A lot of confusion is unnecessarily being created over civil-mly relations. Let's get some facts clear. In a democracy civilian supremacy is the norm but for the state to function effectively there must be civil - mly harmony.
I have always been known as a hawk on military matters & I carry that label with pride bec I believe in a strong mly capability for Pak, esp Full Spectrum Deterrence. However I also believe strongly in democracy & civilian supremacy as envisaged in our constitution.
So let's be clear. There is no arrogance in a PM appointing CMs of his choice - in fact it is his prerogative. Just as it his prerogative to advise President on selection of the 3 service chiefs. PM's prerogative to select DGI. Advice on mly appts always rightly sought from mly.
Under Articles 243 & 245 our armed forces constitutional role is clearly defined so if mly assists civilian leadership in performing its tasks then it helps foster harmonious civil-mly relations. Help in getting thru imp legislation fosters strengthening civil-mly ties.
However there have been times when critical human rights legislation our govt was committed to, was derailed too! Incidentally interesting to know that politicians who abused mly ad nauseam are kosher now that they have been brought in thru US-instigated regime change conspiracy!
But then why are so many young & old Baloch esp still being "disappeared" or arrested on charges of being anti-state? Also it seems the known corrupt mafia politicians, despite massive evidence, are also washed clean after a US stamp of approval! #PakistanNeedsElections
Q: why should it concern the mly ldrship if relations between govt & some of its ruling party legislators are temporarily strained? This shd only be a cause of concern for the ruling pol party & it's ldrship. #PakistanNeedsElections
Perhaps the most ironical fact is that the US-instigated regime change conspiracy comes at a time when economy stabilising & recovery was visible; when we had controlled the Covid pandemic; when remittances & tax collection were rising; when universal health care was in place;
But this was also the time IK was charting an indep foreign policy; when he had given a clear "absolutely not" to US drone bases; when IK was making the West uncomfortable for bringing together Ummah & UNGA against islamophobia; the Russia trip was just too much Pak indep for US!
So conspiracy was being hatched - many local abettors in which US has invested here - & the cipher reflected this categorically. US-instigated regime change conspiracy to bring a corrupt pol mafia in power that would be subservient to US interests. #امپورٹڈ_حکومت_نامنظور
Now that has happened. An indep-minded PM who vowed never to make his nation bow before any temporal power has been replaced by a motley group of corrupt criminals. It has been done by design - there was never nor is there any neutrality on display here.
IHC was opened late night simply to hear a petition premised on presumption that COAS may be removed by then PM IK! Seriously! Why? It is for the nation to decide if IK let them down & that is thru elections, not thru US-initiated regime change conspiracy. #امپورٹڈ_حکومت_نامنظور
Salute to all our soldiers, LEAs, civilian martyrs who continue to lay down their lives to keep our nation secure. Salute to our people who have come out to reject an #ImportedGovernment thrust on Pakistan thru a US-initiated regime change conspiracy. Pakistan Zindabad.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Shireen Mazari

Shireen Mazari Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ShireenMazari1

Apr 19
The very Honourable CJ of Pak has asked a very pertinent Q if newspaper reports are correct. Why should SC decide on pol crisis? Not sure if an answer, with utmost deference, would be seen as contempt but here goes: Bec SC has been doing so in our chequered judicial history;
Bec parliamentary supremacy reflected in Dy speaker's ruling, while in Speaker's chair, was cast aside by the very Honourable SC on issue of VNC motion; bec even date & time of when NA shd be called was decided by the Honourable court. So we look to Honourable SC to interpret 63A
& we request with greatest deference that the Honourable SC also examine the threatening message of regime change by US conveyed in official cipher from r Envoy & to set up a Commission. After all, Memogate precedence is there for SC action.
