Putin is suffering from the failure to understand that Russia is not the great power he thought it was. With his whole army tied down in Ukraine, Kazakhstan is using the opportunity to pull away. Putin’s attempts to maintain influence are likely backfiring.
Xi Jinping’s ducking out of visiting Putin is also an interesting sign. China and India seem happy to take advantage of Russian weakness, but they don’t want to get too close. thetimes.co.uk/article/end-of…
We are seeing the huge problem of basing great power status solely on nuclear weapons. If all you can do is threaten to blow up the world to get your way, you are a well armed weak power. The USA or China never have to threaten nuclear attack to have others cooperate with them.
If Russia were a great power Finland and Sweden would not be in NATO, Kazakhstan and other central Asian states would not be pulling away, The Chinese would not be holding Russia at arms distance, RussIa would not have to sell its oil to China and India at a discount.
The borders of Russia would not be basically defenceless, it’s army would not have to rely increasingly on old and out of date equipment. Calling Russia a great power before the war was just wrong.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Sunday update, a discussion of range/accuracy versus mass. There is a noticeable change in the last 2 weeks in the ranged war (which is the most important in this attritional phase) and that is that Ukraine is now showing the ability to hit back.
If you look at a map of FIRMS data (fires that can be picked up by satellite) there is a significant change since the beginning of June. Then, most of the fire was very close to the front line, and crucially mostly where the Russians were trying to advance.
Best to start with Donetsk Oblast, occupied by Russia for years, which has been a relatively secure base for their logistics and the major city of Donetsk is right on the border between Ukrainian and Russian controlled territory. Here is @War_Mapper purple/red Russian controlled
Worth adding this to the talk about attacking weapons depots. Ukraine also using its new range systems to go after Russian command and control. That’s definitely US doctrine, and if they can seriously degrade both Russian supply and command in the Kherson area, watch out.
Here is a map from the story with some of the largest facilities that have been hit. Most in territories occupied before Feb 24, which would have been large and had time to be built up.
This campaign seems to be going hand in hand with an attempt to sever rail communications to the west,
Btw, I assume Johnson stays unless the Conservative Party rules are changed or he simply can’t find people to serve in his cabinet (and by people I mean anyone). If the rules don’t change and he has a cabinet, bet he stays for longer than we think.
Real question tonight is whether people will accept the open cabinet posts I suppose. And whether more open up.
It has now been 76 days since the Russians launched the Battle of the Dohnbas. This would make it one of the longest major battles in the 20th and 21st centuries. Many times longer than Kursk,e Bagration Normandy, Bulge, etc. Its much closer to WWI (Somme, Passchendale, Verdun)
And what has happened in the 2.5 months so far. Best to start with this map. Basically the Russians have dialled back enormously on their expectations (and frankly the expectations of others) that they would take a big chunk of Ukrainian territory.
Instead after 11 weeks of combat, major losses and command changes, desperate attempts to raise forces and concentrating their firepower in a very small area, the Russians have compelled to Ukrainians to withdraw from Severodonetsk and Lysychansk.