Damian Shiels Profile picture
Aug 9 19 tweets 11 min read
100 years ago today the most intensive day of fighting in the Battle for Cork was taking place around Rochestown. To mark the anniversary of the bloodiest engagement of Cork's revolutionary period, this🧵explores some of the archaeological traces left behind. #BattleforCork100 /1
The National Army had landed in Passage West the previous day, moving to engage IRA defenders on the high ground to the west. Some of the very first fire of this engagement can be traced today- these are impact scars from National Army bullets on buildings opposite the docks. /2
The IRA defence was aided by fire from Carrigaloe across the Lee Channel on Great Island. Fire from buildings here directed at the National Army landing force smacked into buildings in Passage West, especially those on higher ground. Here are impacts in Passage from that fire. /3
The National Army responded to the IRA engaging them from across the river channel by peppering the buildings on the opposite side with rifle and machine-gun bullets. The buildings in Carrigaloe on Great Island still bear the evidence of that response. /4
The National Army soon drove the small number of IRA defenders of Passage West out of the town towards Cork. Today many of the locations photographed at the time by W.D. Hogan (now in @NLIreland) are instantly recognisable when comparing them to the modern landscape. /5
The IRA retreat from Passage was far from the end of the fighting. In order to halt the National Army advance to Cork City, road and rail bridges were blown. The damage to the road bridge can still be seen at Brendan Barry Murphy Park in Rochestown, traceable in later repairs. /6
The 9 August saw the focus of the fighting shift to Rochestown, and it was the bloodiest day of the battle. The Capuchin Friary there had visits from IRA defenders during the night of the 8-9, some receiving absolution before the heavy engagement they knew was coming. /7
Holding buildings and hedgelines around Rochestown, the IRA were engaged by both National Army infantry and artillery, in the shape of an 18 Pounder Field Gun (positioned near the Friary). Among the buildings damaged was Old Court House, where a shell pierced the wall. /8
Pushed out from Rochestown proper, the epicentre of the fighting shifted to around the modern Garryduff Sports Centre, where National Army troops sought to push through strong IRA positions centred on machine-guns set up on field boundaries, including this one in Moneygurney. /9
The home of Dr James Lynch at Garryduff came under intense IRA fire, aimed at National Army troops in and around it, who quickly began to fall victim to the bullets. The home itself became an impromptu dressing station as the family sheltered within. /10
In some of heaviest fighting seen in the Civil War, the National Army troops- many WW1 veterans- had to push up this hill through the fields and into a storm of machine-gun fire, causing many casualties. For some, it must have felt like being back on the Western Front. /11
Near the top of the hill, close to where three National Army soldiers were cut down, a lone gate still bears testimony to the savage fighting. Known locally as the "Battlefield Gate", it retains a number of bullet-holes created during the 9 August 1922 fighting. /12
Numbers finally began to tell, and the IRA were forced back. Not all left. A "last stand" at Cronin's Cottage cost the lives of two IRA defenders, including the well-liked Scot Ian "Scottie" MacKenzie Kennedy. The Cronins were later photographed outside their devastated home. /13
The fighting continued for a third day, as the National Army pushed into Douglas village. But ultimately the IRA were forced to withdraw, the City of Cork fell, and the fighting moved west. Less than two weeks later, Michael Collins would lose his life at Béal na Bláth. /14
We have created a map of many of the archaeological features associated with the first two days fighting in the Battle of Cork (below). You can check it out in more detail at the Landscapes of Revolution page dedicated to it here: landscapesofrevolution.com/projects/battl… /15
You can also read more about the archaeology of the Battle for Cork in the @RTE & @UCC hosted piece, "Bullet Holes & Battlefields: The Archaeology of the Battle for Cork" (and thanks to @heleneokeeffe for the invitation to contribute!) rte.ie/history/conven… /16
There is a also a piece Professor Joanna Brück of @UCDArchaeology and I wrote on the archaeology of the battle for @DGannon2016 & @FFearghal's excellent @RIAdawson book "Ireland 1922: Independence, Partition, Civil War" ria.ie/ireland-1922-i…. /17
The analysis on which the work was based was undertaken by Professor Brück and I together with Dr John Borgonovo and @niallmurray1, both of @UCCHistory. You can find out more about the archaeological traces of Ireland's revolutionary past at landscapesofrevolution.com /18 🧵ends.
