Walter Derzko Profile picture
May 28 16 tweets 5 min read
Remembering the late Dr. Bohdan Hawrylyshyn, a truly unique individual .

The only Ukrainian member of the Club of Rome, as far as I know, & cofounder of the European Management Forum at Davos.”Bohdan Hawrylyshyn was a Canadian, Swiss & Ukrainian economist,strategic thinker,1/
benefactor and advisor to governments and large companies worldwide. (Wikipedia). Bohdan was one of my early mentors. After reading his book “Roadmaps to the Future” in 1980, I got interest in Futures Studies & Strategic Foresight, which I later taught at OCAD university 2/
MA program in Strategic Foresight & Innovation. I was honoured to be his friend. His prediction for the collapse of the Russian Federation for 2024-2026 may still hold true. ( at the latest 2030 when Russia run out of viable oil/ gas exports & goes broke, like the USSR 3/
did previously)
His comments to my posts from Sept 2014.

SWOT / W
A 2nd weakness of the RF we should focus on is the economic collapse of the RF just like the USSR.

Here is part of my email exchange with Dr. Bohdan Hawrylyshyn in Geneva on this point.4/
Dear Walter,

It was a great idea to raise the topic. I have some ideas on one of the ways to try to outfox Putin. I have been predicting for the last year, but not in a published form, that Russian federation will disintegrate in 10/12 years, like the Soviet Union did in 1991.5/
I have predicted the event in my book “Road Maps to the Future: Towards More Effective Societies” in 1980, which was subsequently published in 8 other languages. The 2nd English edition of 2009 is called “Towards More Effective Societies. Road Maps to the Future”.6/
It includes a Chapter “Ukraine: The Last 20 Years and the Next 20”. My prediction is based on analysis rather than on wishful thinking. Here are some of the elements of the analysis: 7/
- GDP per capita in 🇷🇺 Federation is much higher than in 🇺🇦. This hides however the fact that it is indeed way higher in the “islands of wealth”in Moscow, Saint Petersburg, Tatarstan, possibly Novosibirsk and in the far east Zeleny Mlyn (with 🇺🇦 as a big part of population).8/
- In the rest of the RF people are very poor. One just has to go 40 km out of Moscow to see that poverty, I’ve seen it several times.
- Enormous corruption, starting with Putin and various special services, fully subserving to him. 9/
- 🇷🇺’s infrastructure(roads,railroads,planes etc.) is in very poor condition,with some exceptions e.g. Railroad St Petersburg –Moscow. Very little investment in upholding, modernizing expanding the infrastructure because the available money went into pockets of those in power.11/
- The bulk of the income from the export comes from gas, oil, aluminum, nickel, uranium & weapons, i.e. mostly from natural resources, in some cases with some transformation.
- Very narrow industrial base.11/
Production of military hardware with many components from Ukraine, some petrochemicals, steel, some type of machinery.
- Scientifical forces in the “islands of wealth”, autonomous republics.
- The number of global consumers of 🇷🇺 propaganda is shrinking with great rapidity.12/
- RF is almost fully isolated from the West, from which it was buying or steeling technology and importing so many consumer goods, now banned by sanctions imposed by US and EU.
I think it would be worth to publish some such publications about the imminent collapse of the RF 13/
& that Putin and company react. This might tilt this balance of Ukraine and Ukrainian diaspora, merely reacting to enormous lies of Putin an co°.

Keep up your good work.

With my best regards to you and friends in Toronto,

Bohdan Hawrylyshyn 14
Sadly, Dr Hawrylyshyn passed away in 2016
N.B. I did publish a blog post 3 years earlier in 2011 about the collapse of Putin & Yanukowych regimes. Well, I was 1/2 right. Borys Nemtsov, translated my blog into Russian & subsequently in appeared in dozen of 🇷🇺 media 15/
My blog 2011 post, updated in 2015 smarteconomy.typepad.com/smart_economy/… got me into a lot of trouble with the Kremlin, 16/

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Walter Derzko

Walter Derzko Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SmartEconomy

May 28
Putin’s bluffing with nukes

Lots of rhetoric & threats that Putin will use Russian nukes. It’s all a bluff!
Ukrainian counter intel knows it & Putin knows it! I wonder about the maintenance of 🇷🇺 arsenal (silos and missiles) after 30-40 years. Most wouldn't fly. 1/
Recall that Russia was asking the US & other countries for help to clean up nuclear reactors in aging submarine fleet rotting in the harbors. Do we believe that the missiles in the silos are any different. The fuel is very corrosive so the engines are probably all rotten away. 2/
Other similar comments from experts

“Nuclear missiles have a finite shelf life, the warheads decay. The fuel is corrosive, and they have a lot of rubber gaskets and seals.

