's first abbacy (1420-40) while transept ends were under Wallingford (1476-92). All were destroyed under Edmund Beckett (1st Baron Grimthorpe)'s reign of "restoration" in the 1880s. West front shortly before B...South transept window (over...Best I've found of the N tr...
Read 4 tweets
Apr 18, 2022
Emergency engineering work underpinning the crossing of York Minster in 1967-72 set out the circumstances to open the tombs of two archbishops of York from the 13thc! What they found may surprise you! Or not, if you already know. Good pictures though.
CW human remains. The Walter de Grey tomb in September 2017, from the SE  httpRCHM photograph of the Walter de Grey tomb in November 1968
The superstructure of the tomb of Walter de Gray, died 1255, had been precarious for a long time. Partly from the differential settlement of the Minster, but also due to its remarkably slender Purbeck shafts: decision was taken to dismantle it and strengthen them with steel rods. Undated pre-restoration NBR photograph but marked J.W. on baPhotograph by F.H. Crossley (d.1955)Photograph by Mrs. P Bicknell, recieved by the National Buil
The monument was dismantled down to the superstructure by January 1968. As the whole thing had to be brought down to the floor, the rubble in the chest over the actual coffin lid was removed, and there was a surprise... Overhead of the Purbeck effigy of Walter de Grey afer the reImage of the Purbeck marble effigy of Walter de Grey removed
Read 23 tweets
Apr 16, 2022
Martyrium of St Simeon Stylites, c.20 miles NW of Aleppo. Enormous 100m long church of four basilicas converging on a grand octagon, with the site of the column the titular ascetic lived atop in the Syrian desert at its centre. Built under Byzantine Emperor Zeno last quarter 5thc G Earth satellite image fro...Looking NE - the E arm and ...From the N transept looking...From the E arm looking W th...
yeah it's a tremendously wonky plan, lmao. Suspect E arm was built first aligning to the small 5-bay church on the S side that may have built in Simeon's lifetime (d. 459). Found some scientific paper arguing it might have been wobbled off by earthquakes, absolute nonsense imo ImageLooking east from the nave ...
that smaller church to the S and the courtyard in front where the first pillar site may have been. amazing resources we have these days. I always leave the credit in on G 360s but Kostas Chaidemenos did a particularly stellar set here. Looking N across the courty...Inside the possible first c...
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(