About usefulness or not usefulness of Reading Books of Famous Lawyers:
As a young lawyer, I too read such books. They inspired and I hoped that reading them would improve my English expressions and use of idioms and phrases.
But after many years now, I have different views.
2/ I have found that such books have not helped me in my journey.
Some of these books were just showcases of their intelligence.
In some books they just tried to transfer their unfulfilled arguments, dreams, Just as our parents wanted us to pursue their dreams..
3/ None of the books which I read was specially written to empower Lawstudents or young lawyers. This was their last consideration.
Successful lawyers of these books had different circumstances, different education,
Their parents were different. Their cities were different.
4/ They were sucessful for the reasons that were not even remotely applicable to me.
These book unnecessary created in my mind "high, unreal, fanciful, idealistic view of the world".
It created a "cognitive dissonance in my mind".
5/ I felt that with their ideals, my steps were not exactly falling on my grounds of my realities..
If I needed to improve my language and expressions, I could have directly read books which taught those skills.
6/ Their struggles, their dreams, their ideals were not which I could pursue.
I needed to read some books, that could have helped me to think independently on my own.
I needed to become an authentic person.
7/ I needed some books that could teach me how to observe realities of my own circumstances.
Later I read some books for that purpose.
Last week I saw an old movie on Hotstar, "Dead Poets Society". It was to the point. The movie exhorts to become authentic in first 15 mins.
8/ If you are a fan of famous legal personalities, do read their books. I have no quarrel with your opinion.
But I suggest that you read some books that a) enhance your life skills b) and help you to think on your own about your own best interests.
Thread : Can a Police Officer seek Stay Order from Court if he is transferred, for not investigating as per wishes of political leader?
1/ The general answer is NO.
2/ Before 1982, if a govt officer was transferred in violation of guidelines, Courts used to stay such transfer
3/ Then a legal principle was evolved, "No govt servant has right to serve at any particular place". (So even if he is transferred in violation of transfer guidelines, no court can grant stay order on transfer.)
This principle of law, put all govt servants at mercy of Admin.
4/ After this principle was evolved, the Courts became helpless.
Though they can see that an honest govt servant is being transferred wrongly, they cannot stay the transfer order..
2/ The public perceptions of a public personality is formed by the way he is seen in public, the way he speaks when he is public, what he is seen "writing for public viewing". This is all about managing optics. Now professional services of Perceptions Managers have also come up.
3/ This automatically means that a Public Person must hide that which is distasteful to public eyes and he should display only that which is suitable for public. This creates a double personalities within one individual.
"God Help Me".. These three words are probably most common words in all religions of the world. These words could have varients. But request for help is almost same in almost all religions of world.
2/ "Is this God?" a very small boy pointed out at the stars blinking in a dark night and asked his father.
Later, this young boy became a great scientist. He discovered Lasik rays. His name is Dr Mani Bhaumik.
He authored book "Code Name God".
3/ In the book "Code Name God", after eleventh chapter he is discussing how science is likely to catch up with religions.
Thread ; What you need to know if you want that certain crime need to be investigated by CBI.
1) Demanding CBI probe by starting trend on twitter usually do not help, though it may cause public support.
You need to know how to put law into motion.
2/ CBI can enter investigation of any Crime
a) At request of Central Government,
b) At request of State Government if it is endorsed by Central Govt.
c) By order of a High Court on an order under Art.226 petition filed by a relative of deceased or a complainant.
3/ d) By an order of Supreme Court passed in Art 32 petition by or on behalf of complainant or by an order in Art 136 petition against order by which High Court may have refused to order CBI investigation
Thread to explain "How murders are punished in India, in accordance with degrees of murders and why law to give death sentence to child rapist may not stand scrutiny of Judges, and why there is trend to impose reformative punishments"
1) You may find this thread interesting.
2/ This thread may be long as it is very difficult to explain these concepts in short. But it will Not be a very long thread.
3/ Know that in India, there is no detailed classification of different types of murders as First Degree Murder, Second Degree Murder etc.
Thread on "Why bad things keep happening to people?".
1) Many good people keep wondering why bad things continue to keep happenning to them though they have done nothing wrong. They wonder why destiny is so hard on them though they are always doing good things?"
2/ In sixteenth century a lawyer and philosopher wrote a short novel titled "Zadig" centred around theme why bad things keep happening to good people.
The novel shows how bad things continued to happen to Zadig though he was a well read and wise man.
3/ The good people assume that if they will be good and fair to others, the others will also be good and fair to them.
There appears to be no such hard and fast rule. There are some others laws that mould the conducts of human beings.