Anton Barbashin Profile picture
May 4 11 tweets 2 min read
Can Putin just call THIS a victory and be done with it?
There is an ongoing discussion about it.
I don't think he can do a "full Syria" at this point any longer.
This war gone too far and there are no longer good options for the Kremlin.
Thread 1/11
Sure, Russians or at the very least half of the nation believe propaganda. They believe Russia is fighting NATO via Ukraine as proxy, there are all sort of horrors happening in Ukraine but Russia is on the right side of history, "victory will be ours" and all that.
2/11
So on May 9th or May 29th Putin can address the nation and declare A victory. "Russia has liberated Donbas. People that suffered there are safe".
But can he then pull out 90% of forces involved back to Russia and call it a day?
Doesn't look like it.
3/11
There has not been a major victory for Russian military nor Ukraine is depleted of resources.
Russians are slowly occupying Kherson and South East and showing no signs they would be ready to leave it.
So, can he minimize fighting at this point and avoid UA counterattack?
4/11
Can Putin actually stop fighting and even preserve what was already captured?
Even if we imagine Kremlin will be okay with being done with what was already taken, I doubt Kyiv will agree.
So, continued fighting is unavoidable.
5/11
So in a sense, Putin can declare a victory only to announce that now Russia will need to defend that victory - and seek yet new ways to get people excited about going to fight in Ukraine.
None of that would be enough to lift any of the sanctions
6/11
So Putin under no circumstance can declare any type of victory over the West.
By the end of the summer/in the fall - when Russia runs out of all the pre-war reserves and Russian manufactures go back to producing 1984 models of cars and equipment, some
7/11
additional explanation would be due.
Also, let's not forget that practically every single day there is a "fire" or clear cut attack on military and logistical objects in Russia.
People in Bryansk,Kursk and Belgorod will hardly get even the "victory over Donbas" at this point
8/11
Then of course, what do you do with Kadyrov, Volodin and every other Medvedev that demands taking the Phase 2 to the entire territory of Ukraine, taking Kyiv and all?
Sure, you can ask them to be quite - but once they figure out that Putin ends with a "victory over Donbas"
9/11
or in other words with political, military, diplomatic and economic defeat - how long do they stay the course and not look for "other options"?
Again, I'm speculating here a bit. But my point is that Putin got himself in a situation when he no longer has a plug.
10/11
He can't just say "we're done" and actually be done with it.
Again, he may proclaim Victory only to begin shooting back the very next day.
Syria was a universe away from Russia. This in not Syria
11/11

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Anton Barbashin

Anton Barbashin Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ABarbashin

Apr 25
What is the Russian "Party of War" like?
Who are the hawks of Russian elite and why do they push for more escalation? What motives them?
Thread 1/6
Russian elite could be divided into three groups: the largest group "party of silence", a tiny "party of peace" - a number of Yeltsin-era oligarchs like Roman Abramovich, Oleg Deripaska, Mikhail Fridman and Vladimir Lisin and the most visible "party of war"
2/6
Key figures of the party of war are: Ramzan #Kadyrov, Dmitry #Medvedev, Vyacheslav #Volodin, Dmitry #Rogozin, Andrey #Turchak, Alexei #Gromov and a few other.
This groups has no hierarchy, they are often act
3/6
Read 6 tweets
Apr 22
Speculative thread on Russian military communication.
Why announce plans to create a land bridge to #Transnistria while most of your forces are not even there and are clearly set to encircle UA troops in around Kramatorsk area? Divert attention from where you actually attack?
1/8
Everyone has jumped to discussing Russian "imminent" attack on "Odesa and Moldova" while just a couple of weeks ago Russian army has proved that it is incapable of doing just that. It can't fight multiple fronts at once. It has to regroup and attempt to take one at the max.
2/8
Moreover, it kind of sounds dumb to announce exactly where you going to attack next BEFORE you've dealt with Ukrainian resistance in Donbas.
It seems clear that Russia has to change tactics from early March and thus would not be doing the same dance twice.
3/8
Read 8 tweets
Apr 20
Something about how persecution of Russian civil society works. Recently there was a publication about "British network of influence in Russia" in a freshly created "media" that looks a bit more complex then Prigozhin dumps.
A material is based on stolen documents of Moscow
1/4
School of Political Studies seminars in Oxford for media. These documents could have been hacked
either from a participant or from someone within the organization.
What is curious though that whoever processed those documents added facts of biographies/data that
2/4
either could have not been in those documents or are fake. For instance, @IrisovaOlga who was a speaker has few lines of bio added/links to profiles she doesn't have. And I was labelled as someone working for Navalny's now "illegal" organization FBK.
Naturally, the tone of
3/4
Read 4 tweets
Apr 19
Because of my dissertation I read a lot of Russian foreign policy writing. I think I would be ready to program an algorithm to write those texts pretty soon now. Especially when dealing with "world order".
A few simple steps for the most generic text:
1/8
DOs
1. Assert the world order is changing/unipolar moment is gone/multipolarity is coming.
2. West is on historic decline/Asia is on the rise (mention China and India).
3. Proclaim that some new integration is due/old one boosted - BRICS, Greater Eurasia, Eurasian Union+
2/8
4. Crucial point - this new world order desperately needs Russia (energy/security/diplomacy).
5. This new configuration is better because is it going to be more just/fair/balanced (if you're hip - you could mention western colonialism legacy here)
3/8
Read 8 tweets
Apr 11
The quest to define "what has just happened" and "why it is a new beginning for us" by Russian foreign policy community is on the rise.
Here is a take by Dmitry Trenin, following the lead of Fyodor Lukyanov.
I'll help translate/interpret his key points. Thread
1/
Thesis 1: this is not about Ukraine. This is a story of the changing world order, shifting power from the West to China/India and other non-Western world.
Thesis 2: With this war Russia has ended it's 300 year attempt to become part of Europe. But this Europe, he says was
1/7
more a community of the West and Russia does not belong to it (mostly)
Thesis 3: Russia is a civilization of its own - European East/Orthodox East - along with Belarus, Serbia and Donbas, we are the heirs of Byzantine.
Thesis 4: Russia is not just a former European Empire.
2/7
Read 8 tweets
Mar 29
Over the course of last week we've seen media reports and statements from Russian officials that indicate that:
Russia is ready to drop "denazification" but it is the still the purpose of war;
It was about Donbas all along but Russia's bringing more troops to the war theater
1/7
Russia is recognizing Zelesnky as the sovereign leader of Ukraine and that Ukraine is governed by a Nazi junta;
The negotiations are progressing but nothing of first importance is getting agreed upon.
There are at least several reasons for this ambiguity -
2/7
A number of people that actually know what Russia's policy towards Ukraine now is is close to zero. Even Putin might have not decided what to do and is considering multiple options.
Several of Russian policy makers are attempting to get the most favorable outcomes for
3/7
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(