This is a Starlink in Ukraine & future history thread🧵
In case you all haven't noticed, Starlink connected to the Ukrainian 'Gis Arta' artillery C3I app in a vehicle mobile device is pure death for Russians.
The Russians have a great many reasons to be utterly pissed off at Elon Musk.
I have referred to the Russo-Ukrainian War as the "First Starlink War" for many good & sufficient reasons.
The military & political power accruing to Musk from Starlink and Starship will not
3/
...be broken up by the American SCOTUS for the next 20 years.
And I mentioned the military dimension for a reason. If Russia wants to start "Space War One" with Elon. It will lose it for logistical reasons.
1st, Russia failed at hacking Starlink.
4/
2nd, every satellite with a working thruster can be an anti-satellite weapon ONCE.
Musk has more ion drive 'space ammo' than everyone else in humanity combined & can launch it faster & cheaper than Russia without Starship.
Software used to avoid space impacts can be used
5/
...to direct them.
And this leaves out the possibility that multiple close approaches by Starlink satellite's won't be arranged such that a Russian ASAT gets blasted & 'soft killed' by Kryption fueled ion thrusters using temporarily positive-charged ion thrust streams.
6/
And by the way, with sufficient warning from the US Space Force, the delta vee that Starlink satellites have from their ion thrusters make them a slippery target for an orbital maneuvering ASAT.
Superior specific impulse & long burn times do that. 7/
This doesn't mean a direct assent Russian ASAT can't tag a Starlink bird.
The problem is that after the 1st try, they will be harder to hit.
Plus, Musk's SpaceX simply has more replacement Starlink satellites in his next Falcon-9 launch than Russia has direct assent ASATs. 8/
So playing high tech "Hybrid War" with SpaceX is a losing hand for the Putin Regime.
Russia attacking SpaceX launch or control facilities in the territory of USA will start a war Putin is guaranteed to lose.
That leaves assassination, which is where Ukraine comes in.
9/
However the Russo-Ukrainian War ends, the Ukrainian people will be a very close political and military ally of Musk for the rest of his life.
It is a Ukrainian blood debt to be repaid to Elon Musk which hits a whole lot of deep cultural identity keys
10/
...in the Ukrainian national character.
There is a lot that flows from that fact which many of Musk's detractors & enemies clearly have not begun to think through.
A lot of Humanity's future history will have its roots in this 21st century blood-debt relationship.
11/
Frankly, things have been so "science fiction turned reality" lately.
I would not be surprised if SpaceX gets a detachment of Ukrainian Space Marine-Astronauts for Elon's personal & Martian colony security in the 2030's.
12/End
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Alright, one more Russo-Ukraine War casualty rate thread🧵
This one is to deal with a specific criticism of my 5 June 2022 posts that WW2 casualty rates are in no way representative of what Russia is suffering in Ukraine.
There is a point to that "WW2 isn't representative" criticism, but it doesn't cut the way people making that argument think.
Casualty rates are a function of the type of combat fought and the medical support available. The reality about Russia's Army in Ukraine is that it
2/
...has the highest AFV to soldier ratio of any combat force fighting on this scale...ever.
This wasn't by design.
It was a downstream consequence of "Ghost Troop" corruption, a grift where Russian commanders pocket the payroll for soldiers not present in their unit.
3/
I've gotten some push back on my last two casualties in the Russo-Ukrainian War threads.
So, I'm going to drop some photo clips in this 🧵from on-line WW2 casualty documents that were background to the previous casualty posts.
They will illuminate who is dying in this war.
1/
When I referenced Trevor Dupuy in the previous tweets. It was due to the fact I backtracked to WW2 casualty reports to validate Dupuy's source data so I could trust it.
There were a lot of casualty reports in WW2, but they had the same general pattern for battle casualties.
2/
When it comes to non-battle casualties, the WW2 reports get a lot flakier.
Let's start with the 1945 Okinawa Campaign and specifically with issues of neuropsychiatric casualties
3/
There is a lot to unpack from this video & for the purposes of this thread. 🧵 The assumption is we are looking at a timely #Severodonetsk counterattack video.
Short form:
The Russian Army has run out of trained infantry, which is what "Culminating Point" means. 1/
Ukraine has inflicted on the order of 79,000 Russian KIA & WIA to date.
Of the 190,000 Russian troops that invaded only between 10% & 20% are dismounted infantry, most likely on the lower end due to Russian "Ghost Troops" corruption.
What is 10% of 190,000?
2/
It's 19,000, and 20% is 38,000.
Russia has not only burned through all its infantry. It has burned through all the LNR infantry as well.
Which is why bolt-action rifle armed DNR troops were sent to both Mariupol and now Severodonetsk in Luhansk. They & the Chechen
3/