Mark Hertling Profile picture
Sep 5 16 tweets 5 min read
While it's not on the news, I'm watching the current fight in Kherson (and the renewed fight in the Donbas).

The "Kherson pocket" (a smaller version of the WWII "Falaise Pocket" I mentioned a few weeks ago) is not a large "counteroffensive," but it is interesting. 1/16🧵
What follows are maps, descriptions of terrain, locations of tactical battles, and their relative potential significance.

Without battlefield intel, I don't know details of what General Zaluzhnyi or Col-Gen Shaptala see, but these are my thoughts.2/

nytimes.com/2022/08/17/wor…
1st, some geographical reminders about Kherson (in light green).
-It's both a city & an Oblast (like a province)
-The Oblast is about the size of Maryland, the city is about 1/2 the size of Baltimore.
-The wide Dnipro River dissects the Oblast and runs to the Black Sea. 3/
The main M14 motorway runs from Rostov (in Russia), thru Mykolayiv & Odesa, into Moldova

It's a key logistics route (or, in Army talk, LOC or Line of Communication)

East is Zaporizhzhya, west is Mykolays'ka, to the South is Crimea.

Kherson is central & critical to S fight. 4/
A few weeks ago, UA started "shaping operations." I won't go into a doctrinal definition, but that means countering the enemies ability to affect ur maneuver.

UA used LONG & SHORT range artillery strikes, SOF, small unit teams, resistance/territorials.5/
voanews.com/a/ukraine-tell…
When the enemy (RU) is on the defensive & trying to secure ground, UA can strike at the time & place of their choosing. That's the advantage of the offense.

Having precision weapons (HIMARS) & good Special Operating Forces (SOF) contributes to that. 6/
greydynamics.com/ukrainian-spec…
Not only do these actions destroy (and shape) the RU forces so they are more vulnerable to attack, they also lower RU morale by killing a lot of RU soldiers & destroying equipment.

All that contributes to UKR - even with a smaller force - having greater freedom of maneuver. 7/
So as a commander, what would I do with that small force?

Same thing I would do with artillery: Target key enemy elements. Attack those that are the most vulnerable.

Shifting to the Kherson as the main attack was brilliant for many reasons. 8/
After successfully defending in the Donbas against repeated unsuccessful RU attacks, UA began shifting forces to Kherson when they saw an opportunity.

That opportunity was a large RU force in Kherson, with a river at their back & limited supply lines. 9/
Poor RU leadership pushed many BTGs over the Dnipro because Putin wanted Kherson City, Mykolayiv, and eventually Odesa.

But on the M14, there are only 2 Bridges across the Dnipro. Destroy those bridges...and logistics & a trapped force becomes a RU problem. 10/
In the last few days, UA has used HIMARs to "drop" the bridges, while also attacking RU forces

I won't draw military arrows or objectives, but reports indicate UA has been involved in intense fighting in Vysokopillya, Arkhangelske & Potemkine. (boxes on the map) 11/
There are also indications RU troops are falling back to the Beryslav Bridgehead (see box area on map) as part of a "refit" & "reconsolidate" operation.

Once there, it'll be hard for them to get back across the VERY WIDE river to escape (Note only 2 Bridges in Kherson). 12/
UA is targeting key RU w/ precision weapons, confusing a RU force that already has very low morale and poor leadership, with a relatively small combined arms (tanks, infantry, artillery, engineers, logistics, etc) force.

All while RU has depleted BTG w/ little supplies. 13/
So while there is the potential for a lot of RU prisoners in this significant battle in the next few weeks, there's more...

There are early reports in the Donbas that UA forces have launched an attack over the Severski Donets River and seized the town of Ozerne (see below) 14/
While a relatively smaller victory, this action by UA in the Donbas is *after* the RU pulled forces to head south, again showing offensive spirit by Ukraine. 15/
Because I've been asked in the last few days "how's it going in Ukraine?" I thought these few tactical observations might show:
-the slow pace of what we should expect in coming weeks
-the offensive spirit & skill of the UA
-the quandary RU finds itself in 16/16

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Mark Hertling

Mark Hertling Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @MarkHertling

Sep 6
Reports indicate Zelenskyy will announce tonight (Ukraine time) that UA is executing operations in Kharkiv Oblast.

