Lewis Goodall Profile picture
May 7 20 tweets 4 min read
BREAKING: Sinn Féin are now on 27 seats- they’re at a point where numerically where they cannot be beaten by the DUP.

It is the first time in the 101 year history of Northern Ireland that a nationalist party has won the most seats in an election. Historic.
Fermanagh and South Tyrone have pushed them over the top. 3 seats, no change.

Indeed with 2 seats to go we can say that SF aren’y going to gain seats, they’ll stick on 27. They’re going to come first because of the decline of DUP and splintering of unionism.
It’s a significant moment of fact and of symbolism. For a long time political nationalism in Northern Ireland was essentially disbarred from or contained within the system. Now a nationalist, and a Sinn Fein nationalist at that, would be the nominee for First Minister.
It is historically important and remarkable too. The partition of Ireland took place after the 1918 general election, where most of Ireland voted for the first Sinn Fein, much of Ulster voted for unionist parties. Hence the divide and NI's borders were drawn up to ensure...
...a Unionist majority and dominance in the then subsequent political institutions. Instead we've gone from Terence O'Neill, the fourth Northern Ireland Prime Minister of the old Unionist dominated Stormont, to the prospect of Michelle O'Neill, as powersharing First Minister.
But much of the fevered talk about an imminent collapse of the UK and reunification is misplaced. For the following reasons

1) There's no guarantee O'Neill will become FM. Power sharing requires the assent of the DUP and Unionism to operate. DUP have six months to play with.
2) Even if there is a new Stormont and O'Neill becomes FM, the posts of FM and DeputyFM are equal. There will be no practical changes to nationalism's power. They cannot call a border poll, in the gift of the UK govt.
3) Part of the reason nationalism won't have more power...
...is because in terms of the strength of the two blocs there really hasn't been much change. If you add up the votes of the nationalist parties and the unionist parties they're both on roughly 40% each. That's why the DUP has ended up just behind SF on seats even though...
...they were quite a bit behind on share- they received the reallocated second, third etc preferences of other unionist parties. SF itself stayed static in terms of seats and only a modest increase in share, largely from SDLP, the other main nationalist party.
4) Had it not been for the workings of the electoral system, the TUV (the hardline unionist party led by Jim Allister) would have won more seats.

Again, that's not to underestimate the symbolic and historical significance of SF coming top, in NI of all places symbolism matters.
And clearly the prospect of having Sinn Fein in first place in Northern Ireland and possibly a Sinn Fein Taoiseach after the next Irish elections changes the dynamics and tone of Anglo-Irish elections. The biggest parties in north and south would be agitating for a border...
...poll and reunification in a way that certainly in the Republic has not happened for decades. We've gone from a place pre-Brexit where the constitutional question in NI was entering near dormancy to a place where it is again central.
But overemphasis on SF's first place risks distracting us from two other big stories in this election

1) the rise of the Alliance: There have always been two blocs in NI politics, Unionism and Natioanlism. The Alliance is non-aligned and non-sectarian and wants to move NI away..
...from that sort of politics, for which it remains such an outlier in modern Europe. It was the big winner of the election, gaining 9. It had 17% of the vote. It's a sizeable bloc of its own, winning support from unionists and nationalists and young people in particular...
...for whom those labels mean less. If there were to be a border poll, these voters will be the key. But even short of that, their presence adds a new dimension, a glimmer of a different sort of politics in NI which shouldn't be underestimated.
2) A border poll isn't going to...
...happen any time soon in any event. Far more pressing than lofty discussions about the breakup of the UK is the immediate stability of NI, which has been destabilised by Brexit, by the changes in the UK's political arrangements with the EU and therefore the Republic...
...which has placed Northern Ireland and its old settlement in the most difficult position. We find ourselves consistently drawn into the dreary steeples of the debate around how Brexit can work in NI, and the inescapable quicksand of the fact unionists won't accept...
...the protocol and nationalists can't accept the alternative of any kind of border with the Republic. That fact and deep contestation means represents a continuing unstable element in the politics of NI which is far more pressing than questions around a border poll.
Talk of reunification will get all the headlines. But that belies the fact the politics and power bloc of NI remains finely balanced. Finding a way through this impasse will be extremely difficult. It's going to be up to London and Dublin to find answers. The stakes are high.
And those stakes relate more to the stability of Northern Ireland itself, ie the continued viability of power sharing and the institutions created as part of the Good Friday agreement, than it does to which state it might ultimately find itself a part of.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Lewis Goodall

Lewis Goodall Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @lewis_goodall

May 9
Keir Starmer's press conference starting

"People were entitled to expect that politicians would follow the same rules as everyone else. When my Mother-in-Law died suddenly just before lockdown, my wife and I were unable to provide the support to her father we wanted to."
"Because we followed the rules. Barely a day has passed where we haven't agonised over that decision. But we did it. Because we followed the rules."
Starmer: "The idea that I would casually break those rules is wrong. And frankly I don't believe those who are accusing me believe I would either. They're trying to feed cynicism, to get the public to believe that all politicians are the same. I'm here to say that they're not."
Read 9 tweets
May 9
Have heard similar things. Really this is the only play if Starmer knows he would resign if fined anyway. This is the only way he gains political advantage from it if he comes through unscathed- by drawing a counterfactual comparison between himself and the Prime Minister.
If he doesn’t think he would resign if fined, then that’s another story but also a whole different world of political pain.
Read 4 tweets
May 7
Scores on the doors for Stormont

21 seats to go…
13 to go
Still waiting

As soon as SF reach 26 (23 atm) they’ll cross the finish line and we’ll know for sure they’ll be the biggest party
Read 6 tweets
May 7
London wasn't the only city the Conservatives went backwards yesterday. They retreated, often from low or lowish bases in others too.

Birmingham: -3 (Lab HOLD)
Leeds: -2 (Lab HOLD)
Bradford: -2 (Lab HOLD)
Trafford: -4 (Lab HOLD)
Coventry: -1 (Lab HOLD)
Trafford is a really interesting example of the Conservatives' urban and in particular suburban decline. This Greater Manchester borough was Tory until 2018. Now the Conservatives only have 14 seats. Reason for one Sir Graham Brady to worry.
Labour’s sudden progress in Westminster is quite something,
Read 5 tweets
May 7
Over half of Stormont’s seats now in. Already historic as will be the first time a nationalist party comes first in seats in a NI election.

Why is it happening? Largely because of significant DUP decline rather than SF gaining much vote share. Unionist vote fragmented.
Northern Ireland was quite literally designed to prevent nationalist parties coming out on top. It’s a fundamental change.

But remember, if you add up unionist parties, unionism still has a plurality, just about.

But the non-aligned Alliance is the big winner, from 5th to 3rd
Some seats where all the members have been declared

Lagan Valley-DUP stronghold. DUP vote decline to TUV’s benefit. Alliance biggest winner. SF picking SDLP support.
Read 5 tweets
May 6
Yesterday the general assumption was that anything over 200-250 seats would be a poor result for the Conservatives. They’re currently on 320 losses. It’s been a poor night indeed for them: hovering around some of the party’s worst performances in the last ten years.
And the 325 is just for England. Across Great Britain the Conservatives are currently on 455 losses. That’s very bad indeed. The party’s second worst result over the last decade.
As ever the order of the results influences how they’re perceived. And though there are places of genuine advance for the Tories, where the headwinds of realignment are still carrying them through, there are plenty of places Lab are making up ground against them and…
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(