Gender ideology has infected med, psych & social discourse w/ buzzwords we’re supposed to accept as descriptive, but are loaded terms to make sex denialism seem consonant w/ reality. Eg, “transition” is a misnomer b/c no one transitions from one sex to the other (or to sexless).
If we accept “transition” lingo we go directly to arguing over “medical transition” vs “social transition” for children. Neither could possibly contribute to healthy child development b/c “transition” re sex isn’t a thing, & it’s irresponsible for adults to swap fact for fantasy.
Unpacking gender lingo reveals its faith over fact, soul over body doctrine destructive to human flourishing. Gender ideology queers individual self-determination into the upside notion that one can only be authentic & confident if one’s subjective beliefs are affirmed…
& shared by everyone else. Gender doctrine teaches youth to alleviate emotional upset by expecting the external world to bend reality rather than through emotional resilience to “be me” against the backdrop of material reality & alongside the 8 billion others who are “being me.”
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Gender ideology plays linguistic games of at least 6 types. Spot & resist w/ clear, accurate language using non-circular words w/ plain meaning. Kids’ health is at stake; clarity & seriousness are more important than avoiding offense or signaling in-group status thru lingo: /1
Euphemism. Genderism sells well b/c it describes harsh, grave things in light, cheery words. Double mastectomy used to connote somber, empathetic life/death context of women battling cancer. Now “top surgery” has 40,000 girls on GoFundMe begging $$ for voluntary breast loss. /2
Neologisms. To con society into believing & basing policy on false propositions, genderism concocts new words that sound substantive & vaguely academic but can mean nothing or anything. Eg “Transgender” & “Nonbinary” have no real meaning yet have upended sex classifications. /3
“Trans suicide” is a terrible myth to manipulate parents & lawmakers who are nice liberal people & don’t want children’s blood on their hands. But responsible parenting (& lawmaking) means knowing the difference b/w reality & cruelty, b/w a helping hand & helping self-harm. /1
It’s never been a good idea to give kids everything they think they want. It’s downright abusive to gaslight kids into thinking a fantasy is not only what will help them feel good, but if anyone doubts the fantasy the child “will die” (of suicide). Kids learn resilience /2
by struggling thru all kinds of feelings & external unfairness. Wishing you could be a boy/girl when you aren’t, never requires a life of social, legal, medical fantasy - or suicide. Humans evolved sexually dimorphic; sex doesn’t kill, unless a cult convinces you it does. /3
This Forbes article details the trend of men filing Title IX complaints w/ Dept of ED challenging scholarships, awards & similar set asides for women as sex discrimination — & winning. Even w/o “gender identity” replacing sex, women-only benefits are legally vulnerable b/c /1
sex discrimination law strongly favors strict equality (treat people
the same regardless of sex). Title IX has some specific exceptions that allow single-sex services (eg bathrooms, sports) but if it’s not a listed exemption, men probably have the legal right to shut it down. /2
or make it mixed-sex. Women’s ability to have anything that’s dedicated “women only” is under threat 2 ways: 1) men can use Title IX to force benefits to be open to both sexes; 2) “gender identity” means even women-only spaces expressly allowed by Title IX become mixed-sex. /3
Genderism has inverted the mission of every single legacy organization set up for groups w/ a characteristic that needs legal attention or protection. Now, women’s orgs sell out women, gay orgs call gays bigots, disability groups ignore “gender care” that can worsen disabilities.
Legacy organizations are zombie shells of their former venerable missions. Worse than ineffective, they are Trojan horses that keep the $$ flowing in ostensibly to advocate for women/LGB/disabled/kids, but promote policies steeped in gender ideology directly harming those groups.
Turning our backs on these legacy orgs (NOW, ACLU, HRC, etc etc in the US) may feel painful, but nostalgia for rights & liberation movements of past eras won’t restore integrity to groups that have allowed themselves to become “queered” by genderism.
“To most liberals, “supporting trans kids” is just another way to stand up for oppressed groups…This is why “Don’t say gay” works...We don’t want to oppress anyone, esp. not children. But supporting children is not akin to brainwashing w/ gender unicorns” pitt.substack.com/p/cognitive-po…
“Despite…“liberal” beliefs, I now find myself aligned w/ Republicans when it comes to parenting. When my daughter was 12…& wanted a binder…She said she hated her new breasts & had “dysphoria” – her words. This was not the vocabulary of my 12-year-old.”
“We have crossed a line by introducing this kind of magical thinking about gender to our children, & teachers, therapists, healthcare providers, pharmaceutical companies & surgeons are now all entwined in collective…chaos…we need to come together, regardless of…politics”
It’s no coincidence there’s a surge in demand for the “human right” to rent a woman’s womb to “have a baby,” using gay men as cover, only now that all things “LGBTQ” are infected w/ Queer Theory. Parallel w/ genderism’s efforts to dissociate humanity from the reality of sex /1
now comes a new way to foster the notion that humans are gender souls trapped in constrictive bodies that can be discarded, chopped up, bought & sold for parts, on the premise that bodies (our own & others’) exist solely to serve our inner counter-factual fantasies or desires. /2
Gay men didn’t frame surrogacy as a “gay right” until gender ideology took over, perhaps b/c homosexuals intuitively understand that our minds & bodies are inseparably intertwined (struggling w/ sexual orientation requires coming to terms with one’s own sex, the sex of others, /3