If Russian tanks and trucks aren't being serviced properly, why would the missiles & silos be? 3/
Read 7 tweets
May 28
Remember in late Dr Bohdan Hawrylyshyn Part 2 of 2

From an email exchange in 2014
“I think it would be worth to publish some such publications about the imminent collapse of the RF, and that Putin and company react.
1/
This might tilt this balance of Ukraine and Ukrainian diaspora, merely reacting to enormous lies of Putin an co°.
Keep up your good work.
With my best regards to you and friends in Toronto,
Bohdan Hawrylyshyn”
2/
Sadly, Dr Hawrylyshyn passed away in 2016.

BTW, I did publish a blog post 3 years earlier, in 2011 about the possible collapse of Putin & Yanukowych regimes. Well, I was 1/2 right. The late Borys Nemtsov, 🇷🇺 opposition leader, translated my blog post into Russian 3/
Read 11 tweets
May 28
Lose the battle in the short term but win the war in the medium & long term!

How Ukraine 🇺🇦 will outsmart Russian forces 🇷🇺 strategically and tactically…my take on the next steps1/
In the short run over the next month or two, we may see Russian forces 1) making incremental gains in strategically insignificant towns & villages in Donbas, and 2) establishing beachheads to try & control this temporary territory 2/
Russians will be suckered into this play, to give Putin a much needed & desired win (ie capture & hold/ control), which Russia has not had so far in this war. This will be a fatal mistake by Putin & his generals 3/
Read 10 tweets
May 28
The Russian GRU - Unit 54777

Since its founding in 1918, the GRU has always been a full-scale intelligence service, running operations all over the world. Unlike the KGB, which was dissolved & then refashioned into several separate agencies, 1/
the GRU has remained a constant institution throughout the Soviet and post-Soviet eras. It has:

👉🏻recruited spies and run “illegals” from Manhattan to Tokyo;

👉🏻it’s stolen industrial, military, and atomic secrets;

👉🏻it’s attempted coups and assassinations;
2/
👉🏻it’s propped up disinformation portals masquerading as “news” agencies; and

👉🏻it’s run ambitious cyber operations that have inveigled or damaged democratic electorates, shut down national power grids, and temporarily halted international commerce to the cost of $ billions. 3/
Read 11 tweets
May 28
Historically Moscow/ Muscovy belongs to , or are vassals to / slaves to Crimea - the Crimean Khan , not the other way around, as 🇷🇺contends now.

Ukraine on the map of 1652

Another work by the Frenchman G. Beauplan, which is also quite interesting and artistically attractive.1/
"A new map of the entire Kingdom of Poland, the Grand Duchy of Lithuania with their voivodships and their borders was made in detail by G. Levasser de Beauplan, His Royal Highness, military architect and captain." 2/
Original was added to the book of 1652 "Simonis Starovolsci [i] Polonia, nunc denuo recognita et aucta ...". It can be seen on page 11. This map in the Swedish archives is a later copy of the work of 1651 (See Figure 15. Map 13 of our book, Treasures of the Swedish Archives).3/
Read 17 tweets
May 27
Putin’s Hopes to Exhaust Ukraine with a Long War Almost Certainly for Naught, Eidman Says
Paul Goble
            Staunton, May 11 – The US has concluded that Putin, having failed to defeat Ukraine quickly as he expected to do, now hopes to win by means of a war of exhaustion; 1/
but such hopes, Igor Eidman says, are almost certainly for naught given the attitudes of Russians & the resources of the Ukrainians.
            “Russia is rapidly exhausting its own resources and has nowhere to replace them,” the Russian sociologist says, 2/
while Ukraine now has access to the virtually “unlimited military and economic resources of the US and NATO” (gordonua.com/blogs/eydman/b…). 3/
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(