And I should add, the work of the Landscapes of Revolution Project is continuing under the excellent guiding hand of @AbartaGuides - you can explore their current project on the Tipperary IRA Map here: landscapesofrevolution.com/tipperary-ira-… (🧵really ends now, I promise 😀)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Damian Shiels

Damian Shiels Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @irishacw

Apr 12, 2021
The Irish and the start of the American Civil War-A Short Thread. The conflict began today in 1861, when Confederates opened fire on Fort Sumter, Charleston Harbor, South Carolina. Within the Fort's walls, there were more Irish-born than American-born soldiers. 1/9 #IrishDiaspora
Within the Fort, Captain Abner Doubleday is regarded as the man who gave the command to return fire- the first U.S. shot of the war. Galwegian Private James Gibbons (below) may well have served that gun. Years later he would claim to be the man who physically fired that shot. 2/9
The Confederates had opened fire due to the imminent arrival at Fort Sumter of provisioning U.S. vessels. Many of those ship crews were also Irish-born. Dubliner Stephen Rowan held a key role during the operation, as Commander of the sloop-of-war USS Pawnee. 3/9
Read 9 tweets
Sep 30, 2020
The taoiseach: “iconic and historic locations such as this should be preserved or at a minimum incorporated into any new developments” But successive govts have not acted to identify & map these sites so they can be considered in planning. Thread /1 irishtimes.com/news/ireland/i…
The damage and destruction of revolutionary sites is wholesale around the country. For a small number of them (not many), a public outcry has occurred, but almost always late in the planning process (e.g. Moore St/O'Rahilly home). Very few have any significant protection. /2
Our legislation is extremely limited- we refuse to consider post 1700AD sites archaeologically, making it hard to protect them as historic landscapes. The protected structure mechanism works only in certain circumstances, and is also a limited form or protection. Fundamentally /3
Read 13 tweets
Sep 3, 2020
We have to try and start to resist the temptation to place new memorials and "tidy up" already memorialised revolutionary sites for the centenary when there hasn't been landscape archaeological assessments. Aside from other issues, we have no clue about any damage being done.
Having been banging on about if for years it's a bit exasperating to see additional memorialisation is still the unquestioned mainstay of remembrance. We need some funding guidelines at Council level. It would be great to see @HeritageHubIRE develop best practice guidelines.
Memorialisation has its place, but when as a State we are not prepared to place any protection on these sites, or even require that we understand them as landscapes, we have to try and be extra careful about the potential unintended damage we can cause them with new memorials.
Read 4 tweets
Jul 29, 2020
An urgent appeal re Vinegar Hill. Planning permission is being sought for a major development that will have an irreversible and catastrophic impact on the 1798 battlefield site. Details here. Time is short, but anyone who can should seek to lodge objections this week. Please RT Image
We have recently lost one portion of the battlefield in the vicinty of Green Hill, but this development will be even more detrimental. Located on the site of the former golf course, on 21 June 1798 it was within the United Irishmen's lines and is part of the core battlefield area
For those familiar with Vinegar Hill, if granted permission, the development (a nursing home and major residential estate) will be sited below the current battlefield carpark, forever impacting the visual setting of the Monument. Its detrimental impact can't be overstated.
Read 4 tweets
Jul 13, 2020
The New York City Draft Riots began #OTD in 1863. The Irish dominated among the rioters, and African Americans were particularly targeted and murdered. The Irish American noted: "wherever a colored person was seen, he was hooted, pelted, or badly beaten; and one even hanged." 1/8 Image
Among the buildings singled out by the rioters during those tumultous days was the Colored Orphan Asylum, which was set ablaze (above image). The New York Irish American Weekly gave their accounting of the week's events here: irishamericancivilwar.com/2013/07/18/150… 2/8
To my mind, class conflict was the main driver behind the Riots, and is also central to understanding why Irish Americans viewed African Americans as they did. I explore some of the reasons behind Irish racial attitudes here: irishamericancivilwar.com/2013/01/04/to-… 3/8
Read 8 tweets
Jun 20, 2020
I'm writing about late American Civil War economic enlistees. Every time I do so I find myself discomforted by how groups such as substitutes still tend to be characterised in much of the literature. Unreliable, untrustworthy and somehow "lesser" than early war volunteers. 1/7
Aside from the problems that privileging early war volunteers as somehow being "better men" creates, the reality is that the majority of eligible white men in the U.S. chose not to serve during the Civil War. These late war recruits were willing to do what most were not. 2/7
They are woefully understudied, but immigrants (and Irish Americans) appear disproportionately represented among their number. Somehow, this is often cast as a negative, as if it provides evidence of a lesser commitment to Union. But again, most men chose not to serve at all. 3/7
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(