The latest Harrison is a giant encyclopedia of molecular data. Clinical medicine has been reduced to a bare minimum. I am talking about the 20th ed.
In fact, the Oxford Textbook of Med 6th ed is relatively better clinically but it comes in 4 giant volumes.
I am seeing that the 'older' generation of doctors ie those who are consultants and have been practising for a few years now are predominantly in favour of Harrison.
I feel it is likely that they have not read recent eds which have significantly pared down the clinical aspects.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1) It must be hard being an MBBS student nowadays with everybody criticizing you for not having enough clinical knowledge/not going to the wards etc etc.
I don't think we should blame them for circumstances beyond their control.
2) Medical science has expanded so rapidly that you must now run, just to stay in the same place. Basic knowledge has also changed with along with our ideas of complications. Its no longer 'a simple case of anything'.
3) You will need an MBBS course lasting at least a decade if you need people to master all the skills that MBBS students of decades earlier could master. Medical science has far outpaced our capacity to learn.
1) A terrible crash at the Grand Prix today, but thankfully no lives were lost --> and it is all thanks to this man.
2) Who was he?
Dr Eric Sidney Watkins |(1928-2012) , commonly known in Formula 1 (F1) as Professor or Prof Watkins was an English neurosurgeon.
He was the FIA F1 Safety and Medical delegate, head of the F1 medical on track team and first responder for a period nearly 26 years.
3) He is most famous for treating Ayrton Senna, the Brazilian three-time F1 champion who died in 1994 in a crash at the San Marino Grand Prix in Italy. He was only 34 at that time.
1) Gen med residents are taught to think of secondary hypertension, especially primary hyperaldosteronism, if the following conditions are met.
- young onset HTN (age < 40)
- family history
- resistant HTN
- hypokalemia
2) First of all, young onset HTN is a controversial term nowadays --> with the rise of fast food and sedentary lifestyles with pediatric obesity and metabolic syndrome --> it is entirely possible that the age may need to be shifted even lower!
3) This study, done in AIIMS with @DrSarahAlam as the lead author looked at PA epidemiologically.
202 patients with young onset HTN (YH) were evaluated.
A middle aged relative of mine has been forgetting things recently --> he doesn't remember where he put his keys, his assistant's name or what he had for lunch that day.
2) His daughter calls me up and schedules a meeting.
Its borderline Alzheimers --> she worries!
What will happen to him? Is there anything to be afraid of? Should we consult a neurologist?
3) First things first --> I say.
Let me evaluate him and see what needs to be done.
Turns out he is HTNsive on meds for more than a decade, since the time he had his first stroke --> no documents available from that time.
Bilateral locomotor brachialis in a middle aged patient with severe hypertension and severe dizziness under eval ? post circulation stroke --> 280/170 mmg Hg (manually measured 4 times by 4 different people)