Read 6 tweets
Apr 18
سول و عسکری تعلقات پر نہایت غیر ضروری طریقےسے بہت سا ذہنی الجھاؤ پیدا کیا جارہا ہے۔چلئے کچھ حقائق واضح کئے دیتے ہیں۔ جمہوریت میں سویلین بالادستی ایک عمومی ضابطہ ہے مگر کسی ریاست کے معاملات کو مؤثر انداز میں چلانے کیلئے سول و عسکری ہم آہنگی لازم ہے۔
عسکری معاملات پر مجھے ہمیشہ سخت گیر مؤقف کی حامل سمجھاجاتا ہےاورمجھے اس پر فخر ہےکیونکہ پاکستان کیلئےمیں بھرپور عسکری صلاحیت خصوصاً کامل ہمہ جہت دفاعی استعداد پر یقین رکھتی ہوں۔ اس کے ساتھ دستورِ پاکستان کے تحت جمہوریت اور سویلین بالادستی پر بھی میرا ایمان کامل ہے۔
چنانچہ سمجھ لیجئےکہ اپنی مرضی کے CMsکی تقرریوں سےPM کسی تکبر کے مرتکب نہیں ہوتےبلکہ یہ اُنکا اسی طرح استحقاق ہےجیسےتینوں سروسزچیفس کی تعیناتیوں پر انہیں صدرِمملکت کومشورہ دینےکاحق حاصل ہے۔DGI کاانتخاب بھی انہی کااستحقاق ہے۔عسکری تقرریوں پر ہمیشہ درست طور پر فوج سےمشاورت کی گئی
Read 13 tweets
Apr 16
#CrimeMinister's kowtowing before US has already begun so all can "be forgiven"! One: no comment on the "do more" mantra from him! Instead, a huge thank u statement to US for congratulating him! Two: immed removal of new Pak Envoy Masood Khan whom US was reluctant to accept
Bec massive Indian lobbying against him. Agre'ment took months before US accepted! Now PPP loyalist will join Haqqani to do what US wants done! Meanwhile, invisible shadows ensuring total subservience, even forcing critical TV discussions to be cut midway! #امپورٹڈ_حکومت_نامنظور
PTI denied media coverage; pressers not covered;my prog with Mehr stopped midway! Officers pursuing corruption cases ag Sharifs all transferred & invisible calls striking terror in official circles. Invisible protection for imported govt & their corruption #امپورٹڈ_حکومت_نامنظور
Read 4 tweets
Mar 29
The facts:There is a document that was conveyed officially to Pak before filing of motion 4 VNC which refers to VNC. The doc categorically states if VNC doesnt succeed & PM not removed there will be serious consequences 4 Pak. Threats r direct & target Pak in critical issue areas
Confidential & sensitive communications are not placed before public & media. PM IK & our govt prepared to show this doc to CJ SCP. Already shared with civil/mly ldrshp. NS in UK knew & was part of this int conspiracy. Q is how many Opp mbrs here knew?
PM IK's independent foreign policy does not sit well with those powers who have viewed Pak as a state where ldrs are subservient to foreign diktat. ZAB was hanged bec of his indep FP. Regime change is a frequent tool of powerful states & allied vested interests from within.
Read 4 tweets
Sep 28, 2021
So again Pak will be made to pay heavy price 4 being an ally of US in its "War on Terror" as a Bill (see pp 25-26) is introduced in US Senate in aftermath of the US's chaotic Afghan withdrawal followed by collapse of ANA & Ashraf Ghani's flight to UAE.
foreign.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/…
20 years of presence by economically & militarily powerful US & NATO left behind chaos with no stable governance structures.Pak now being scapegoated for this failure.This was never our war; we suffered 80000 casualties, a dessimated economy, over 450 drone attacks by r US "ally"
& disastrous fallout of these attacks on our tribal ppl & area. US Senate shd do serious introspection:Where did $ 2 trillion disappear? Why did the heavily-invested-in ANA simply dissolve? Who asked Pak to free TTA ldrship? Who signed Doha agreement with TTA & hosted them in DC?
Read 4 tweets
Jun 24, 2020
As the Indians up the hostile ante against Pakistan, some have given out that it could be in response to the humiliation the Hindutva Supremacist Modi Govt suffered at the hands of China in Ladakh, but there is a wider context to this.
India feels emboldened partially bec it feels the int community will continue to tolerate its brutal repression in & illegal annexation of IOJK; it's abuse of & making stateless it's Muslim citizens; & its military aggression against Pak - despite the growing criticism it has
received from govts, INGOs & UN bodies regarding all these actions! Why does India feel emboldened? Bec no concrete sanctions have come India's way yet; nor arms embargoes. The unfortunate UNSC mbrshp votes 184 from 192 cast has added to this Indian perception of itself as able
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(