Voter ID is a “solution” for a problem that doesn’t exist - and it will lead to disenfranchisement of people from ethnic minority and working class communities
Matt Hancock is trying hard to convince us all that he wasn’t responsible for unlawful policies that led to thousands of care home residents dying - he blames PHE
As well as being morally reprehensible, his “defence” is untenable
Let’s look at some documents from the case… 🧵
Matt Hancock claims the High Court judgment says that he did not receive advice from PHE on the risks associated with asymptomatic transmission
But that isn’t what the judgment says…
What the High Court says is that no evidence was provided *to the Court* to show that Hancock or his advisers addressed the risk of asymptomatic transmission when drafting the second of the policies under challenge in early April
He says Govt didn’t know about asymptomatic transmission when it allowed hospital patients with Covid to be transferred to care homes without proper mitigations
The High Court said “it is apparent that the changing evidential picture was recognised within Government” and cites Lord Bethell’s remark in the HoL on 9 March & Sir Patrick Vallance’s comments on the Today programme on 13 March re asymptomatic transmission