This confirms RU inability to maneuver forces between theater locations & within their force's defensive "stance" to counter Ukrainian offensive actions.

Why? 1/
As noted from the start of the RU illegal invasion, intel indicated RU had aligned a force estimated in size of 190,000 troops around UKR's ~1400 mile border, with a plan of attack along 9 main axes.

A large part of that force was in the north & it was decimated. 2/ Image
In phase 2 (starting in April), RU shifted their northern forces to the eastern Donbas to try to achiever more limited objectives.

Remember, there was a shoddy attempt to "regenerate" the forces for that second offensive...they rushed it, and UA kept up the pressure. 3/ Image
Read 10 tweets
Sep 2
An attention-grabbing headline DOESN'T tell the story.

cnn.com/2022/08/31/pol…

@CNN's @EllieCKaufman reports accurate information, but the headline -with one small picture- implies West Point (my alma mater) is displaying a plaque to the KKK outside an academic building. 1/5
Several other media outlets have done the same.

In reading this article, Ellie does a good job in telling of the "triptych" artwork that tells "the history of the United States in bronze relief" w/ 3 panels each 11x5 feet.

Here's what the ENTIRE piece of art looks like: 2/
Artist Laura Fraser (1889–1966) was an American sculptor commissioned to design the panels.

She wanted to create a piece depicting “historical incidents or persons” while "documenting both tragedy & triumph in our nation’s history." The KKK was part of the tragedy. 3/
Read 5 tweets
Aug 31
In 2011, a Sikh recruit approached his basic training commander asking for an exception to Army policy to allow him to serve with religious accommodation.

The @usarmy did so. His name is @kamaljeetkhalsi
& today he is a reserve LTC, surgeon & member of a @potus commission. 1/
He made a strong argument, stood up for his religious & cultural beliefs, & made sacrifices. He was awarded a Bronze Star in Afghanistan while saving many lives. 2/
He’s also helped other Sikhs join our @USArmy, and several have graduated from West Point.
Read 4 tweets
Aug 23
It's 6 PM here on the east coast, but it's 0100 in the morning in Kyiv. It is already Ukraine's Independence Day.

There's predictions this will be a tough day for our friends, as Russia hates independence - freedom & sovereignty - when it concerns great nations. 1/8
Putin threatens more death from the skies - from Russian rockets, missiles, whatever is left - and promises to reign these devices on civilians.

They threaten strikes on Kyiv's Khreshchatyk Street, the one stretching from European SQ through the Maidan to Bessarabska SQ. 2/
.@StateDept is telling US citizens to seek safety because Russian rockets aren't precise & Kyiv is likely a target. That's prudent.

So today, I've been thinking more about Ukraine...Ukrainian soldiers, seeing Ukraine's culture... during my last few years in the Army. 3/
Read 8 tweets
Aug 20
Informally engaging w/ MBA students & healthcare professionals over the last few days, I often hear "what's going on in Ukraine."

Here's a summary 🧵 of what has happened in the last 6 months, what's happening now, & some things I'm watching. 1/21
Russia’s ground forces have proven to be poorly led, ill-trained & with low morale, increasingly & significantly attritted in personnel & equipment (some sources now indicating that when they went into this fight in Feb most units were understrength), unable to regenerate. 2/
RU lacked the ability to execute combined arms operations (CAO’s), defined as combining infantry, tanks, fires (arty or air), engineers (for river crossings, demining operations, etc), aviation, intel, & logistics to seize, occupy, & defend land areas or secure ground. 3/
Read 21 tweets
Aug 17
This 25 tweet 🧵by my Australian friend MG (ret) Mick Ryan @WarintheFuture is succinct, descriptive of campaign planning & operational art, and a phenomenal discussion of Ukraine's potential plans in the south.

Hope Mick doesn't mind, but I'll add a few additional comments. 1/
Like Mick, I also attended a campaign course, @us_sams.

Affectionately called the "book a day club," as we were required to read (& apply) history, military art, doctrine, theory.

Best military course, ever. 2/
MG Ryan describes what campaign planners consider.

-Political guidance & strategy
-Friendly & Enemy Capabilities
-Constraints & restraints
-Will
-Tactics & Operational Design (sequencing battles to achieve strategic endstates) 3/mwi.usma.edu/developing-a-c…
Read 21 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(