Thread of excepts I found interesting from the book "The New Dealers' War: FDR and the War Within World War II" amazon.com/New-Dealers-Wa…
Roosevelt issues order to shoot German submarines on sight, Hitler tries to avoid war with America:
Roosevelt gives speech after Pearl Harbor trying to bait Hitler into declaring war on America
George F. Kennan writes that FDR could have avoided war with Japan if he behaved differently:
By the late 30s other countries were recovering from the depression faster than the United States:
Roosevelt wants to provoke war but not fire the first shot... Morgenthau is upset that he FDR would rather follow public opinion than lead it...
FDR works to censor enemies like Father Couglin:
Some people were upset with Germany first policy: 50% of servicemen wanted to kill a Japanese soldier vs 10% who wanted to kill a German soldier
During the first 21 months of the war photos of dead soldiers are not displayed so that the public doesn't call for peace:
Roosevelt worried that not enough enthusiasm towards war, most couldn't name 4 freedoms. War needed to be moralized
When Roosevelt announces doctrine of unconditional surrender, Churchill and the British are concerned it would make Germans fight harder:
Goebbels is overjoyed at unconditional surrender:
British diplomatic office was filled with hatred of Germans which could be traced to one man:
Unconditional surrender may have helped prevent coup in Nazi government:
As the war continued on, race riots swept across many cities including Detroit:
The Vice president Henry Wallace uses the war aims of "fighting for democracy" to condemn these riots:
Roosevelt is sympathetic to the Jews but doesn't want people to think thats the real reason behind the war:
Churchill (first quote) and Roosevelt have harsh plans for the Germans after the war:
Vitriol towards the Japanese reaches a fever pitch, Roosevelts son thinks that half of population of Japan should be destroyed
British and Americans worked out a compromise US would target bomb during the day, British would area bomb at night
Pope sends out message that unconditional surrender is inconsistent with Christian doctrine:
Throughout the war pro Russian articles books and movies swept across America:
Roosevelt thought that a Russian American alliance could be used to reign in European fratricidal tendencies
FDR was seemingly opposed to the British empire and somewhat sympathetic to socialism
Roosevelt tells his ambassador to Moscow he doesn't care if countries bordering Russia become communist
FDR wants his approval of communist Poland kept secret until after 1944 election:
This is pretty well known at this point, but still blows my mind: the Roosevelt govt was teeming with Soviet spies
As brutal air raids continue many Germans tried to lynch downed soldiers, but were often saved by soldiers and led to POW camps
The media decided to start showing photos of the dead so that Americans wouldn't think Germans and Japanese were the only ones willing to die for their own country:
When plotters tried to kill Hitler and they were put down, allied government were unsympathetic and saw all Germans as the same:
As is well known, Morgenthau announces his plans to stamp our Germany after the war cheered on by Soviet spy Harry Dexter White
Morgenthau tells White he doesn't care if 20 million people starve, Germany needs to realize they are a defeated nation
Many German soldiers knew the war was hopeless, but fought on fearing consequences of unconditional surrender
The authors view is that the doctrine of unconditional surrender cost millions of lives
In the last scene in the book, the author describes meeting Truman and asking him what he thought of Roosevelt. Says he is the coldest person he ever met, but brought the US into the 20th century
Short thread about the numerous errors in the post linked below.
First she cites the work of Paul Dolan claiming that married women are less happy. This is due to a misreading of the ATUS. @CathyReisenwitz If you are honest you will correct this.
Obviously we don't know how much is causal, but both married men and women are happier.
She cites the male marriage premium as evidence of a benefit, but that could also be evidence men work harder for their families when they are married, and women don't feel the need to work as hard when they have a man.
Some opinions I have that are left wing or otherwise possibly unpopular or contrarian in this sphere: 1. Toxic masculinity is real (but so is toxic femininity).
2. Depending on the definition, the idea of rape culture doesn't seem that unreasonable.
3. The NYT is probably the best source of news in the country. Sure they are woke and that sucks but they have tons of apolitical reporting. And they often report "based" facts if you read between the lines. The WSJ is good too, but not quite at the level of the NYT
There is an interesting subreddit called r/BarbaraWalters4Scale (referencing the fact that Walters, MLK and Anne Frank were all born in 1929) with a interesting time comparisons. For example:
>Joe Biden was born closer to Lincolns presidency than his own.
>Obama is the only president to serve under the same flag he was born under
>Jimmy Carter lived through 41% of the independent US
>Nintendo existed at the same time as the Ottoman Empire
>Hitler was alive when the big chungus cartoon was released
>Jimmy Carter saw JD Vance (who was born after his presidency) get elected VP
>For his federal elections, Biden had voters between 1880s and 2002
>Hitler's bodyguard could have watched the Hitler epic rap battle
>Betty Marion White (BMW) is older than the BMW car
If TikTok is banned for a while in the US the contents will likely eventually be deleted. Many would say good riddance but I would consider this a loss to the historical record. TikTok contains a record of the trends, attitudes aesthetics, and political debates of the time.
It also gives a record of how Americans reacted to many historical events like the pandemic, BLM riots, the 2020 and 2024 elections, Jan 6th, withdrawal from Afghanistan, invasion of Ukraine, 10/7, the rise of AI and the Trump assassination attempt.