Justin Alexander Profile picture
Jul 7, 2022 20 tweets 6 min read Read on X
Westward, ho!

The PCs are shipwrecked in the wilds of Ergoth.

The core concept of DL7 Dragons of Light is that all the elves in the world have fled here on ships, only to suffer the acute embarrassment of having all of their ships spontaneously vanish in a puff of fiat. Image
After negotiating their way through the elven situation, the PCs will therefore need to march north through the only mountain pass in search of a ship to continue their journey, conveniently stumbling upon the Tomb of Huma as they go.
Our Let's Read of Dragonlance started over here if you'd like to begin from the beginning!

The "elven situation" is largely about waves of refugees, which feels more than topical at the moment.

Silvanesti, on the eastern edge of the map here, is the original empire of the elves. Image
After the Kinslayer Wars (which were fought with the old Empire of Ergoth), the elven empire broke apart, and the western lands of Qualinesti declared independence.
More recently, the elves of both Qualinesti and Silvanesti have fled before the dragon army invasions.

Both have chosen to come to the "wilds" of southern Ergoth, forming the refugee kingdoms of Silvamori and Qualimori.

Their close proximity has reignited old tensions.
Here in Ergoth they also discovered the Kagonesti -- dark skinned, "more muscular" native "wild elves" who are immediately enslaved by the white-skinned imperials.
Later depictions of the Kagonesti would course correct to show them as pale-skinned.

But in DL7 they are 100% dark-skinned "primitives". Image
We know this because of the blackface. Image
Whoops. Forgot alt text. Apologies:

"The attacking elves are the Youngbloods,
Qualinesti raiders from across the bay (...) disguised as Kagonesti. The disguise is good only from a distance: up close the berryjuice darkening their skin and hair is obvious."
Anyway.........

A third element in this adventure is the silver dragon Dargent, who is secretly trying to help the PCs find the secrets of the dragonlances buried in Huma's impressive tomb.

(Why secretly? Well, the DM isn't allowed to know because that would ruin the surprise.)
The story as told in the Chronicles novels have now moved ahead of the publication schedule of the modules. Image
The adventures, therefore, are now concerned about spoilers.

Grubb's solution is to provide a random table of possible "secret identities" for Dargent, subverting the expectations of novel readers. Before play begins, either ...
(Although note the incorrect title for the novel here: TALES of Winter Night instead of Dragons of Winter Night. Not sure if that's a typo or an indication of a working title.)
This "randomize the secret role" technique will now become a mainstay of the DL series.

You can compare & contrast with the earlier handling of the traitor in Volume I, where the DM is simply instructed to not allow players to take action based on info gleaned from the novels.
Someone we haven't talked about much in this Let's Read is Fizban, a sort of demented Gandalf figure.

He pops up every so often to spout exposition, provide deus ex machinas, and provide oh-so-random bits of humor. On the topmost step of the ...
In the novels, Fizban is secretly the god Paladine.

You remember? The God of Railroads?

The DM has, once again, not been allowed to know this. (Spoilers!) But the "randomize the secret role" mechanic will actually be used in a later module to obfuscate Paladine's identity, too. Image
The stone dragon on the cover is, in fact, a pretty nifty -- and very unique -- dungeon.

We once again note how the #Dragonlance Saga is packed to the gills with some of the best dungeons in D&D's history. Image
Here's Larry Elmore's original sketch of the dragon.

Apparently the image was originally commissioned for the Dragonlance Calendar (with the editors selecting a different sketch that Elmore used for the final painting), a reminder of the project's massively multimedia nature. Image
The Let's Read continues with DL8 Dragons of War over here!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Justin Alexander

Justin Alexander Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @hexcrawl

Oct 10
Step 1: When you place a secret, you have to be at peace with the idea that the PCs may never find that secret.

If you're not, then the secret isn't really a secret. It's a pantomime.

(This thread will make more sense if you read James' full tweet.)
"I then decide to elaborate about the dust, so they don't miss the secret; now I'm the one deciding whether they find the secret!"

Right. So don't do that.

That's going to solve a bunch of your problems.
First decision you make is how obvious the secret is. This is roughly a spectrum:

- No clue at all; they'd need a blind search to see it.
- Indication only noticed with examination.
- Indication that could be noticed in the initial room description.
- Big sign pointing at it.
Read 27 tweets
Jun 7
Hypothesis: The beholder's mouth gets larger with each new edition.

Let's start with the original 1975 appearance on the cover of Supplement I: Greyhawk. Image
Okay, let's compare AD&D 1E (Tom Wham) to AD&D 2E (Jeff Easley).

Here I think you could argue that the 1E beholder has a wider mouth, but I definitely think the 2E has more maw.
Image
Image
Now AD&D 2E (Jeff Easley) to D&D 3E (Scott Fischer).

Bigger teeth. Bigger mouth.
Beholder, AD&D 2e (Jeff Easley)
Behlder, D&D 3e (Scott Fischer)
Read 9 tweets
Jan 22
This article was removed because it was attracting transphobes and its original purpose was also defunct.

Core claims from the article and the discussion at the time it was written:

1. You shouldn't deadname people.
2. However, the ethics of re-editing material written before a name change is complicated.

3. If Jennell requested a change to the original article, I would change it.

(She did, and I did.)
For better or for worse, I stand by those claims.
Read 8 tweets
Jan 22
I have been asked to respond to this post.

Short version: The post is not only lying about what I said, it's also wrong about what Jennell said and what Jennell's wife has said.

diyanddragons.blogspot.com/2024/01/xander…
For one example completely out of my control, the post claims Jennell's wife said she was in a coma on November 1st in the GoFundMe updates.

You can go look: That's not true.

(Make a donation while you're there.)

gofundme.com/f/jennell-jaqu…
The post is, IMO, deceptive in countless ways, for example by claiming that my descriptions of private messaging in the spring of 2023 is actually describing a public comment on a deleted blog post from 2018.
Read 7 tweets
Jun 20, 2023
When I did theater, we would periodically run into "my significant other is uncomfortable with my character (me) kissing someone onstage."

Never once had someone's significant other get concerned about their significant other getting stabbed or haunted by a ghost on stage.
Remove the script and the formality of the stage and... well...
I'm not even saying "it's because people will get concerned." I'm saying human emotion is complicated and personal comfort with emotion, particularly in Puritanical America, is varied.
Read 16 tweets
Jun 19, 2023
Re: 5E DMG. #dnd

A lot is made of chapter order (start by creating a pantheon of gods!). That's easy to point to, but is really only representative of the more fundamental problem:

The designers didn't have a clear vision for the structure of play. Cover of 5E Dungeon Master'...
So there's a bunch of stuff, but very little of it is actually connected to any clear function. It seems mostly sourced from other D&D books and a vague sense that this is "cool" or "should be there."

Which makes it tough for the reader to come to grips with it.
It's like a hoarder's garage. If you dig through it, you're occasionally like, "Holy crap! There's a 3D printer in here!"

The print head is missing and you'll need to track down some filament before you can use it, but... 3D printer! Wow!
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(