Every week we see columns, tweets, headlines blaming progressive prosecutors (wrongly) for crime. But hard research shows that aggressive misdemeanor prosecution might actually *increase* crime — inverting the popular narrative around public safety. (2/5)
And by contrast, a new paper shows that cutting welfare benefits appears to have a serious & lasting effect on crime rates, markedly increasing “offenses for which income generation is a primary motivation.” (3/5) bfi.uchicago.edu/working-paper/…
Papers like these show that, with smarter policies, we can build a world that is both equitable and safe. But our political narrative remains stuck in the view that prison & punishment are the only tools for reducing crime. We need to think more holistically about safety (4/5).
I’m not saying I have all the answers, or that law enforcement doesn’t have a role in building safe communities. But I am saying that the old view — that we can have racial & economic justice *or* safety — is just wrong. We can and must have all three. (5/5)
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Barbarian invasions didn't singlehandedly topple the Roman Empire, nor did (per Gibbon and other scolds) some too-narratively-convenient collapse of republican virtue. Instead, the fall of Rome was at least in part a supply chain failure.
A short thread!!
Starting in the mid-second century B.C.E., the Roman state provided free or subsidized grain to some subset of the population. Egypt began to supply most of that grain starting in the reign of Augustus.
Fast forward to roughly 400 C.E. and, while Egypt now supplies Constantinople, the Western Roman Empire still depends on grain from North Africa. Around midcentury, though, Gothic armies capture North Africa. Regular traffic of grain ships across the Mediterranean *to Rome* ends.
@RSI@senatorshoshana Allow me to expand. This is a big deal because it's another policy heavyweight, with significant credibility on the Hill, coming out in favor of a sentencing reform package that's flying under the radar of most reporters, but will do a lot of good once enacted.
@RSI@senatorshoshana But @RSI is *also* endorsing the Equal Act, as a matter of public safety and common sense. That bill would finally #endthedisparity in crack and powder cocaine punishment, but faces an uncertain future in the Senate despite a resounding 6-1 vote in the House.
Downplaying the increase in homicides makes it seem like “reform is a luxury.” That’s a mistake, says @JohnFPfaff. Really insightful point that turns the issue’s framing on its head.
Yes, crime in general is down. But violent crime drives the political discussion, and murder especially, says @JohnFPfaff.