The arrival of HIMARS in Ukraine seems to be causing a real outbreak of despondency among Russian commentators on Telegram. This one is from commentator Dmitryev, who has around 100K followers. @mdmitri91@RALee85t.me/russ_orientali…
Translation: What do the first weeks of HIMARS use in Ukraine tell us? That it will not be possible to get out of the war while saving face. There were options to do so, but back then - in March, April, May. /1
Like taking Donetsk [and] Luhansk [regions] and the south and establishing a foothold for a few years, until a new war. To use these years for creation of new military structures. But no, such an opportunity will not be given. /2
Missiles will fly all the way through the line of demarcation, to the opposite side as well. Ukraine will become an artillery range and will be destroyed during the years of confrontation, the western part of Russia is also under attack. /3
There is no power to push the front to the west, even if they [the Russians] drive a million mobilised people there. /4
In Donbass, the Russian Armed Forces managed to create a local offensive advantage and the Russian command assumed that it would now be possible to slowly push the border westwards from city to city, but now the AFU has an antidote - they are smashing ammunition depots. /5
I am trying to understand what can stop this negative scenario developing - when Ukraine becomes a field of missile war and Russia gets bogged down in losses and subsequent socio-economic problems - and I can't think of anything. /6
To be honest, I don't see a military solution. The only thing that can reduce its intensity is some kind of global crisis, with crises in each specific country, which will push the causes of the war, very abstract, into the background. /end
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
On 24 February 2022, Russia launched a special military operation in Ukraine. The aim is to demilitarise and denazify, to bring to justice all war criminals responsible for the "genocide" of the civilians of Donbass. /1
From the first days of its existence, the 205th Cossack Brigade has been taking part in special operations on the territory of Ukraine and has been successfully fulfilling its military tasks. /2
1/ What do two yachts, a $30,000 watch and the Tsar's former residence have in common? They're all assets of Patriarch Kirill of the Russian Orthodox Church. A 🧵 on how the church's role in the Ukraine war is tied up with its finances and role as an instrument of 'soft power'.
2/ This is the second thread of a series of three (I'll be posting the third part in due course). Here's the first part:
3/ The Russian Orthodox Church (ROC) has faced numerous scandals over the past 30 years concerning its financial affairs. But the story really starts with Russia's 40,000 priests and deans, most of whom work in thousands of small towns and villages across the country.
1/ The Russian Orthodox Church (ROC) has emerged as a major player in the war in Ukraine. The UK has sanctioned its head, Patriarch Kirill, and the EU attempted to do so but was blocked by opposition from Hungary. Why is the ROC in such a controversial position? 1st 🧵 of three.
2/ The Orthodox Churches of eastern Europe have played a hugely important role in the development of their countries. This was brought home to me when I spent Easter this year in Bulgaria, enjoying the Orthodox Easter - a beautiful and very spiritual festival.
3/ From remote and beautiful places such as Bulgaria's Rila Monastery, the Orthodox Church nurtured Christian culture during the long centuries of Ottoman occupation. Rila had Bulgaria's first printing press and produced the country's first Bulgarian-language grammar book.
@ian_matveev has posted another very insightful and admirably realistic thread on the situation in the Donbas following the fall, or imminent fall, of Lysychansk. It's well worth a read. An English translation follows:
Putin's army is taking over Lysychansk. Let's do a brief dissection of the situation and in particular discuss why the Ukrainian army is forced to continually retreat in Donbass. Thread ⬇️
1. A week has passed since Zolote was encircled. During this time the Russian Army called up its reserves to attack Lysychansk, which was in an artillery pocket, with strikes from three sides.
1/ Being a Russian soldier in Ukraine isn't fun. The food is lousy, you're living in squalid conditions, you're constantly being shot at and most of your unit is already dead or wounded. What to do? Report to the nearest Mobile Point for Military-Political Work, comrade! A 🧵.
2/ The collapse of Communism left the Russian army with a motivation problem: if you're no longer fighting for a global proletarian revolution, what exactly is the cause you're fighting for? Putin's Russia has tried to address this in a number of ways.
3/ In early 2018, the Russian Ministry of Defence announced the reintroduction of the Main Military-Political Directorate (GVPU). The GVPU, which had been discontinued after 1991, was originally responsible for Soviet military 'political officers' - known as zampolits.